ConwayLife.com - A community for Conway's Game of Life and related cellular automata
Home  •  LifeWiki  •  Forums  •  Download Golly

Geminoid Challenge

For discussion of specific patterns or specific families of patterns, both newly-discovered and well-known.

Re: Geminoid Challenge

Postby dvgrn » October 21st, 2013, 4:25 pm

Here's a minor update to the replicator body: the following is four copies of a replicator's memory loop, construction arm, and one-time switching circuitry -- 117 still lifes to construct in all. The only non-Spartan items in the pattern -- the integral signs with boat-bits -- are not built by the construction arm directly, but instead are created by triggering a slow-salvo seed at the end of the construction cycle.

x = 10432, y = 11176, rule = LifeHistory
323.2A$323.2A9$338.2A$338.2A7$89.2D$90.D$90.D.D$91.2D225.2A$319.A$
106.2D208.3A$106.2D208.A2$97.2D$89.2D6.2D$89.2D5.2D$96.2D175.A$273.3A
$102.D173.A$101.D.D47.2A122.2A$94.2D6.2D47.2A127.2A$95.D74.2A108.2A$
92.3D74.A2.A99.A34.A$92.D77.2A4.2D92.3A32.3A$142.2A32.2D91.A34.A$142.
2A125.2A33.2A20.2A$259.2A15.2A39.2A7.2A$260.A15.2A40.A$260.A.A55.A.A$
261.2A4.2A44.2A4.2A$146.2A118.A2.A44.A20.2A$146.2A119.2A45.A.A18.A$
279.2A34.2A16.A.A$279.2A52.2A6$189.A$188.A.A166.4B$188.2A75.2A3.2A32.
2C52.4B$266.A3.A20.2A11.2C53.4B$263.3A5.3A18.A67.4B$263.A9.A15.3A35.
2A32.2B4D$177.2A110.A37.2A2.2A29.BD2A2D$177.2A141.2A9.A.A29.DADAD$
181.A138.2A11.A29.3DA2D$180.A.A150.2A30.D2AD$180.A.A182.4D$181.A$315.
A$314.A.A$189.2A111.2A10.A.A$189.2A112.A11.A$168.2A130.3A$168.2A130.A
$194.2A$194.2A3$166.2A114.2A$166.2A114.2A4$278.2A$278.2A$316.2A$316.
2A2$169.2A$169.2A3$289.2A$289.2A2$238.2A$238.2A10.2A$250.2A2$294.2A$
225.2A11.2A54.2A$216.2A6.A2.A10.2A$216.A7.A2.A$214.A.A8.2A$214.2A16$
267.2A3.2A$267.A.A2.2A$268.A8$109.A$107.3A93.2E$106.A96.2E$106.2A8.2A
$116.A38.A$114.A.A38.3A$114.2A12.2A28.A$127.A.A27.2A34.A$127.A11.A53.
3A$104.2A20.2A9.3A56.A14.A$104.2A30.A58.2A12.3A$136.2A10.2A58.A$85.2A
17.2D42.A59.2A$85.2A17.2D40.A.A$146.2A$123.2A82.2A$123.2A63.2A17.2A$
104.2D82.2A63.2A$104.2D147.A.A$249.2A3.A$249.2A3$157.2A32.2A$132.2A
23.2A11.2A20.A$133.A36.A18.3A$130.3A38.3A15.A82.2A$95.2A33.A42.A20.2A
76.2A$95.2A22.2A74.A$119.A.A70.3A$121.A70.A73.2A$121.2A143.2A5$185.2A
$186.A$186.A.A15.2A$187.2A15.2A12$205.2A$205.A.A$207.A$207.2A2$8.2A8.
A$8.2A6.3A$15.A$2A13.2A$.A$.A.A$2.2A$7.2C186.2A$7.2C2D184.2A$9.2D3$4.
A$3.A.A$3.2A201.2A$185.2A19.A$186.A17.A.A$12.2A172.A.A15.2A$12.2A173.
2A4.A$192.A.A$192.A.A$193.A10.2A$204.A.A$206.A$206.2A$191.2A$192.A$
189.3A$189.A46$323.2A$323.2A9$338.2A$338.2A7$89.2A$90.A$90.A.A$91.2A
225.2A$319.A$106.2A208.3A$106.2A208.A2$97.2C$89.2A6.2C$89.2A5.2D$96.
2D175.A$273.3A$102.A173.A$101.A.A47.2A122.2A$94.2A6.2A47.2A127.2A$95.
A74.2A108.2A$92.3A74.A2.A99.A34.A$92.A77.2A4.2D92.3A32.3A$142.2A32.2D
91.A34.A$142.2A125.2A33.2A20.2A$259.2A15.2A39.2A7.2A$260.A15.2A40.A$
260.A.A55.A.A$261.2A4.2A44.2A4.2A$146.2A118.A2.A44.A20.2A$146.2A119.
2A45.A.A18.A$279.2A34.2A16.A.A$279.2A52.2A6$189.A$188.A.A$188.2A75.2A
3.2A32.2C$266.A3.A20.2A11.2C$263.3A5.3A18.A$263.A9.A15.3A35.2A$177.2A
110.A37.2A2.2A$177.2A141.2A9.A.A$181.A138.2A11.A$180.A.A150.2A$180.A.
A$181.A$315.A$314.A.A$189.2A111.2A10.A.A$189.2A112.A11.A$168.2A130.3A
$168.2A130.A$194.2A$194.2A3$166.2A114.2A$166.2A114.2A4$278.2A$278.2A$
316.2A$316.2A2$169.2A$169.2A3$289.2A$289.2A2$238.2A$238.2A10.2A$250.
2A2$294.2A$225.2A11.2A54.2A$216.2A6.A2.A10.2A$216.A7.A2.A$214.A.A8.2A
$214.2A16$267.2A3.2A$267.A.A2.2A$268.A8$109.A$107.3A93.2E$106.A96.2E$
106.2A8.2A$116.A38.A$114.A.A38.3A$114.2A12.2A28.A$127.A.A27.2A34.A$
127.A11.A53.3A$104.2A20.2A9.3A56.A14.A$104.2A30.A58.2A12.3A$136.2A10.
2A58.A$85.2A17.2D42.A59.2A$85.2A17.2D40.A.A$146.2A$123.2A82.2A$123.2A
63.2A17.2A$104.2D82.2A63.2A$104.2D147.A.A$249.2A3.A$249.2A3$157.2A32.
2A$132.2A23.2A11.2A20.A$133.A36.A18.3A$130.3A38.3A15.A82.2A$95.2A33.A
42.A20.2A76.2A$95.2A22.2A74.A$119.A.A70.3A$121.A70.A73.2A$121.2A143.
2A5$185.2A$186.A$186.A.A15.2A$187.2A15.2A12$205.2A$205.A.A$207.A$207.
2A2$8.2A8.A$8.2A6.3A$15.A$2A13.2A$.A$.A.A$2.2A$7.2C186.2A$7.2C2D184.
2A$9.2D3$4.A$3.A.A$3.2A201.2A$185.2A19.A$186.A17.A.A$12.2A172.A.A15.
2A$12.2A173.2A4.A$192.A.A$192.A.A$193.A10.2A$204.A.A$206.A$206.2A$
191.2A$192.A$189.3A$189.A46$323.2A$323.2A9$338.2A$338.2A7$89.2A$90.A$
90.A.A$91.2A225.2A$319.A$106.2A208.3A$106.2A208.A2$97.2C$89.2A6.2C$
89.2A5.2D$96.2D175.A$273.3A$102.A173.A$101.A.A47.2A122.2A$94.2A6.2A
47.2A127.2A$95.A74.2A108.2A$92.3A74.A2.A99.A34.A$92.A77.2A4.2D92.3A
32.3A$142.2A32.2D91.A34.A$142.2A125.2A33.2A20.2A$259.2A15.2A39.2A7.2A
$260.A15.2A40.A$260.A.A55.A.A$261.2A4.2A44.2A4.2A$146.2A118.A2.A44.A
20.2A$146.2A119.2A45.A.A18.A$279.2A34.2A16.A.A$279.2A52.2A6$189.A$
188.A.A$188.2A75.2A3.2A32.2C$266.A3.A20.2A11.2C$263.3A5.3A18.A$263.A
9.A15.3A35.2A$177.2A110.A37.2A2.2A$177.2A141.2A9.A.A$181.A138.2A11.A$
180.A.A150.2A$180.A.A$181.A$315.A$314.A.A$189.2A111.2A10.A.A$189.2A
112.A11.A$168.2A130.3A$168.2A130.A$194.2A$194.2A3$166.2A114.2A$166.2A
114.2A4$278.2A$278.2A$316.2A$316.2A2$169.2A$169.2A3$289.2A$289.2A2$
238.2A$238.2A10.2A$250.2A2$294.2A$225.2A11.2A54.2A$216.2A6.A2.A10.2A$
216.A7.A2.A$214.A.A8.2A$214.2A16$267.2A3.2A$267.A.A2.2A$268.A8$109.A$
107.3A93.2E$106.A96.2E$106.2A8.2A$116.A38.A$114.A.A38.3A$114.2A12.2A
28.A$127.A.A27.2A34.A$127.A11.A53.3A$104.2A20.2A9.3A56.A14.A$104.2A
30.A58.2A12.3A$136.2A10.2A58.A$85.2A17.2D42.A59.2A$85.2A17.2D40.A.A$
146.2A$123.2A82.2A$123.2A63.2A17.2A$104.2D82.2A63.2A$104.2D147.A.A$
249.2A3.A$249.2A3$157.2A32.2A$132.2A23.2A11.2A20.A$133.A36.A18.3A$
130.3A38.3A15.A82.2A$95.2A33.A42.A20.2A76.2A$95.2A22.2A74.A$119.A.A
70.3A$121.A70.A73.2A$121.2A143.2A5$185.2A$186.A$186.A.A15.2A$187.2A
15.2A12$205.2A$205.A.A$207.A$207.2A2$8.2A8.A$8.2A6.3A$15.A$2A13.2A$.A
$.A.A$2.2A$7.2C186.2A$7.2C2D184.2A$9.2D3$4.A$3.A.A$3.2A201.2A$185.2A
19.A$186.A17.A.A$12.2A172.A.A15.2A$12.2A173.2A4.A$192.A.A$192.A.A$
193.A10.2A$204.A.A$206.A$206.2A$191.2A$192.A$189.3A$189.A46$323.2A$
323.2A9$338.2A$338.2A7$89.2A$90.A$90.A.A$91.2A225.2A$319.A$106.2A208.
3A$106.2A208.A2$97.2C$89.2A6.2C$89.2A5.2D$96.2D175.A$273.3A$102.A173.
A$101.A.A47.2A122.2A$94.2A6.2A47.2A127.2A$95.A74.2A108.2A$92.3A74.A2.
A99.A34.A$92.A77.2A4.2D92.3A32.3A$142.2A32.2D91.A34.A$142.2A125.2A33.
2A20.2A$259.2A15.2A39.2A7.2A$260.A15.2A40.A$260.A.A55.A.A$261.2A4.2A
44.2A4.2A$146.2A118.A2.A44.A20.2A$146.2A119.2A45.A.A18.A$279.2A34.2A
16.A.A$279.2A52.2A6$189.A$188.A.A$188.2A75.2A3.2A32.2C$266.A3.A20.2A
11.2C$263.3A5.3A18.A$263.A9.A15.3A35.2A$177.2A110.A37.2A2.2A$177.2A
141.2A9.A.A$181.A138.2A11.A$180.A.A150.2A$180.A.A$181.A$315.A$314.A.A
$189.2A111.2A10.A.A$189.2A112.A11.A$168.2A130.3A$168.2A130.A$194.2A$
194.2A3$166.2A114.2A$166.2A114.2A4$278.2A$278.2A$316.2A$316.2A2$169.
2A$169.2A3$289.2A$289.2A2$238.2A$238.2A10.2A$250.2A2$294.2A$225.2A11.
2A54.2A$216.2A6.A2.A10.2A$216.A7.A2.A$214.A.A8.2A$214.2A16$267.2A3.2A
$267.A.A2.2A$268.A8$109.A$107.3A93.2E$106.A96.2E$106.2A8.2A$116.A38.A
$114.A.A38.3A$114.2A12.2A28.A$127.A.A27.2A34.A$127.A11.A53.3A$104.2A
20.2A9.3A56.A14.A$104.2A30.A58.2A12.3A$136.2A10.2A58.A$85.2A17.2D42.A
59.2A$85.2A17.2D40.A.A$146.2A$123.2A82.2A$123.2A63.2A17.2A$104.2D82.
2A63.2A$104.2D147.A.A$249.2A3.A$249.2A3$157.2A32.2A$132.2A23.2A11.2A
20.A$133.A36.A18.3A$130.3A38.3A15.A82.2A$95.2A33.A42.A20.2A76.2A$95.
2A22.2A74.A$119.A.A70.3A$121.A70.A73.2A$121.2A143.2A5$185.2A$186.A$
186.A.A15.2A$187.2A15.2A12$205.2A$205.A.A$207.A$207.2A2$8.2A8.A$8.2A
6.3A$15.A$2A13.2A$.A$.A.A$2.2A$7.2C186.2A$7.2C2D184.2A$9.2D3$4.A$3.A.
A$3.2A201.2A$185.2A19.A$186.A17.A.A$12.2A172.A.A15.2A$12.2A173.2A4.A$
192.A.A$192.A.A$193.A10.2A$204.A.A$206.A$206.2A$191.2A$192.A$189.3A$
189.A64$89.2A$90.A$90.A.A$91.2A2$106.2A$106.2A2$97.2C$89.2A6.2C$89.2A
5.2D$96.2D2$102.A$101.A.A$94.2A6.2A$95.A74.2A$92.3A74.A2.A$92.A77.2A
6$174.2A.2A$173.A.A.A.A$174.A4.A$179.A.A$180.2A5$148.2A$148.A$149.3A$
152.A$151.2A2$151.2A$150.A.A$151.A31$342.A$341.2A$341.A.A142$486.A$
485.2A$485.A.A142$630.A$629.2A$629.A.A176$806.3A$806.A$807.A556$1366.
A$1365.2A$1365.A.A142$1510.A$1509.2A$1509.A.A144$1654.3A$1654.A$1655.
A143$1800.2A$1799.2A$1801.A587$2390.A$2389.2A$2389.A.A142$2534.A$
2533.2A$2533.A.A143$2678.2A$2677.2A$2679.A169$2848.3A$2848.A$2849.A
562$3414.A$3413.2A$3413.A.A142$3558.A$3557.2A$3557.A.A144$3702.3A$
3702.A$3703.A156$3862.A$3861.2A$3861.A.A574$4438.A$4437.2A$4437.A.A
142$4582.A$4581.2A$4581.A.A143$4725.3A$4725.A$4726.A151$4879.2A$4878.
2A$4880.A580$5462.A$5461.2A$5461.A.A142$5606.A$5605.2A$5605.A.A143$
5751.A$5750.2A$5750.A.A160$5911.3A$5911.A$5912.A571$6486.A$6485.2A$
6485.A.A142$6630.A$6629.2A$6629.A.A143$6773.3A$6773.A$6774.A156$6932.
2A$6932.A.A$6932.A575$7510.A$7509.2A$7509.A.A142$7654.A$7653.2A$7653.
A.A143$7798.2A$7798.A.A$7798.A158$7957.3A$7957.A$7958.A573$8534.A$
8533.2A$8533.A.A142$8678.A$8677.2A$8677.A.A143$8821.3A$8821.A$8822.A
160$8984.2A$8983.2A$8985.A354$10362.2A$10362.2A5$10358.2A$10358.2A
207$10392.A31.2A$10390.3A31.2A$10389.A$9557.2A830.2A$9557.A.A814.2A$
9557.A817.A$10375.A.A$10376.2A10.A$10387.A.A$10387.A.A$10388.A4.2A$
10376.2A15.A.A$10375.A.A17.A$10375.A19.2A$10374.2A2$10399.2A$10399.A$
10397.A.A$10397.2A$10385.2A$10385.2A9$10373.2A$10374.A$10374.A.A$
10375.2A9$10362.2A$10362.2A2$10376.2A15.2A$10376.2A15.A.A$10395.A$
10358.2A35.2A$10358.2A5$10389.A$10387.3A$10386.A$10386.2A19.2A$10392.
A15.A$10390.3A15.A.A$10389.A19.2A$10389.2A3$10430.2A$10430.2A2$10392.
2A$10373.2A17.2A$10373.2A3$10372.2A$10373.A$10370.3A12.2A$10370.A14.A
16.2A$10386.3A14.A$10388.A11.3A$10400.A$10420.2A$10420.2A67$9701.2A$
9701.A.A$9701.A107$10392.A31.2A$10390.3A31.2A$10389.A$10389.2A$10374.
2A$10375.A$10375.A.A$10376.2A10.A$10387.A.A$10387.A.A$10388.A4.2A$
10376.2A15.A.A$10375.A.A17.A$10375.A19.2A$10374.2A2$10399.2A$10399.A$
10397.A.A$10397.2A$10385.2A$10385.2A9$10373.2A$10374.A$10374.A.A$
10375.2A9$10362.2A$10362.2A2$10376.2A15.2A$10376.2A15.A.A$10395.A$
10358.2A35.2A$10358.2A4$9864.A$9863.2A524.A$9863.A.A521.3A$10386.A$
10386.2A19.2A$10392.A15.A$10390.3A15.A.A$10389.A19.2A$10389.2A3$
10430.2A$10430.2A2$10392.2A$10373.2A17.2A$10373.2A3$10372.2A$10373.A$
10370.3A12.2A$10370.A14.A16.2A$10386.3A14.A$10388.A11.3A$10400.A$
10420.2A$10420.2A133$10023.2A$10023.A.A$10023.A41$10392.A31.2A$10390.
3A31.2A$10389.A$10389.2A$10374.2A$10375.A$10375.A.A$10376.2A10.A$
10387.A.A$10387.A.A$10388.A4.2A$10376.2A15.A.A$10375.A.A17.A$10375.A
19.2A$10374.2A2$10399.2A$10399.A$10397.A.A$10397.2A$10385.2A$10385.2A
9$10373.2A$10374.A$10374.A.A$10375.2A9$10362.2A$10362.2A2$10376.2A15.
2A$10376.2A15.A.A$10395.A$10358.2A35.2A$10358.2A5$10389.A$10387.3A$
10386.A$10386.2A19.2A$10392.A15.A$10390.3A15.A.A$10389.A19.2A$10389.
2A3$10430.2A$10430.2A2$10392.2A$10373.2A17.2A$10373.2A3$10372.2A$
10373.A$10370.3A12.2A$10370.A14.A16.2A$10386.3A14.A$10388.A11.3A$
10400.A$10420.2A$10420.2A176$10392.A31.2A$10390.3A31.2A$10389.A$
10389.2A$10374.2A$10375.A$10375.A.A$10376.2A10.A$10387.A.A$10387.A.A$
10388.A4.2A$10376.2A15.A.A$10375.A.A17.A$10375.A19.2A$10374.2A2$
10399.2A$10399.A$10397.A.A$10397.2A$10385.2A$10385.2A9$10373.2A$
10374.A$10374.A.A$10375.2A12$10376.2A15.2A$10376.2A15.A.A$10395.A$
10395.2A6$10389.A$10387.3A$10386.A$10386.2A19.2A$10392.A15.A$10390.3A
15.A.A$10389.A19.2A$10389.2A3$10430.2A$10430.2A2$10392.2A$10373.2A17.
2A$10373.2A3$10372.2A$10373.A$10370.3A12.2A$10370.A14.A16.2A$10386.3A
14.A$10388.A11.3A$10400.A$10420.2A$10420.2A!

The main improvement from the last version is that the construction elbow now starts and ends the construction cycle in exactly the same position -- so each child replicator is an exact (though slightly phase-shifted) copy of the original. It turned out to be easier to store the elbow as a beehive between construction cycles, instead of as a block, just because there aren't many good elbow operations where the very last glider pair emits a 90-degree glider _and_ puts the elbow block back on the correct lane with no leftover debris. There are thousands of other possible solutions, though -- this is just the first one that worked.

Running the pattern demonstrates how the data on the tape will be interpreted as glider pairs fed directly to the construction arm. Once construction is complete, the next cycle of the memory loop will copy all the gliders to the newly created child loop.

When all gliders are copied, the output path is shut off again, and the parent replicator returns to its exact starting state. However, a key part of the child replicator is a pair of integral signs catching glider pairs from the parent's construction arm, so the parent can no longer reach its construction elbow. The child replicator picks up where the parent left off and constructs a grandchild replicator, which in turn suppresses the child's construction arm -- and so on.

-- Now that the replicator body is just about as small as I can figure out how to make it, I'm getting back to work on the slow-salvo compiler for arbitrary Spartan constellations. Have had a few breakthroughs recently, so things are looking good so far!
dvgrn
Moderator
 
Posts: 3988
Joined: May 17th, 2009, 11:00 pm
Location: Madison, WI

Re: Geminoid Challenge

Postby codeholic » October 22nd, 2013, 3:43 am

dvgrn wrote:When all gliders are copied, the output path is shut off again, and the parent replicator returns to its exact starting state. However, a key part of the child replicator is a pair of integral signs catching glider pairs from the parent's construction arm, so the parent can no longer reach its construction elbow.

Though this solution is undoubtedly elegant, it seems to me a little bit cheaty, that parent's and child's bounding boxes intersect :)

dvgrn wrote:Now that the replicator body is just about as small as I can figure out how to make it, I'm getting back to work on the slow-salvo compiler for arbitrary Spartan constellations.

Restoring an eater from 10 still lifes still seems wasteful to me. I'm pretty sure there is a 4 SLic seed plus probably one or two still lifes for a one-time glider turner.
Ivan Fomichev
User avatar
codeholic
Moderator
 
Posts: 1138
Joined: September 13th, 2011, 8:23 am
Location: Hamburg, Germany

Re: Geminoid Challenge

Postby dvgrn » October 22nd, 2013, 12:42 pm

codeholic wrote:Though this solution is undoubtedly elegant, it seems to me a little bit cheaty, that parent's and child's bounding boxes intersect :)

I certainly won't disagree. On the other hand, at least for the moment I'm not about to redesign the replicator so that the parent and child don't overlap...!

It would be fairly easy to come up with a mechanism where a non-destructive test would tell the parent whether a child replicator already exists in the construction location. If the test comes back positive, the parent could disable its own constructor arm, instead of relying on the child pattern to drop those two glider blockers into the construction-arm lanes.

Basically the parent would build a Construction Stopper seed -- two still lifes to block off its construction arm, just the same as the current design. Then it would run the child existence test, which would be a vanish reaction if no child was present, but would send back a return glider if (say) a block was found in the right location. The return glider would trigger the Construction Stopper seeds. If no glider comes back, of course, the parent's next task is to carefully shoot down the Construction Stopper seeds before it begins constructing the child replicator.

-- But someone else can figure out those details if they want to! Here's the definition of "replicator" I'm using, under which my design is definitely a replicator, overlap or no:

A replicator is a pattern P that, after N ticks, produces two or more copies of every live cell in P, at some offset and phase shift. After creation, P1 and P2 must each match P exactly at some time within N ticks -- but these two times T1 and T2 can be nonzero and different from each other.

In this design, N is some big number depending on the size of the full recipe -- say 25M or so. T1=0 (the parent is an exact copy of itself) and T2=277 (the child becomes an exact copy of the parent after a small delay).

I believe this means that a diagonal line of maybe a hundred thousand of these replicators together can be considered to be a single replicator with no phase shift -- T1=T2=0, and N = 25M x 100K. Exact numbers will have to wait until the construction recipes are all done -- but there will definitely be some delay D where R=(some long line of phase-shifted replicators) becomes 2*R at time D, 3*R at 2*D, 4*R at 3*D, etc. [...Yes, there will still be a bounding-box overlap.]

codeholic wrote:Restoring an eater from 10 still lifes still seems wasteful to me. I'm pretty sure there is a 4 SLic seed plus probably one or two still lifes for a one-time glider turner.

Well, I wanted to try using both contributions from last week... Extrementhusiast's 10sL eater seed is nice and clean, and accepts an input glider from the right direction. Dealing with the extra blinker debris in the integral-sign seed turned out to cause some minor synchronization headaches, and it only had about one chance in two of working in the Output Stopper location.

I'd definitely be happy to replace both the integral-sign seeds and the 10sL eater seed with a nice clean 4sL eater seed, though! The ones on the construction arm would still have to have 6hd clearance from their glider lanes. Again, it would be okay if there was a little leftover debris off to the side somewhere, though it would be nice if it was something stable -- and really a clean seed would be nicer.
dvgrn
Moderator
 
Posts: 3988
Joined: May 17th, 2009, 11:00 pm
Location: Madison, WI

Re: Geminoid Challenge

Postby codeholic » October 22nd, 2013, 5:18 pm

A nice definition of "replicator". How do you define "spartan", by the way?
Ivan Fomichev
User avatar
codeholic
Moderator
 
Posts: 1138
Joined: September 13th, 2011, 8:23 am
Location: Hamburg, Germany

Re: Geminoid Challenge

Postby dvgrn » October 22nd, 2013, 7:36 pm

codeholic wrote:A nice definition of "replicator". How do you define "spartan", by the way?

Well, it used to be something like "still life, less than eight ON cells, no aircraft carriers or snakes".

So the standard Spartan collection is mostly block, tub, boat, beehive, loaf, and eater. Haven't really needed the ship, barge, or longship much in constructible Herschel conduits, though the ship is seeing some use now in Guam's shortest new conduit, and they might all come in handy in self-destruct circuitry. The pond turns out to be really useful as a destruction seed, so let's include that too.

Really I'd now be happy to include as Spartan any small stable object that can be constructed in all orientations by, say, a dozen unidirectional P2 slow-salvo gliders or less, starting from a block. See the attached archive of P2 slow recipes up to 8 gliders -- each line is a separate recipe, which you can copy and build with the script in the link below.

I think it may actually be okay to include aircraft carriers as Spartan now -- they show up in almost a hundred recipes, much more often than snakes for example. Just have to check that some of them are close enough to the edge of their construction envelopes to be workable in a slow-salvo context.

Most of the UNKNOWN patterns are just loaves that show up a little too close to blinkers -- there are only a few hundred UNKNOWNs in all, so I didn't bother to improve the object-recognition code to figure them out. There may be some good constructions in there somewhere.

EDIT: Hmm, there are indeed some snakes among the unknowns, and a few other things I should have included in my object definitions. Use build-EO-lane-slow-salvo.py to explore these recipes:

snake block:E-9 E-15 E-29 E-23 O-35 O-23 O-7 O-11
snake block:E-9 E-1 E13 E7 O19 O7 O-9 O-5
snake:E-9 E11 E-7 E13 E-3 O7 E7 O9
snake:E-9 E-1 E-17 O15 O-31 E-17 O5 O-13
shillelagh block:E-9 E-1 O13 E15 E19 E13 E37
shillelagh block:E-9 E-9 E21 O11 E-5 O-1 O-21 E-43
shillelagh block:E-9 E7 E-9 E-41 E-59 E-21 E-55
shillelagh block:E-9 E-23 E-7 E25 E43 E5 E39
shillelagh block:E-9 E-7 E-37 O-27 E-11 O-15 O5 E27
shillelagh:E-9 E-15 O17 O-23 O-49 E-47 O-3 E-17
shillelagh:E-9 E-7 E-37 O-27 E-11 O-15 O5 O25
shillelagh:E-9 E-1 O-33 O7 O33 E31 O-13 E1
boattieboatB block:E-9 E-13 E-13 E-1 O13 O15 E5
longbargeA block:E-9 E-1 O19 O3 O-1 O-3 O-17 O-25
longshipA block:E-9 E-15 O3 E-5 O-5 O-13 O-9
longshipA block:E-9 E-1 O-19 E-11 O-11 E5
integral block:E-9 E-27 E-17 E1 E13 E13 E-21 O-37
integral block:E-9 E-9 O-17 O-19 O-25 E7 E-13 O3
integral block:E-9 E11 E1 E-17 E-29 E-29 E5 O21
elevener tub:E-9 E-15 O3 O-31 E-5 O-25 O-23
canoeA1:E-9 E-23 E1 E17 E-7 E15
canoeA2:E-9 E7 E-17 E-33 E-9 E-31
hatA:E-9 E-29 E-5 E41 E-9 O33 E-33 O-7
hatB:E-9 E-17 O-1 E-15 E37 E41 O-21 O9
bipondB:E-9 E-7 E-27 O-3 E11 E-13 E-15
boatwtail block:E-9 E7 E-17 E-9 O-3 E-13 O-25
boatwtail block:E-9 E-23 E1 E-7 O-13 E-3 O9
tubwtailC2 block:E-9 E7 E-23 O-5 E23 E1 E3 O27
tubwtailC2 block:E-9 E-23 E7 O-37 E-9 E-31 E-29 O-5
tubwtailC2 block:E-9 E-9 O-19 O-7 E21 E-1 E1 E31
tubwtailC2:E-9 E-9 O-19 O-7 E21 E-1 E1 E23
tubwtailB1 block:E-9 E-9 O19 E-9 E-19 E13 E11 O-13
tubwtailB1 block:E-9 E7 E-23 O21 E-7 E15 E13 O-11
tubwtailB1 block:E-9 E-23 E7 O-11 E-39 E-17 E-19 O-43
tubwtailB1 block:E-9 E-7 O3 O-9 E-37 E-15 E-17 O-41

(the last two recipes' output locations are different by one cell)

Boat-tie-boat seems to be the only one of these objects that might be allowed as Better Than Spartan (because I have decent recipes for all orientations). But there's no particular need to add it unless, say, it turns out to be really disproportionately useful for self-destruct circuitry. Many of these recipes drop their objects in the middle of the construction envelope, so they can't easily be constructed in front of other still lifes. That makes them definitely not Spartan, but maybe in special cases a few of them will be of some use anyway.

I'm generally collecting "object block:" recipes instead of just "object:" recipes because that's the easy way to handle unidirectional slow salvo constructions. Each recipe starts with a block in the correct target location, and produces the object you want to construct -- plus another block, which you can then hit with standard block-move recipes to get to the next target location and construct the next object.
Attachments
blockmove2-stable-sorted.zip
object recipes up to 8 slow gliders, compiled from the P2 block-move table (so not a complete list!)
(1.43 MiB) Downloaded 537 times
dvgrn
Moderator
 
Posts: 3988
Joined: May 17th, 2009, 11:00 pm
Location: Madison, WI

Re: Geminoid Challenge

Postby dvgrn » October 23rd, 2013, 5:47 am

codeholic wrote:With 3 seeds, you can make [the integral+blinker seed] purely blockic:

Turns out it's possible to do better than three blocks, from the point of view of construction anyway. Here's a seed made up of a block and two beehives, which can be constructed from a single block with 7 P2-slow gliders:

#C integral blinker:E-9 E11 E1 E-17 E-29 E-29 E5
x = 325, y = 323, rule = LifeHistory
2E$2E19$15.3A$15.A$16.A48$75.3A$75.A$76.A48$120.3A$120.A$121.A48$161.
3A$161.A$162.A48$205.3A$205.A$206.A48$255.3A$255.A$256.A48$322.3A$
322.A$323.A!

This showed up during a review of unknown intermediate-target objects in the P2 block-move table. Same clearance (12hd) as the three-block versions, I think -- well, the honeyfarm stage of the construction drops down to 10hd, but I think that's still workable.

There may be a way to get one of those three-block constellations from a single block with less than 7 gliders, but I haven't seen it -- and probably won't look very hard, though I am thinking of building a library of all the block -> N-block P2-slow recipes at some point.
dvgrn
Moderator
 
Posts: 3988
Joined: May 17th, 2009, 11:00 pm
Location: Madison, WI

Re: Geminoid Challenge

Postby knightlife » October 23rd, 2013, 7:18 am

Not currently needed for replicator, but possibly useful for Geminoid knightship, etc.
A remarkable two block (half LOM) solution and two near misses with single block seed.
The two block seed is placed quite a distance away from the semi-snark and still does the job:
x = 257, y = 42, rule = B3/S23
130bo124bo$18b2o111bo122bo$14b2o2b2o109b3o122b3o$14b2o3$32b2o8bo$32b2o
6b3o$39bo$24b2o13b2o$25bo$25bobo$26b2o$31b2o$31b2o4$28bo$27bobo$27b2o
2$139b2o7bo80b2o7bo$36b2o101b2o5b3o80b2o5b3o$36b2o107bo89bo$130b2o13b
2o73b2o13b2o$131bo89bo$131bobo87bobo$132b2o88b2o$137b2o88b2o$125b2o10b
2o76b2o10b2o$125b2o88b2o3$134bo89bo$133bobo87bobo$133b2o88b2o3$3o139b
2o88b2o$2bo139b2o88b2o$bo!

Note there are two slightly different semi-snarks in the above, as mentioned earlier in the thread.
knightlife
 
Posts: 564
Joined: May 31st, 2009, 12:08 am

Re: Geminoid Challenge

Postby dvgrn » October 23rd, 2013, 9:20 am

knightlife wrote:Not currently needed for replicator, but possibly useful for Geminoid knightship, etc.
A remarkable two block (half LOM) solution and two near misses with single block seed.
The two block seed is placed quite a distance away from the semi-snark and still does the job...

Looks good! For anyone interested in the construction details, the "near misses" are actually just what is needed for cases where the replicator unit has to destroy and rebuild itself with a small offset -- say (1,1) or (-2,-1). The semi-Snark will need to be almost completely destroyed so that an overlapping copy can be rebuilt. But with a single construction arm, it's important to always leave a target to aim at. By default the "hand" is a block.

For a (1,1), or (-2,-1) offset, the general plan would be for the replicator unit to build a ridiculously long diagonal string of blocks, or other one-time turner still lifes, pointed at each reflector. Each string is a "freeze-dried" slow-salvo seed that quickly destroys and reconstitutes that reflector in the new location. The seed is triggered at the end of each construction recipe, when no gliders are passing through that reflector.

The (1,1) version is a variant of an old idea about finding two small constellations that, when hit by a single glider, each happened to congeal back into a slightly displaced version of themselves, plus a 180-degree glider on just the right lane to trigger the other constellation. The odds always seemed to be heavily against the existence of this kind of adjustable-speed spaceship... but a Geminoid can do the trick without too much trouble (except it needs more gliders bouncing back and forth, by five or six orders of magnitude!)
dvgrn
Moderator
 
Posts: 3988
Joined: May 17th, 2009, 11:00 pm
Location: Madison, WI

Re: Geminoid Challenge

Postby codeholic » October 24th, 2013, 4:12 pm

I've got some preliminary results from a gencols search I'm running.

A pretty cheap seed of an eater in the eating position, but the clearance is only 1hd (but probably it doesn't matter unless you use it for blocking construction lanes):
x = 71, y = 58, rule = LifeHistory
69.A$68.A$68.3A33$22.2C$22.2C2$15.C$14.C.C$14.2C13.A$28.A$28.3A2$26.
2D$17.2C8.D$17.2C5.3D$24.D8$.2A$A.A$2.A!

A seed of an eater in a boat-bit catching position with 4hd clearance:
x = 69, y = 88, rule = LifeHistory
67.A$66.A$66.3A3$62.A$61.A$61.3A40$20.A$19.A$19.3A3$18.2D$18.D$19.3D$
21.D$22.C$21.C.C$22.C$31.2C$31.2C7$26.2C$26.2C17$.2A$A.A$2.A!
Ivan Fomichev
User avatar
codeholic
Moderator
 
Posts: 1138
Joined: September 13th, 2011, 8:23 am
Location: Hamburg, Germany

Re: Geminoid Challenge

Postby codeholic » October 24th, 2013, 4:38 pm

Another eating eater with 2hd clearance and different orientation of the triggering glider:
x = 64, y = 95, rule = LifeHistory
.A$2.A$3A48$51.A$52.A$50.3A9$60.2D$52.C7.D$51.C.C7.3D$52.2C9.D6$61.2C
$61.2C3$62.2C$61.C.C$62.C16$34.2A$33.A.A$35.A!
Ivan Fomichev
User avatar
codeholic
Moderator
 
Posts: 1138
Joined: September 13th, 2011, 8:23 am
Location: Hamburg, Germany

Re: Geminoid Challenge

Postby dvgrn » October 24th, 2013, 9:18 pm

codeholic wrote:Another eating eater with 2hd clearance and different orientation of the triggering glider...

This one looks very nice -- I'll substitute it in at least for the output-stopping eater, when I get to that stage of the construction recipe.

The eater seeds with 1hd clearance would be maybe a little too close to use on the construction lanes. But then again, the closest block in the 1hd could very well be constructed directly by the elbow on its final pass through, just before the seeds are triggered; without that block, the 1hd would become a very reasonable 6hd. As I mentioned previously, I'm pretty sure 2hd will turn out to be wide enough clearance in an emergency, if that's the best option that shows up.

It's probably time to slightly modify the challenge here. Technically the thing to minimize is the cost of construction of the entire combined seed for eaters on both sides of the construction-arm lanes --including the branch that removes the output-suppressing eater. The construction and removal should all be triggered by a single glider from the construction elbow. This combined seed, and then the trigger glider, will be the last thing that each replicator unit builds. Construction should start, let's say, from an arbitrary single block on each side.

Really just counting total still lifes is probably a good enough measure for now. It may be hard to beat an optimized version of the solution that's in there now, though: it's already only 11 still lifes and can easily be cut to 8, or maybe less, by replacing non-Blockic splitters and turners. I previously posted a variant of the integral seed that can be constructed with just a six-glider P2 slow salvo.

However, I would definitely be happy to use a few extra still lifes or construction gliders if I could replace those integral boat-bit catchers, plus the extra blinkers, with something that really eats gliders instead of catching them! The recipe in the current replicator proof-of-concept was chosen only after discarding almost a dozen other options that _almost_ worked, but failed for one subtle reason or another -- mostly as a result of a blinker ending up in the wrong phase.
dvgrn
Moderator
 
Posts: 3988
Joined: May 17th, 2009, 11:00 pm
Location: Madison, WI

Re: Geminoid Challenge

Postby Extrementhusiast » October 24th, 2013, 11:53 pm

How much would an infinity-clearance eater help?
x = 131, y = 84, rule = LifeHistory
7.2A$7.2A4.2A$13.2A$.2A$A.A$.A2$13.2A$13.2A2$129.A$128.A.A$128.A.A$
116.2A11.A$116.2A3$120.2A$120.2A48$58.2A$58.2A6$56.2A$56.2A4$64.3A$
64.A$65.A2$59.2A$59.2A!
I Like My Heisenburps! (and others)
User avatar
Extrementhusiast
 
Posts: 1644
Joined: June 16th, 2009, 11:24 pm
Location: USA

Re: Geminoid Challenge

Postby dvgrn » October 25th, 2013, 7:18 am

Extrementhusiast wrote:How much would an infinity-clearance eater help?

Thanks! This is definitely good to have as an option, but maybe a little too expensive to use for a construction-lane stopper in the prototype replicator. For no particularly good reason, I'm trying to keep the number of still lifes to a minimum; there are 86 in the current replicator body, and that can easily be brought down to 66 or so... but at a higher cost in temporary still lifes. It now looks like it might be possible to bring the total number of still lifes that need to be constructed -- temporary and permanent -- down to about 100.

The current prototype already has an 11-still-life seed that successfully (though awkwardly) blocks both lanes, and also clears the COPY output path. I think that will probably be reduced to 8 still lifes or so in the next few days. Making eaters by crashing *WSSes together takes about 10 still lifes per eater, plus a few more for glider splitters to trigger both seeds and shoot down the COPY output-stopping glider... so I probably won't use the extra still lifes for an Infinity Clearance Glider Stopper in this case. No doubt it will come in handy at some point, though!

In other news, the replicator's construction recipe is starting to take shape. I'm over halfway through building the SE reflector --

#C 157-glider P2 slow salvo constructs 12 still lifes (and hand block)
x = 23423, y = 23572, rule = B3/S23
2bo$obo$b2o144$152bo$150bobo$151b2o156$300bobo$301b2o$301bo143$450bobo
$451b2o$451bo150$600bobo$601b2o$601bo136$752bo$750bobo$751b2o156$902bo
$900bobo$901b2o152$1052bo$1050bobo$1051b2o127$1202bo$1200bobo$1201b2o
156$1350bobo$1351b2o$1351bo145$1502bo$1500bobo$1501b2o167$1650bobo$
1651b2o$1651bo142$1802bo$1800bobo$1801b2o142$1952bo$1950bobo$1951b2o
157$2102bo$2100bobo$2101b2o136$2252bo$2250bobo$2251b2o155$2402bo$2400b
obo$2401b2o146$2550bobo$2551b2o$2551bo145$2702bo$2700bobo$2701b2o137$
2850bobo$2851b2o$2851bo158$3002bo$3000bobo$3001b2o151$3152bo$3150bobo$
3151b2o136$3302bo$3300bobo$3301b2o156$3450bobo$3451b2o$3451bo145$3602b
o$3600bobo$3601b2o167$3750bobo$3751b2o$3751bo142$3902bo$3900bobo$3901b
2o142$4052bo$4050bobo$4051b2o157$4202bo$4200bobo$4201b2o136$4352bo$
4350bobo$4351b2o155$4502bo$4500bobo$4501b2o172$4652bo$4650bobo$4651b2o
148$4802bo$4800bobo$4801b2o149$4950bobo$4951b2o$4951bo144$5102bo$5100b
obo$5101b2o137$5252bo$5250bobo$5251b2o159$5402bo$5400bobo$5401b2o148$
5552bo$5550bobo$5551b2o150$5702bo$5700bobo$5701b2o162$5850bobo$5851b2o
$5851bo142$6000bobo$6001b2o$6001bo160$6152bo$6150bobo$6151b2o148$6302b
o$6300bobo$6301b2o140$6452bo$6450bobo$6451b2o140$6602bo$6600bobo$6601b
2o133$6750bobo$6751b2o$6751bo146$6900bobo$6901b2o$6901bo161$7052bo$
7050bobo$7051b2o137$7202bo$7200bobo$7201b2o150$7352bo$7350bobo$7351b2o
155$7502bo$7500bobo$7501b2o158$7652bo$7650bobo$7651b2o141$7802bo$7800b
obo$7801b2o159$7952bo$7950bobo$7951b2o140$8102bo$8100bobo$8101b2o137$
8252bo$8250bobo$8251b2o159$8400bobo$8401b2o$8401bo166$8552bo$8550bobo$
8551b2o145$8702bo$8700bobo$8701b2o141$8852bo$8850bobo$8851b2o146$9002b
o$9000bobo$9001b2o106$9152bo$9150bobo$9151b2o149$9302bo$9300bobo$9301b
2o157$9450bobo$9451b2o$9451bo144$9602bo$9600bobo$9601b2o141$9752bo$
9750bobo$9751b2o149$9902bo$9900bobo$9901b2o145$10050bobo$10051b2o$
10051bo146$10202bo$10200bobo$10201b2o155$10352bo$10350bobo$10351b2o
151$10502bo$10500bobo$10501b2o165$10650bobo$10651b2o$10651bo151$10802b
o$10800bobo$10801b2o162$10950bobo$10951b2o$10951bo137$11102bo$11100bob
o$11101b2o147$11252bo$11250bobo$11251b2o149$11402bo$11400bobo$11401b2o
129$11550bobo$11551b2o$11551bo165$11700bobo$11701b2o$11701bo130$11850b
obo$11851b2o$11851bo158$12002bo$12000bobo$12001b2o153$12152bo$12150bob
o$12151b2o156$12302bo$12300bobo$12301b2o116$12452bo$12450bobo$12451b2o
148$12602bo$12600bobo$12601b2o144$12750bobo$12751b2o$12751bo158$12902b
o$12900bobo$12901b2o154$13050bobo$13051b2o$13051bo147$13202bo$13200bob
o$13201b2o131$13352bo$13350bobo$13351b2o155$13502bo$13500bobo$13501b2o
159$13650bobo$13651b2o$13651bo151$13802bo$13800bobo$13801b2o159$13950b
obo$13951b2o$13951bo138$14102bo$14100bobo$14101b2o145$14252bo$14250bob
o$14251b2o150$14402bo$14400bobo$14401b2o135$14550bobo$14551b2o$14551bo
164$14702bo$14700bobo$14701b2o135$14850bobo$14851b2o$14851bo148$15002b
o$15000bobo$15001b2o148$15152bo$15150bobo$15151b2o150$15302bo$15300bob
o$15301b2o121$15452bo$15450bobo$15451b2o157$15600bobo$15601b2o$15601bo
138$15750bobo$15751b2o$15751bo155$15900bobo$15901b2o$15901bo145$16050b
obo$16051b2o$16051bo149$16202bo$16200bobo$16201b2o149$16352bo$16350bob
o$16351b2o182$16500bobo$16501b2o$16501bo131$16652bo$16650bobo$16651b2o
154$16802bo$16800bobo$16801b2o139$16952bo$16950bobo$16951b2o151$17102b
o$17100bobo$17101b2o152$17252bo$17250bobo$17251b2o151$17402bo$17400bob
o$17401b2o138$17552bo$17550bobo$17551b2o138$17702bo$17700bobo$17701b2o
149$17852bo$17850bobo$17851b2o135$18002bo$18000bobo$18001b2o156$18152b
o$18150bobo$18151b2o151$18302bo$18300bobo$18301b2o153$18450bobo$18451b
2o$18451bo175$18602bo$18600bobo$18601b2o152$18750bobo$18751b2o$18751bo
144$18900bobo$18901b2o$18901bo171$19052bo$19050bobo$19051b2o151$19200b
obo$19201b2o$19201bo135$19352bo$19350bobo$19351b2o157$19502bo$19500bob
o$19501b2o152$19652bo$19650bobo$19651b2o144$19800bobo$19801b2o$19801bo
175$19952bo$19950bobo$19951b2o152$20100bobo$20101b2o$20101bo144$20250b
obo$20251b2o$20251bo171$20402bo$20400bobo$20401b2o151$20550bobo$20551b
2o$20551bo135$20702bo$20700bobo$20701b2o157$20852bo$20850bobo$20851b2o
152$21002bo$21000bobo$21001b2o144$21150bobo$21151b2o$21151bo175$21302b
o$21300bobo$21301b2o152$21450bobo$21451b2o$21451bo144$21600bobo$21601b
2o$21601bo171$21752bo$21750bobo$21751b2o151$21900bobo$21901b2o$21901bo
135$22052bo$22050bobo$22051b2o157$22202bo$22200bobo$22201b2o152$22352b
o$22350bobo$22351b2o141$22500bobo$22501b2o$22501bo178$22650bobo$22651b
2o$22651bo138$22800bobo$22801b2o$22801bo156$22950bobo$22951b2o$22951bo
140$23100bobo$23101b2o$23101bo150$23252bo$23250bobo$23251b2o147$23402b
o$23400bobo$23401b2o23$23421b2o$23421b2o!

The compiler script is still a long way from being operational, but the actual construction library is really solid now. I'm putting together the first reflector semi-manually, just to get a better idea of how exactly the compiler can try to optimize the construction recipe without getting swamped by the size of the search space.
dvgrn
Moderator
 
Posts: 3988
Joined: May 17th, 2009, 11:00 pm
Location: Madison, WI

Re: Geminoid Challenge

Postby codeholic » October 25th, 2013, 11:57 am

So far the best clearance of 4hd for an eating eater:
x = 93, y = 91, rule = LifeHistory
17.2C$16.C2.C$17.C.C$18.C7$29.2C$29.2C3$29.C$28.C.C$27.C2.C$28.2C7$
25.2D$26.D$26.D.D$27.2D$30.2A$30.A.A$30.A4$.2A$A.A$2.A52$90.2A$90.A.A
$90.A!

It also produces a big spark outside of the reaction center that can be used to trigger further reactions.
Ivan Fomichev
User avatar
codeholic
Moderator
 
Posts: 1138
Joined: September 13th, 2011, 8:23 am
Location: Hamburg, Germany

Re: Geminoid Challenge

Postby Freywa » October 25th, 2013, 10:09 pm

dvgrn wrote:In other news, the replicator's construction recipe is starting to take shape.

The words make it feel like a von Neumann universal constructor. Is it similar in design to Langton's loops?
User avatar
Freywa
 
Posts: 274
Joined: June 23rd, 2011, 3:20 am
Location: Singapore

Re: Geminoid Challenge

Postby dvgrn » October 26th, 2013, 12:23 am

codeholic wrote:So far the best clearance of 4hd for an eating eater...
It also produces a big spark outside of the reaction center that can be used to trigger further reactions.

Nice! Kind of shoots itself in the foot at the end there, doesn't it? The glider it produces while stabilizing the upper spark then conveniently goes on to suppress another part of the pattern.

I think 4hd is probably safe enough, since these can be the very last objects constructed. The block that the trigger glider hits first actually has 11hd clearance, so I think it's just a matter of picking elbow operations carefully. I'll build this eater seed into the next draft of the replicator prototype, at least for the construction-arm lanes, unless something better shows up in the meantime.

That means my next priority will be sorting loaf recipes to make sure I have everything I need. With over thirteen thousand different recipes (see attached) I suspect something workable will turn up! These are just intermediate targets up to eight p2 slow gliders from Paul Chapman's latest Glue block-move table. So it's not actually an exhaustive list, but it's as close as I need to get for the moment...

EDIT 10/26/2013: Replaced the attachment to fix a parity problem with some final gliders
Attachments
loafblock-sorted.zip
13,583 ways to move a block and create a loaf
(74.98 KiB) Downloaded 437 times
Last edited by dvgrn on October 26th, 2013, 8:07 am, edited 2 times in total.
Reason: fixed a minor bug in the data
dvgrn
Moderator
 
Posts: 3988
Joined: May 17th, 2009, 11:00 pm
Location: Madison, WI

Re: Geminoid Challenge

Postby dvgrn » October 26th, 2013, 3:32 pm

Freywa wrote:
dvgrn wrote:In other news, the replicator's construction recipe is starting to take shape.

The words make it feel like a von Neumann universal constructor.

That's the general idea. Conway's Life was originally investigated as a possible simplification of von Neumann's design. B3/S23's two states are a lot fewer than 29, so it was really interesting that universal constructors could be supported in such a "simple" (!?!) rule.

B3/S23 UCs were proved to exist over forty years ago, but the first working model wasn't put together until 2003. Even then, it was such a pain to program the prototype that nobody ever actually tried to make it construct anything more interesting than an oblique line of eaters... all the way up to 2010, when Andrew Wade's Gemini spaceship suddenly appeared, along with some key new ideas about efficient storage and decoding of construction recipes.

Freywa wrote:Is it similar in design to Langton's loops?

Sort of, but not really -- a diamond-shaped Geminoid/replicator is a possibility, and that might look a little bit like a Langton's Loop design. But it wouldn't work by extending a pseudopod and gradually bending it into a new loop -- it would build the whole new loop, then copy the data to it.

It's technically possible to do the pseudopod-extending trick in B3/S23 now, but that would involve designing an exact-timing glider-pair reflector for 9hd or 10hd construction arms. Many other smaller lane spacings would also work, actually, it doesn't really matter -- could even be done with 0hd, just one lane!

But reflectors for such closely-spaced pairs of lanes will either be very big, or very slow to recover, or more likely both. That means that just one 90-degree turn component in a Langton's-Loop-style replicator or spaceship design would almost certainly contain more still lifes than the entire circuitry of the current replicator.

So for now, I'm sticking with the design I have! With a lot of help, mostly from Paul Chapman, I've gotten a universal constructor cut down to just 43 Spartan still lifes, plus or minus a few. There's only one input stream of data, instead of the twelve in the Gemini spaceship -- so it's suddenly pretty easy to feed the constructor a recipe for itself, and shunt a copy of the recipe data into the newly-constructed copy.
dvgrn
Moderator
 
Posts: 3988
Joined: May 17th, 2009, 11:00 pm
Location: Madison, WI

Re: Geminoid Challenge

Postby dvgrn » October 26th, 2013, 6:12 pm

dvgrn wrote:
codeholic wrote:So far the best clearance of 4hd for an eating eater...

Nice!... I think 4hd is probably safe enough, since these can be the very last objects constructed. The block that the trigger glider hits first actually has 11hd clearance, so I think it's just a matter of picking elbow operations carefully.

Here's a 19-slow-glider construction of the new 4hd eater seed -- definitely better than I expected:

# loafA block m4,-6:E9 E1 E-17 E-1 O-13 O11 E-11
# m10,-6:E9 E-7 E27 E21 O17
# loafB block m,:E9 E-7 E21 E13 O-11 O3 E21
# Combining the above --
# eater seed:E9 E1 E-17 E-1 O-13 O11 E-11 E29 E13 E47 E41 O37 E43 E59 E31 E39 O63 O49 E31
# eater seed triggered:
#:E9 E1 E-17 E-1 O-13 O11 E-11 E29 E13 E47 E41 O37 E43 E59 E31 E39 O63 O49 E31 E19
x = 2651, y = 2642, rule = LifeHistory
2E$2E2$37.D$36.D$18.2D3.2D11.3D$18.2D2.D2.D$23.D.D8.2D$24.D10.D$32.3D
$32.D6$9.2D$8.D2.D$8.D.D$9.D$24.3A$24.A$25.A11$42.3D$42.D$43.D135$
170.3A$170.A$171.A148$311.3A$311.A$312.A148$469.3A$469.A$470.A148$
614.2A$613.2A$615.A148$776.2A$775.2A$777.A148$914.3A$914.A$915.A111$
1048.2A$1048.A.A$1048.A156$1198.2A$1198.A.A$1198.A131$1348.2A$1348.A.
A$1348.A151$1498.2A$1498.A.A$1498.A150$1649.A$1648.2A$1648.A.A77$
1730.2A$1730.A.A$1730.A140$1880.2A$1880.A.A$1880.A162$2030.2A$2030.A.
A$2030.A144$2180.2A$2180.A.A$2180.A136$2331.A$2330.2A$2330.A.A155$
2481.A$2480.2A$2480.A.A157$2630.2A$2630.A.A$2630.A23$2648.3A$2648.A$
2649.A!

There may well be a way to string together two of those loaf recipes directly to get as low as 14-16 gliders. It's mostly a matter of finding a lucky pair of recipes where the location of the first output hand block happens to be the same as the location of the second input hand block, so no block-move step is needed in the middle.

The only problem is that most loaf recipes have intermediate targets that drift down into the 4hd danger zone. I may already have picked some of the best available options in that department. -- Anyway, for this project I've tried to adopt the rule that if I can't immediately see how to improve efficiency by a factor of two or more, well, it's good enough: time to move on!

So we're down to ten still lifes in the Construction Stopper seed, and maybe fifty P2-slow gliders to build them:

x = 48, y = 35, rule = LifeHistory
12.2A$11.A2.A$11.A.A$12.A2$46.A$45.A.A$44.A2.A$31.A13.2A$32.A$2A28.3A
$2A3$.A21.D$A.A18.3D$A2.A16.D10.A$.2A17.2D8.A.A$30.A2.A2.2A$31.2A3.2A
5$4.2D$4.D$2.D.D$2.2D25.A$28.A.A$20.2A6.2A$20.2A3$25.2A$25.2A!

Actually it might be better to build and detonate each eater seed separately, and leave an extra construction-arm elbow beyond the eaters in a location matching the replicator's initial elbow. Then the last glider output just has to be a glider-destroying one, same as in the diagonal Geminoid's sample recipe.
dvgrn
Moderator
 
Posts: 3988
Joined: May 17th, 2009, 11:00 pm
Location: Madison, WI

Re: Geminoid Challenge

Postby codeholic » October 26th, 2013, 6:45 pm

If I knew, that you were going to work on the construction stopper seed, I would post these earlier:
x = 369, y = 239, rule = LifeHistory
87.F99.F99.F$7.3D3.D7.D87.2D2.D7.D85.4D2.D7.D85.4D2.D7.D$10.D2.D7.D
65.F20.D.D2.D7.D65.F19.D5.D7.D65.F22.D2.D7.D$8.2D3.3D3.3D85.D2.D2.3D
3.3D85.3D3.3D3.3D87.D3.3D3.3D$10.D2.D2.D.D2.D65.F19.4D2.D2.D.D2.D65.F
22.D2.D2.D.D2.D65.F20.D4.D2.D.D2.D$7.D2.D2.D2.D.D2.D88.D2.D2.D.D2.D
85.D2.D2.D2.D.D2.D86.D4.D2.D.D2.D$8.2D3.D2.D2.3D65.F22.D2.D2.D2.3D65.
F20.2D3.D2.D2.3D65.F20.D4.D2.D2.3D2$87.F99.F99.F$104.A$87.F14.A.A82.F
99.F$103.2A$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F2$
87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F79.A$366.A$87.F
99.F99.F78.3A2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F
$198.A$87.F99.F11.A87.F$197.3A$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F
99.F2$87.F99.F99.F$325.2C$87.F99.F99.F30.C5.C.C$144.A172.C.C5.C$87.F
54.A.A42.F99.F28.C2.C$143.2A172.2C$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F
99.F99.F35.C13.A$322.C.C11.A$87.F99.F99.F34.C.C11.3A$313.2A8.C$87.F
99.F99.F24.A.A$314.A$87.F68.2D29.F99.F$147.C8.D.D$87.F48.C9.C.C9.D28.
F99.F$135.C.C7.C2.C9.2D169.2D$87.F47.C2.C7.2C39.F99.F42.D$136.2C189.
3D$87.F99.F99.F39.D2$87.F99.F99.F$148.2C$87.F60.2C37.F99.F2$87.F99.F
99.F2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F$39.2D$39.D47.F99.F99.F$37.D.D$37.2D
6.C41.F99.F77.2C20.F$34.2A8.C.C217.C2.C$33.A.A8.C2.C39.F99.F77.C.C19.
F$35.A9.2C219.C3.2C$87.F99.F82.2C15.F$248.A$87.F99.F61.A37.F$247.3A$
44.C42.F99.F99.F$43.C.C78.2A$44.2C41.F35.A.A61.F99.F$125.A$87.F99.F
99.F$269.C$87.F99.F67.2D11.C.C16.F$35.2A5.C212.D11.C2.C$34.A.A4.C.C
43.F99.F68.3D9.2C17.F$36.A4.C.C214.D$42.C44.F99.F66.2A31.F$253.A.A$
87.F99.F67.A31.F2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F
99.F2$87.F99.F99.F$4.2A$3.A.A81.F99.F99.F$5.A$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F
99.F2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F2$.A85.F
99.F99.F$2.A$3A84.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F
2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.
F2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F
99.F2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F2$52.2C33.F99.F99.F$52.2C$87.F99.F99.
F2$57.2C28.F99.F99.F$51.C4.C2.C$41.A8.C.C3.C2.C27.F99.F99.F$42.A6.C2.
C4.2C$40.3A7.2C35.F99.F99.F2$44.2D41.F99.F99.F$44.D.D$46.D40.F99.F99.
F$46.2D$87.F99.F99.F$33.2A$32.A.A52.F99.F99.F$34.A$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F
99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.
F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F2$
87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F
2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.
F2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F
99.F2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F2$87.F99.F99.F!

Among others, there is another block+2 loaves seed with 5hd clearance, and a hive+loaf+boat seed with 7hd (!) clearance. And the gencols search is still running with only about 1/8 of it done.
Ivan Fomichev
User avatar
codeholic
Moderator
 
Posts: 1138
Joined: September 13th, 2011, 8:23 am
Location: Hamburg, Germany

Re: Geminoid Challenge

Postby dvgrn » October 26th, 2013, 10:07 pm

codeholic wrote:If I knew, that you were going to work on the construction stopper seed, I would post these earlier... Among others, there is another block+2 loaves seed with 5hd clearance, and a hive+loaf+boat seed with 7hd (!) clearance. And the gencols search is still running with only about 1/8 of it done.

These look good! But not necessarily better than the 4hd one with a 19-glider construction. The 4hd seed was especially cheap because it was possible to construct the block+loaf cluster as a single object.

When I have a spare half-hour I'll write a little search script to see if any of these new seed still lifes can likewise be constructed two or three at a time. Just have to have the script look through the outcomes from the recipes in the truncated P2 block-move list and flag any lucky matching constellations.

Your 7hd-clearance eater insertion will certainly come in handy in one-time circuitry at some point! I didn't find anything like that in the eater recipes I've collected. It will be interesting to see if gencols turns up anything with even higher clearance. Eater seeds can be built with any required amount of clearance, no limit, but they sure seem to get expensive fast...!

For the replication project, I'm not sure it will be easy to improve on the 19-glider recipe. Basically 4hd clearance is as just about good as 5hd in this case. Even if it were necessary to move an elbow back and forth past the seed after construction (which it won't be) the +7 and -3 elbow ops have narrow enough reaction envelopes to get past the 4hd-clearance loaf... and that's true even if there's a similar 4hd-clearance obstruction on the other side, which is not a requirement either.

So I might not switch to a higher-clearance seed unless it's also cheaper to construct. Another advantage of the 4hd seed is that the trigger glider can come directly from the construction arm. Saves building an extra one-time turner to send a glider in from the side.

-- While I'm wishing, it will be great if some version of the eater seed can also directly generate a 180-degree output glider... with the correct color to let it trigger the same reaction on the other side. That would certainly make it worth rebuilding the stopper circuit again!
dvgrn
Moderator
 
Posts: 3988
Joined: May 17th, 2009, 11:00 pm
Location: Madison, WI

Re: Geminoid Challenge

Postby codeholic » October 27th, 2013, 2:43 am

dvgrn wrote:-- While I'm wishing, it will be great if some version of the eater seed can also directly generate a 180-degree output glider... with the correct color to let it trigger the same reaction on the other side. That would certainly make it worth rebuilding the stopper circuit again!

I'll try to find such a seed. But it would need another time-consuming gencols search. Does the color really matter? Because one could probably sort out a suitable reaction for the second lane.

EDIT: New record of amazing 12hd clearance:
x = 71, y = 63, rule = LifeHistory
12$47.D$45.3D$44.D$44.2D2$41.2A16.2C$40.A.A16.C.C$42.A17.C3$58.2C5.2C
$57.C2.C4.2C$58.2C10$43.2A$42.A.A$44.A21$.2A$A.A$2.A!

I think I'll suspend this search here and will look for an eater + 1 or 2 gliders seed.
Ivan Fomichev
User avatar
codeholic
Moderator
 
Posts: 1138
Joined: September 13th, 2011, 8:23 am
Location: Hamburg, Germany

Re: Geminoid Challenge

Postby codeholic » October 27th, 2013, 1:38 pm

codeholic wrote:So far the best clearance of 4hd for an eating eater...

Actually that is 5hd. I've miscounted a little bit. Other clearances in the seeds I posted may be also bigger by 1hd.
Ivan Fomichev
User avatar
codeholic
Moderator
 
Posts: 1138
Joined: September 13th, 2011, 8:23 am
Location: Hamburg, Germany

Re: Geminoid Challenge

Postby dvgrn » October 27th, 2013, 1:44 pm

codeholic wrote:
codeholic wrote:So far the best clearance of 4hd for an eating eater...

Actually that is 5hd. I've miscounted a little bit. Other clearances in the seeds I posted may be also bigger by 1hd.

No, you had it right, I think -- that confused me for a while, too. In this particular recipe, the closest loaf has 5hd clearance from the constructed eater -- but the eater stops a lane that extends 1hd closer to the loaf, so the real clearance is only 4hd.

codeholic wrote:Does the color really matter? Because one could probably sort out a suitable reaction for the second lane.

Absolutely right. The second reaction might have to be different anyway, since it doesn't necessarily need a glider output. But I figured I might as well wish for the simplest possible solution, while I was wishing...

I can't think of anything simpler than a color-preserving [EDIT: sorry, looks like I meant "color-changing"...!] 180-degree reflector/eater seed -- with a nice offset, so that the second output glider doesn't crash into the first construction-lane eater. The second glider could be sent straight down to delete the output-blocking eater, with no other one-time circuitry needed at all.

codeholic wrote:EDIT: New record of amazing 11hd clearance...
I think I'll suspend this search here and will look for an eater + 1 or 2 gliders seed.

Yes, might as well save the rest of the full gencols search for some project that actually needs a larger clearance. 11hd is more than enough for any Geminoid one-time eater construction problem that I can think of at the moment.

-- This beehive-boat-block seed looks great! I'll try finding a cheap construction for it with the search script I was talking about, that looks for matches with intermediate targets in the P2 block-move table. Maybe that whole eater-seed constellation will show up in a lucky recipe somewhere... but I'm not holding my breath.

Here's a trial run that I did with the new search script, looking for cheaper constructions of the two-block 180-degree OTT -- those two blocks show up over a thousand times in the block-move table's intermediate targets, with and without lots of other junk:
t2 block+:E9 E23 E7 E-19 E-43
t2 block+:E-9 E7 E-9 E-35 E-59
t1 block++:E9 E9 O5 O21 O9 O5 O-35
t1 block++:E9 E9 O5 O21 O9 O5 O-21
t1 block++:E9 E9 O5 E-7 O33 O13 E35
t1 block++:E9 E9 O27 O25 E15 O3 O31
t2 block++:E9 E9 O17 O-15 E-11 E1 E3
t2 block++:E9 E9 O17 E25 O41 E41 O7
t2 block++:E9 E9 O17 E25 O3 O27 E37
t1 block++:E9 E9 O17 E25 O23 E5 O41
t2 block++:E9 E9 O17 E25 O17 O29 E1
t2 block++:E9 E9 O17 E25 E23 E37 E13
t1 block++:E9 E9 O13 E19 E-9 O-25 O-1
t1 block++:E9 E9 O11 O-7 O-21 E-1 O-5
t2 block++:E9 E9 O11 E-11 O19 O-1 E-41
t2 block++:E9 E9 O-15 O3 O7 O19 E29
t2 block++:E9 E9 O-15 O3 E27 E27 E45
t2 block++:E9 E9 E5 E17 E25 E39 E-35
t2 block++:E9 E9 E5 E17 E25 E39 E-17
t2 block++:E9 E9 E-3 O-5 O-21 O19
t2 block++:E9 E7 O5 O23 O37 E17 O21
t2 block++:E9 E7 O3 E-3 E25 O41 O17
t2 block++:E9 E7 O11 O9 O-5 E31 O41
t2 block++:E9 E7 O11 O7 O7 O31 O11
t1 block++:E9 E7 O-1 E-9 O-1 O-13 E15
t1 block++:E9 E7 O-1 E-9 E-9 O-1 E15
t1 block++:E9 E7 O-1 E-9 E-7 O-1 E15
t1 block++:E9 E7 O-1 E-9 E-7 E-21 E3
t2 block++:E9 E7 E25 O-3 O23 O1
t1 block++:E9 E7 E11 E-1 E-9 E-23 E33
t2 block++:E9 E3 E3 O31 O-5 O13 E25
t1 block++:E9 E3 E-11 E17 E41 E11 O-5
t1 block++:E9 E3 E-11 E17 E41 E11 O-19
t1 block++:E9 E3 E-11 E-9 E1 O-17 O-7
t2 block++:E9 E29 E5 E21 E5 E-21 E-45
t1 block++:E9 E29 E5 E-9 E7 E33 E57
t1 block++:E9 E29 E23 E7 E23 E49 E73
t2 block++:E9 E29 E23 E31 O19 O3 O37
t2 block++:E9 E29 E-21 E-37 E-9 E-25 O-1
t2 block++:E9 E29 E-19 E-19 E-27 O-37 O-19
t2 block++:E9 E27 E9 E-11 O-5 E-5 O-17
t1 block++:E9 E27 E29 E-1 E23 E-27 E-33
t1 block++:E9 E27 E13 E23 O-1 O-43 O31
t2 block++:E9 E23 E7 O-43 O-41 E-43 E-41
t2 block++:E9 E23 E7 O-43 O-41 E-43
t2 block++:E9 E23 E7 O-43 O-33 E-55 E-43
t2 block++:E9 E23 E7 O-39 O-35 O-17 O-43
t1 block++:E9 E23 E7 O-39 E-31 E-25 E5
t2 block++:E9 E23 E7 O-35 E-9 E-15 E-43
t2 block++:E9 E23 E7 O-31 O-33 O-49 O-43
t2 block++:E9 E23 E7 O-27 O-27 E-25 E-43
t2 block++:E9 E23 E7 O-27 E-25 O-9 O-43
t2 block++:E9 E23 E7 O-25 E-15 O-43 O-23
t2 block++:E9 E23 E7 O-23 O-9 E-43 O-43
t2 block++:E9 E23 E7 O-23 E-13 E-7 E-43
t2 block++:E9 E23 E7 O-21 E-33 O-33 E-43
t2 block++:E9 E23 E7 E-9 O-15 O-39 O-43
t2 block++:E9 E23 E7 E-41 O-15 E-45 O-43
t1 block++:E9 E23 E7 E-41 E-47 O-29 E-39
t2 block++:E9 E23 E7 E-39 O-9 E-31 E-43
t2 block++:E9 E23 E7 E-21 O-43 E-5 E-43
t2 block++:E9 E23 E7 E-21 O-43 E-43
t2 block++:E9 E23 E7 E-21 E-27 E-31 E-43
t2 block++:E9 E23 E7 E-15 E-33 E-21 E-43
t2 block++:E9 E23 E7 E-11 O-11 O-43 O-41
t2 block++:E9 E23 E7 E-11 O-11 O-43
t1 block++:E9 E23 E17 E31 E17 E9 E15
t1 block++:E9 E23 E11 E17 O11 O5 E-15
t2 block++:E9 E23 E11 E17 E3 E-29 E-27
t2 block++:E9 E23 E-7 E27 O25 O3
t2 block++:E9 E23 E-11 E-5 O7 O11 O15
t2 block++:E9 E23 E-1 E27 E7 O25 O-1
t2 block++:E9 E15 O35 O25 E-17 E7 E-27
t1 block++:E9 E15 O31 O41 E15 E39 O41
t1 block++:E9 E15 O31 E43 E-1 E-9 E13
t1 block++:E9 E15 O31 E35 E19 O45 E49
t1 block++:E9 E15 O31 E35 E19 O29 O43
t1 block++:E9 E15 O31 E35 E19 O29 O29
t1 block++:E9 E15 O31 E35 E19 E35 O51
t1 block++:E9 E15 O31 E35 E19 E35 O29
t1 block++:E9 E15 O31 E35 E19 E35
t1 block++:E9 E15 O31 E35 E19 E31 O27
t1 block++:E9 E15 O31 E35 E19 E31 E33
t1 block++:E9 E15 O27 O45 O47 O7 O49
t1 block++:E9 E15 O17 E13 O19 E33 O13
t1 block++:E9 E15 O17 E13 E7 O25 E-15
t2 block++:E9 E15 O-17 E29 E29 O21 O-15
t2 block++:E9 E15 O-15 O13 E11 E7 O-9
t2 block++:E9 E15 E33 O39 E7 O-15 O11
t1 block++:E9 E15 E33 E11 O3 O-53 O-23
t1 block++:E9 E15 E33 E11 O3 O-39 O-31
t1 block++:E9 E15 E33 E11 O3 O-39 E-25
t1 block++:E9 E15 E33 E11 O3 O-23 O-31
t1 block++:E9 E15 E33 E11 O3 O-23
t1 block++:E9 E15 E33 E11 O3 E-51 O-47
t1 block++:E9 E15 E33 E11 O3 E-33 O-57
t1 block++:E9 E15 E33 E11 O3 E-33 O-35
t1 block++:E9 E15 E33 E11 O3 E-33
t1 block++:E9 E15 E33 E11 O3 E-31 O-45
t1 block++:E9 E15 E33 E11 O3 E-31 E-51
t1 block++:E9 E15 E33 E11 O3 E-27 O-25
t1 block++:E9 E15 E33 E11 O3 E-27 O-19
t1 block++:E9 E15 E33 E11 O3 E-21 E-31
t1 block++:E9 E15 E29 E35 E15 E31 O-13
t2 block++:E9 E15 E23 O7 O21 E19 O25
t1 block++:E9 E15 E23 O7 O13 O13 O7
t1 block++:E9 E15 E21 E11 E21 O-13 O-7
t2 block++:E9 E15 E15 E35 O13 O19 E31
t2 block++:E9 E15 E15 E35 O13 E29 O17
t1 block++:E9 E15 E15 E35 O13 E29 O17
t1 block++:E9 E15 E15 E3 O41 O3 E9
t1 block++:E9 E15 E11 O45 O5 O31 E61
t1 block++:E9 E15 E11 E23 E5 E19 O49
t2 block++:E9 E15 E-1 E1 O19 O17 O-1
t1 block++:E9 E15 E-1 E-7 O65 O17 E-23
t2 block++:E9 E13 E27 E33 O9 E27 E9
t2 block++:E9 E13 E27 E-1 E-25 E5 O35
t2 block++:E9 E13 E13 O3 E-13 O3 E-5
t2 block++:E9 E13 E13 O-15 O-15 E-9 E27
t2 block++:E9 E13 E13 O-13 E-15 O27 O-13
t2 block++:E9 E13 E13 E35 E7 E-43 O13
t2 block++:E9 E13 E13 E29 E-11 E-35 E-71
t2 block++:E9 E13 E13 E-17 O-13 O-5 O27
t2 block++:E9 E1 O19 O29 E-17 E-7 O-7
t2 block++:E9 E1 O19 E25 O5 O-45 E11
t2 block++:E9 E1 O19 E13 O19 O-5 O23
t1 block++:E9 E1 O19 E13 E-9 E-17 E-1
t2 block++:E9 E1 O19 E13 E-19 O-15 E19
t1 block++:E9 E1 O-19 O-9 E33 E9 E43
t1 block++:E9 E1 O-19 E11 O-9 O-13 E27
t2 block++:E9 E1 O-19 E-9 O27 E29 O45
t2 block++:E9 E1 O-15 E-7 E3 E1 O-7
t2 block++:E9 E1 O-15 E-19 E-3 O-29 O-27
t2 block++:E9 E1 O-15 E-19 E-3 O-29 E-33
t2 block++:E9 E1 O-15 E-19 E-3 O-25
t2 block++:E9 E1 O-15 E-19 E-3 O-15 O-31
t2 block++:E9 E1 O-15 E-19 E-3 O-13 O-27
t2 block++:E9 E1 O-15 E-19 E-3 O-13 O-13
t2 block++:E9 E1 O-15 E-19 E-3 E-33 O-29
t2 block++:E9 E1 O-15 E-19 E-3 E-33 E-37
t2 block++:E9 E1 O-15 E-19 E-3 E-33 E-19
t2 block++:E9 E1 O-15 E-19 E-3 E-31 O-17
t2 block++:E9 E1 O-15 E-19 E-3 E-19 O-35
t2 block++:E9 E1 O-15 E-19 E-3 E-19 O-13
t2 block++:E9 E1 O-15 E-19 E-3 E-19
t2 block++:E9 E1 O-15 E-19 E-3 E-15 O-11
t2 block++:E9 E1 O-15 E-19 E-3 E-15 E-17
t2 block++:E9 E1 O-15 E-19 E-3 E-11 O-11
t2 block++:E9 E1 O-1 O9 O-15 E-1 E5
t1 block++:E9 E1 E17 O-19 E-15 O31 O31
t2 block++:E9 E1 E17 E25 E-41 E-41 E-3
t1 block++:E9 E1 E17 E15 O-3 O-1 O17
t1 block++:E9 E1 E17 E-11 E29 E41 O31
t2 block++:E9 E1 E1 O-1 E33 E41 E-25
t1 block++:E9 E1 E1 E-19 O3 E-13 O-1
t2 block++:E9 E1 E1 E-19 O3 E-13 O-1
t1 block++:E9 E1 E-19 O-15 O39 E7 E5
t1 block++:E9 E1 E-15 E5 E21 O27 O-17
t1 block++:E9 E1 E-15 E11 O17 E-19 O-23
t2 block++:E9 E-7 E23 O9 E-13 O-3 E-43
t2 block++:E9 E-7 E23 E-5 O-7 O-29
t2 block++:E9 E-7 E21 E13 E-9 E-23 E-53
t1 block++:E9 E-7 E17 O9 O-1 O13 O21
t1 block++:E9 E-7 E17 O7 E-5 O-13 E3
t1 block++:E9 E-7 E-11 E23 E23 O-45 E-29
t2 block++:E9 E-7 E-1 E-15 E-1 E7 E1
t1 block++:E9 E-13 E-7 E-15 O13 O51 O-21
t2 block++:E9 E-11 E3 O31 E37 O-13 O21
t2 block++:E9 E-11 E3 O3 O1 E13 E29
t2 block++:E9 E-11 E3 E-7 O17 O59 O-33
t2 block++:E9 E-11 E3 E-7 O17 O59 O-15
t2 block++:E9 E-11 E3 E-7 O17 O59 E-25
t2 block++:E9 E-11 E-1 E33 E13 E-9 E-21
t1 block++:E9 E-1 O39 O37 O47 O37 O-25
t1 block++:E9 E-1 O15 O5 O-7 O-19 O27
t1 block++:E9 E-1 O15 O5 O-23 O27 E-3
t1 block++:E9 E-1 O15 O5 O-23 O27 E-25
t1 block++:E9 E-1 O15 O5 O-23 O27
t1 block++:E9 E-1 O15 O5 O-1 O27 O-25
t1 block++:E-9 E7 E1 E15 E1 E-7 E-1
t2 block++:E-9 E7 E-9 O-59 O-57 E-59 E-57
t2 block++:E-9 E7 E-9 O-59 O-57 E-59
t2 block++:E-9 E7 E-9 O-59 O-49 E-71 E-59
t2 block++:E-9 E7 E-9 O-55 O-51 O-33 O-59
t1 block++:E-9 E7 E-9 O-55 E-47 E-41 E-11
t2 block++:E-9 E7 E-9 O-51 E-25 E-31 E-59
t2 block++:E-9 E7 E-9 O-47 O-49 O-65 O-59
t2 block++:E-9 E7 E-9 O-43 O-43 E-41 E-59
t2 block++:E-9 E7 E-9 O-43 E-41 O-25 O-59
t2 block++:E-9 E7 E-9 O-41 E-31 O-59 O-39
t2 block++:E-9 E7 E-9 O-39 O-25 E-59 O-59
t2 block++:E-9 E7 E-9 O-39 E-29 E-23 E-59
t2 block++:E-9 E7 E-9 O-37 E-49 O-49 E-59
t2 block++:E-9 E7 E-9 O-29 O-19 O-21 O-59
t2 block++:E-9 E7 E-9 E-57 O-31 E-61 O-59
t1 block++:E-9 E7 E-9 E-57 E-63 O-45 E-55
t2 block++:E-9 E7 E-9 E-55 O-25 E-47 E-59
t2 block++:E-9 E7 E-9 E-37 O-59 E-59
t2 block++:E-9 E7 E-9 E-37 O-59 E-21 E-59
t2 block++:E-9 E7 E-9 E-37 O-25 E-23 E-59
t2 block++:E-9 E7 E-9 E-37 E-43 E-47 E-59
t2 block++:E-9 E7 E-9 E-31 E-49 E-37 E-59
t2 block++:E-9 E7 E-9 E-27 O-27 O-59 O-57
t2 block++:E-9 E7 E-9 E-27 O-27 O-59
t2 block++:E-9 E7 E-9 E-27 E-31 O-39 O-59
t2 block++:E-9 E7 E-9 E-25 O-31 O-55 O-59
t2 block++:E-9 E7 E-9 E-25 E-29 O-19 O-59
t1 block++:E-9 E7 E-5 E1 O-5 O-11 E-31
t2 block++:E-9 E7 E-5 E1 E-13 E-45 E-43
t2 block++:E-9 E7 E-27 E-21 O-9 O-5 O-1
t2 block++:E-9 E7 E-23 O25 E3 O13 E-27
t2 block++:E-9 E7 E-23 E11 O9 O-13
t2 block++:E-9 E7 E-17 O-7 E5 O13 E-3
t1 block++:E-9 E7 E-17 O-17 O-35 O-21 O-29
t2 block++:E-9 E7 E-17 E11 E-9 O9 O-17
t2 block++:E-9 E13 E7 E15 O3 O-13 O21
t1 block++:E-9 E13 E7 E-9 E7 E33 E57
t2 block++:E-9 E13 E-55 E-39 E-55 E-81 E-105
t2 block++:E-9 E13 E-37 E-53 E-25 E-41 O-17
t2 block++:E-9 E13 E-37 E-23 E-39 E-65 E-89
t2 block++:E-9 E13 E-35 E-35 E-43 O-53 O-35
t2 block++:E-9 E13 E-11 E5 E-11 E-37 E-61
t1 block++:E-9 E13 E-11 E-25 E-9 E17 E41
t1 block++:E-9 E11 E13 E-17 E7 E-43 E-49
t2 block++:E-9 E11 E-7 E-27 O-21 E-21 O-33
t1 block++:E-9 E11 E-3 E7 O-17 O-59 O15
t2 block++:E-9 E1 E-19 O-47 O-35 E-25 E7
t2 block++:E-9 E-9 O23 E1 O-19 O11 E-29
t2 block++:E-9 E-9 O-5 O-9 O-9 O15 O-5
t2 block++:E-9 E-9 O-5 O-7 O-21 E15 O25
t1 block++:E-9 E-9 O-5 E7 O-9 E-17
t1 block++:E-9 E-9 O-17 E-25 O-17 O-29 E-1
t1 block++:E-9 E-9 O-17 E-25 E-25 O-17 E-1
t1 block++:E-9 E-9 O-17 E-25 E-23 O-17 E-1
t1 block++:E-9 E-9 O-17 E-25 E-23 E-37 E-13
t2 block++:E-9 E-9 O-13 E-19 E9 O25 O1
t2 block++:E-9 E-9 O-11 O7 O21 E1 O5
t2 block++:E-9 E-9 E9 O-19 O7 O-15
t1 block++:E-9 E-9 E-5 E-17 E-25 E-39 E17
t1 block++:E-9 E-7 O11 O9 E-1 O-13 O15
t2 block++:E-9 E-7 O1 O-31 E-27 E-15 E-13
t1 block++:E-9 E-7 O1 E9 O7 E-11 O25
t2 block++:E-9 E-7 O1 E9 O25 E25 O-9
t2 block++:E-9 E-7 O1 E9 O1 O13 E-15
t2 block++:E-9 E-7 O1 E9 O-13 O11 E21
t2 block++:E-9 E-7 O1 E9 E7 E21 E-3
t1 block++:E-9 E-7 O-5 O-23 O-37 E-17 O-21
t2 block++:E-9 E-7 O-5 E-27 O3 O-17 E-57
t1 block++:E-9 E-7 O-39 E-17 O3 O-27 E13
t2 block++:E-9 E-7 O-31 O-13 O-9 O3 E13
t2 block++:E-9 E-7 O-31 O-13 E11 E11 E29
t1 block++:E-9 E-7 O-3 E3 E-25 O-41 O-17
t1 block++:E-9 E-7 O-11 O5 O-7 O-11 O-51
t1 block++:E-9 E-7 O-11 O5 O-7 O-11 O-37
t1 block++:E-9 E-7 O-11 E-23 O17 O-3 E19
t2 block++:E-9 E-7 O-11 E-23 O-7 E1
t2 block++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O-37 O3
t2 block++:E-9 E-7 E-11 E1 E9 E23 E-51
t2 block++:E-9 E-7 E-11 E1 E9 E23 E-33
t2 block++:E-9 E-3 E11 E17 O-7 E11 E-7
t2 block++:E-9 E-3 E11 E-17 E-41 E-11 O19
t2 block++:E-9 E-3 E-3 O-31 O-31 E11
t2 block++:E-9 E-3 E-3 O-31 O-31 E-3 E11
t2 block++:E-9 E-3 E-3 O-31 O-31 E-25 E11
t2 block++:E-9 E-3 E-3 O-29 E-31 O11 O-29
t2 block++:E-9 E-3 E-3 O-13 E-29 O-13 E-21
t2 block++:E-9 E-3 E-3 E19 E-9 E-59 O-3
t2 block++:E-9 E-3 E-3 E13 E-27 E-51 E-87
t2 block++:E-9 E-3 E-3 E-33 O-29 O-21 O11
t1 block++:E-9 E-29 E39 E23 E39 E65 E89
t1 block++:E-9 E-29 E21 E7 E23 E49 E73
t1 block++:E-9 E-29 E-23 E-31 O-3 O35 O-37
t2 block++:E-9 E-27 E-17 E17 E-3 E-25 E-37
t2 block++:E-9 E-27 E-13 O15 E21 O-29 O5
t2 block++:E-9 E-27 E-13 O-13 O-15 E-3 E13
t2 block++:E-9 E-27 E-13 E-23 O1 O43 O-49
t2 block++:E-9 E-27 E-13 E-23 O1 O43 O-31
t2 block++:E-9 E-27 E-13 E-23 O1 O43 E-41
t2 block++:E-9 E-23 E7 O-7 E-29 O-19 E-59
t1 block++:E-9 E-23 E7 O-41 E-19 O-29 E11
t1 block++:E-9 E-23 E7 E-27 O-25 O-3
t2 block++:E-9 E-23 E7 E-21 O-23 O-45
t2 block++:E-9 E-23 E5 E-3 E-25 E-39 E-69
t2 block++:E-9 E-23 E1 O1 O19 O5 O13
t1 block++:E-9 E-23 E1 O-9 E-21 O-29 E-13
t1 block++:E-9 E-23 E1 O-7 O-17 O-3 O5
t1 block++:E-9 E-23 E-7 O13 O3 O5 O43
t1 block++:E-9 E-23 E-7 E9 E13 O3 O43
t1 block++:E-9 E-23 E-7 E21 O9 E7 E43
t1 block++:E-9 E-23 E-7 E11 E15 O23 O43
t1 block++:E-9 E-23 E-27 E7 E7 O-61 E-45
t2 block++:E-9 E-23 E-17 E-31 E-17 E-9 E-15
t1 block++:E-9 E-17 O23 O21 O31 O21 O-41
t1 block++:E-9 E-17 O-1 O-11 O-39 O11 E-41
t1 block++:E-9 E-17 O-1 O-11 O-39 O11 E-19
t1 block++:E-9 E-17 O-1 O-11 O-39 O11
t1 block++:E-9 E-17 O-1 O-11 O-23 O-35 O11
t1 block++:E-9 E-17 O-1 O-11 O-17 O11 O-41
t1 block++:E-9 E-17 E3 O31 O19 E9 E-23
t2 block++:E-9 E-15 O3 O13 E-33 E-23 O-23
t2 block++:E-9 E-15 O3 E9 O-11 O-61 E-5
t2 block++:E-9 E-15 O3 E-3 O3 O-21 O7
t2 block++:E-9 E-15 O3 E-3 E-35 O-31 E3
t1 block++:E-9 E-15 O3 E-3 E-25 E-33 E-17
t1 block++:E-9 E-15 O-35 O-25 E17 E-7 E27
t1 block++:E-9 E-15 O-35 E-5 O-25 O-29 E11
t2 block++:E-9 E-15 O-35 E-25 O11 E13 O29
t2 block++:E-9 E-15 O-31 E-35 E-19 O-45 O-43
t2 block++:E-9 E-15 O-31 E-35 E-19 O-45 E-49
t2 block++:E-9 E-15 O-31 E-35 E-19 O-41
t2 block++:E-9 E-15 O-31 E-35 E-19 O-31 O-47
t2 block++:E-9 E-15 O-31 E-35 E-19 O-29 O-43
t2 block++:E-9 E-15 O-31 E-35 E-19 O-29 O-29
t2 block++:E-9 E-15 O-31 E-35 E-19 E-49 O-45
t2 block++:E-9 E-15 O-31 E-35 E-19 E-49 E-53
t2 block++:E-9 E-15 O-31 E-35 E-19 E-49 E-35
t2 block++:E-9 E-15 O-31 E-35 E-19 E-47 O-33
t2 block++:E-9 E-15 O-31 E-35 E-19 E-35 O-51
t2 block++:E-9 E-15 O-31 E-35 E-19 E-35 O-29
t2 block++:E-9 E-15 O-31 E-35 E-19 E-35
t2 block++:E-9 E-15 O-31 E-35 E-19 E-31 O-27
t2 block++:E-9 E-15 O-31 E-35 E-19 E-31 E-33
t2 block++:E-9 E-15 O-31 E-35 E-19 E-27 O-27
t2 block++:E-9 E-15 O-31 E-23 E-13 E-15 O-23
t2 block++:E-9 E-15 O-27 O-45 O-47 O-49 O11
t2 block++:E-9 E-15 O-23 O-37 O-23 O3 O15
t1 block++:E-9 E-15 O-23 O-23 O-29 O-45 O15
t2 block++:E-9 E-15 O-17 O-7 O-31 E-17 E-11
t1 block++:E-9 E-15 E1 O-35 E-31 O15 O15
t2 block++:E-9 E-15 E1 E9 E-57 E-57 E-19
t1 block++:E-9 E-15 E1 E-27 E13 E25 O15
t1 block++:E-9 E-15 E1 E-1 O-19 O-17 O1
t1 block++:E-9 E-15 E-35 O-31 O23 E-9 E-11
t2 block++:E-9 E-15 E-33 E-11 O-3 O39 O31
t2 block++:E-9 E-15 E-33 E-11 O-3 E27 O25
t2 block++:E-9 E-15 E-33 E-11 O-3 E27 O19
t1 block++:E-9 E-15 E-31 E-5 O1 E-35 O-39
t1 block++:E-9 E-15 E-31 E-3 E-17 E-27 E-25
t1 block++:E-9 E-15 E-31 E-11 E5 O11 O-33
t2 block++:E-9 E-15 E-21 E-19 O-23 O-11 E-19
t2 block++:E-9 E-15 E-15 O-17 E17 E25 E-41
t2 block++:E-9 E-15 E-15 E-35 O-13 E-29 O-17
t1 block++:E-9 E-15 E-15 E-35 O-13 E-29 O-17
t1 block++:E-9 E-13 E-27 E1 E25 E-5 O-35
t1 block++:E-9 E-13 E-27 E1 E25 E-5 O-21
t1 block++:E-9 E-13 E-27 E-25 E-15 O-33 O-23
t1 block++:E-9 E-13 E-13 O15 O15 E-27
t1 block++:E-9 E-13 E-13 O15 O15 E-13 E-27
t2 block++:E-9 E-13 E-13 O15 O-21 O-3 E9
t1 block++:E-9 E-13 E-13 O13 E15 O-27 O13
t2 block++:E-9 E-1 O7 O7 O13 O29 O-31
t1 block++:E-9 E-1 O7 O21 O7 O-19 O-31
t2 block++:E-9 E-1 O19 O9 E-33 E-9 E-43
t1 block++:E-9 E-1 O15 O25 E-1 E23 O25
t1 block++:E-9 E-1 O15 E7 E-3 E-1 O7
t1 block++:E-9 E-1 O15 E27 E-17 E-25 E-3
t1 block++:E-9 E-1 O15 E19 E3 O29 E33
t1 block++:E-9 E-1 O15 E19 E3 O13 O27
t1 block++:E-9 E-1 O15 E19 E3 O13 O13
t1 block++:E-9 E-1 O15 E19 E3 E19 O35
t1 block++:E-9 E-1 O15 E19 E3 E19 O13
t1 block++:E-9 E-1 O15 E19 E3 E19
t1 block++:E-9 E-1 O15 E19 E3 E15 O11
t1 block++:E-9 E-1 O15 E19 E3 E15 E17
t1 block++:E-9 E-1 O11 O29 O31 O33 O-27
t1 block++:E-9 E-1 O11 O29 O31 O-9 O33
t1 block++:E-9 E-1 O1 E-3 O3 E17 O-3
t1 block++:E-9 E-1 O1 E-3 E-9 O9 E-31
t2 block++:E-9 E-1 O-33 E13 E13 O5 O-31
t2 block++:E-9 E-1 O-31 O-3 E-5 E-9 O-25
t1 block++:E-9 E-1 O-19 E-13 E19 O15 E-19
t2 block++:E-9 E-1 E7 O-9 O5 E3 O9
t1 block++:E-9 E-1 E7 O-9 O-3 O-3 O-9
t1 block++:E-9 E-1 E5 E3 O7 O-5 E3
t1 block++:E-9 E-1 E5 E-5 E5 O-29 O-23
t2 block++:E-9 E-1 E17 O23 E-9 O-31 O-5
t1 block++:E-9 E-1 E17 E-5 O-13 O-69 O-39
t1 block++:E-9 E-1 E17 E-5 O-13 O-55 O-47
t1 block++:E-9 E-1 E17 E-5 O-13 O-55 E-41
t1 block++:E-9 E-1 E17 E-5 O-13 O-39 O-47
t1 block++:E-9 E-1 E17 E-5 O-13 O-39
t1 block++:E-9 E-1 E17 E-5 O-13 E-67 O-63
t1 block++:E-9 E-1 E17 E-5 O-13 E-49 O-73
t1 block++:E-9 E-1 E17 E-5 O-13 E-49 O-51
t1 block++:E-9 E-1 E17 E-5 O-13 E-49
t1 block++:E-9 E-1 E17 E-5 O-13 E-47 O-61
t1 block++:E-9 E-1 E17 E-5 O-13 E-47 E-67
t1 block++:E-9 E-1 E17 E-5 O-13 E-43 O-41
t1 block++:E-9 E-1 E17 E-5 O-13 E-43 O-35
t1 block++:E-9 E-1 E17 E-5 O-13 E-37 E-47
t2 block++:E-9 E-1 E15 E-13 E1 E11 E9
t1 block++:E-9 E-1 E13 E19 E-1 E15 O-29
t1 block++:E-9 E-1 E-5 O29 O-11 O15 E45
t1 block++:E-9 E-1 E-5 E7 E-11 E3 O33
t1 block++:E-9 E-1 E-17 E-23 O49 O1 E-39
t2 block++:E-9 E-1 E-17 E-15 O3 O1 O-17
t2 block++:E-9 E-1 E-1 E19 O-3 O3 E15
t2 block++:E-9 E-1 E-1 E19 O-3 E13 O1
t1 block++:E-9 E-1 E-1 E19 O-3 E13 O1
t1 block++:E-9 E-1 E-1 E-13 O25 O-13 E-7
t2 block+++:E9 E9 O11 E-11 O19 O-1 E-63
t2 block+++:E9 E9 O11 E-11 O19 O-1 E-43
t2 block+++:E9 E9 E7 E-13 O11 O15 O43
t1 block+++:E9 E9 E-9 O19 O-7
t2 block+++:E9 E9 E-3 O-5 O7 E9 E-21
t2 block+++:E9 E9 E-3 O-5 O29 O5 O-21
t2 block+++:E9 E9 E-3 O-5 O19
t2 block+++:E9 E7 O39 E17 O-3 O27 E-35
t2 block+++:E9 E7 O39 E17 O-3 O27 E-15
t2 block+++:E9 E7 E25 O-3 O23
t1 block+++:E9 E7 E19 O21 O15 O5 O37
t1 block+++:E9 E3 E3 O-1 E1 O11 O33
t2 block+++:E9 E23 E7 O-19 O23 E21 E-1
t1 block+++:E9 E23 E7 O-19 O17 E19 E35
t2 block+++:E9 E23 E7 E-9 E-19 O-9 O-43
t2 block+++:E9 E23 E7 E-21 E-9 E-43 E-11
t2 block+++:E9 E23 E-7 O41 E19 O29 E-33
t2 block+++:E9 E23 E-7 O41 E19 O29 E-13
t2 block+++:E9 E23 E-7 E27 O25
t2 block+++:E9 E15 O29 O45 O25 E-7 O-3
t1 block+++:E9 E15 E33 E11 O3 E-25
t2 block+++:E9 E15 E15 E35 O13 O19 O33
t1 block+++:E9 E15 E11 E41 O45 E-7 E-3
t1 block+++:E9 E15 E-1 O-1 E3 E-11 E-43
t1 block+++:E9 E1 O19 E13 E-9 E-17 E19
t2 block+++:E9 E1 O-15 O-27 O-23 E3 O-5
t1 block+++:E9 E1 O-13 O-29 O-9 E23 O19
t2 block+++:E9 E1 E-17 E5 O13 E43 O49
t2 block+++:E9 E1 E-17 E5 O13 E41 O35
t2 block+++:E9 E1 E-17 E5 O13 E41
t2 block+++:E9 E1 E-17 E5 O13 E37 E39
t2 block+++:E9 E-7 E23 O9 E-13 O-3 E-65
t2 block+++:E9 E-7 E23 O9 E-13 O-3 E-45
t2 block+++:E9 E-7 E23 E-5 O-7
t1 block+++:E9 E-7 E23 E-11 O-9
t2 block+++:E-9 E7 E-9 O-35 O7 E5 E-17
t1 block+++:E-9 E7 E-9 O-35 O1 E3 E19
t2 block+++:E-9 E7 E-9 E-37 E-25 E-59 E-27
t2 block+++:E-9 E7 E-9 E-25 E-35 O-25 O-59
t1 block+++:E-9 E7 E-5 E-29 E-9 O-29 E-17
t2 block+++:E-9 E7 E-23 O25 E3 O13 E-49
t2 block+++:E-9 E7 E-23 O25 E3 O13 E-29
t2 block+++:E-9 E7 E-23 E11 O9
t2 block+++:E-9 E-9 O23 E1 O-19 O11 E-51
t2 block+++:E-9 E-9 O23 E1 O-19 O11 E-31
t2 block+++:E-9 E-9 E9 O-29 E9 O-11 O31
t2 block+++:E-9 E-9 E9 O-19 O7
t1 block+++:E-9 E-9 E3 O5 O-9 E-7 E21
t1 block+++:E-9 E-9 E3 O5 O-7 O-3 E21
t1 block+++:E-9 E-9 E3 O5 O-7 E-9 E21
t1 block+++:E-9 E-9 E3 O5 O-1 O-11 O21
t1 block+++:E-9 E-9 E-7 E13 O-11 O-43 O45
t2 block+++:E-9 E-7 O-5 E-27 O3 O-17 E-79
t2 block+++:E-9 E-7 O-5 E-27 O3 O-17 E-59
t2 block+++:E-9 E-7 E-9 E-29 O-5 O27 O-61
t2 block+++:E-9 E-7 E-9 E-29 O-5 O-1 O27
t1 block+++:E-9 E-7 E-25 O3 O-23
t1 block+++:E-9 E-7 E-25 O13 E-25 O-5 O-47
t2 block+++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O3
t2 block+++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O13 O-11 O-37
t2 block+++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O-9 O-13 E-37
t2 block+++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O-9 E-7 E-37
t2 block+++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O-7 E-9 E-37
t2 block+++:E-9 E-3 E-3 O-27 E-25 O-1 O31
t2 block+++:E-9 E-23 E7 O-7 E-29 O-19 E-81
t2 block+++:E-9 E-23 E7 O-7 E-29 O-19 E-61
t1 block+++:E-9 E-23 E7 E-27 O-25
t2 block+++:E-9 E-23 E7 E-21 O-23
t2 block+++:E-9 E-23 E-11 E13 E-7 O13 E1
t1 block+++:E-9 E-15 O3 E-3 E-25 E-33 E3
t2 block+++:E-9 E-15 O-31 O-43 O-39 E-13 O-21
t2 block+++:E-9 E-15 O-29 O-83 O-45 E-11 O-67
t1 block+++:E-9 E-15 O-29 O-45 O-25 E7 O3
t2 block+++:E-9 E-15 O-27 O-45 O-47 O-49
t2 block+++:E-9 E-15 E-33 E-11 O-3 E27 O33
t2 block+++:E-9 E-15 E-33 E-11 O-3 E25 O19
t2 block+++:E-9 E-15 E-33 E-11 O-3 E25
t2 block+++:E-9 E-15 E-33 E-11 O-3 E21 E23
t1 block+++:E-9 E-13 E-13 O11 E9 O-15 O-47
t1 block+++:E-9 E-13 E-13 O-17 E-15 O-5 O17
t1 block+++:E-9 E-1 O13 O67 O29 E-5 O51
t2 block+++:E-9 E-1 O13 O29 O9 E-23 O-19
t1 block+++:E-9 E-1 O11 O29 O31 O33
t1 block+++:E-9 E-1 E17 E-5 O-13 E-41
t1 block+++:E-9 E-1 E-5 E25 O29 E-23 E-19
t1 block+++:E-9 E-1 E-17 O-17 E-13 E-27 E-59
t2 block+++:E-9 E-1 E-1 E19 O-3 O3 O17
t2 block++++:E9 E9 O11 E-11 O19 O-1
t2 block++++:E9 E9 E-3 O-5 O7 E9
t2 block++++:E9 E9 E-3 O-5 O29 O5
t2 block++++:E9 E9 E-3 O-5 O1 O11
t2 block++++:E9 E7 O39 E17 O-3 O27
t1 block++++:E9 E7 E19 O21 O15 O5
t2 block++++:E9 E23 E7 O-23 O-43 E-43
t2 block++++:E9 E23 E7 O-19 O23 E21
t1 block++++:E9 E23 E7 O-19 O17 E19
t2 block++++:E9 E23 E-7 O41 E19 O29
t2 block++++:E9 E1 O-15 O-27 O-23 E3
t2 block++++:E9 E1 O-13 O-67 O-29 E5
t1 block++++:E9 E-7 E9 O35 O-7 E-5
t2 block++++:E9 E-7 E9 O35 O-1 E-3
t2 block++++:E9 E-7 E23 O9 E-13 O-3
t2 block++++:E-9 E7 E-9 O-39 O-59 E-59
t2 block++++:E-9 E7 E-9 O-35 O7 E5
t1 block++++:E-9 E7 E-9 O-35 O1 E3
t2 block++++:E-9 E7 E-23 O25 E3 O13
t2 block++++:E-9 E-9 O23 E1 O-19 O11
t1 block++++:E-9 E-9 E3 O5 O-9 E-7
t1 block++++:E-9 E-9 E3 O5 O-7 O-3
t1 block++++:E-9 E-9 E3 O5 O-7 E-9
t1 block++++:E-9 E-9 E3 O5 O-1 O-11
t1 block++++:E-9 E-9 E-7 E13 O-11 O-43
t2 block++++:E-9 E-7 O-5 E-27 O3 O-17
t1 block++++:E-9 E-7 O-39 E-17 O3 O-27
t2 block++++:E-9 E-7 E-9 E-29 O-5 O27
t2 block++++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O13 O-11
t2 block++++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O-9 O-13
t2 block++++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O-9 E-7
t2 block++++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O-7 E-9
t2 block++++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O-15 O-5
t2 block++++:E-9 E-23 E7 O-7 E-29 O-19
t1 block++++:E-9 E-23 E7 O-41 E-19 O-29
t1 block++++:E-9 E-23 E-7 O19 O-23 E-21
t2 block++++:E-9 E-23 E-7 O19 O-17 E-19
t2 block++++:E-9 E-15 O-31 O-43 O-39 E-13
t2 block++++:E-9 E-15 O-29 O-83 O-45 E-11
t1 block++++:E-9 E-1 O15 O27 O23 E-3
t1 block++++:E-9 E-1 O13 O67 O29 E-5
t1 block++++ blinkerA boatA:E9 E15 O29 O83 O45
t1 block++++ blinkerA boatA:E-9 E-1 O13 O67 O29
t1 block++++ beehiveA:E9 E7 O17 O19
t1 block++++ beehiveA:E-9 E-9 O1 O3
t1 block+++ shipB:E-9 E-9 E3 O5 O-9 E-19
t1 block+++ shipA:E9 E15 E11 E23 O25 E27
t1 block+++ shipA:E-9 E-1 E-5 E7 O9 E11
t1 block+++ boatD:E9 E7 O-1 O-7 E35 E37
t1 block+++ boatD:E-9 E-9 O-17 O-41 E3 O5
t1 block+++ boatD:E-9 E-9 O-17 O-23 E19 E21
t1 block+++ blinkerB:E9 E9 O5 E-7 O33 O13
t2 block+++ blinkerB:E9 E23 E7 E-27 O-35 E-43
t2 block+++ blinkerB:E9 E1 O-15 O-23 O-19 E3
t2 block+++ blinkerB:E-9 E7 E-9 E-43 O-51 E-59
t1 block+++ blinkerB:E-9 E-7 O-11 E-23 O17 O-3
t2 block+++ blinkerB:E-9 E-15 O-31 O-39 O-35 E-13
t1 block+++ blinkerB+:E9 E-7 E-11 E-23 O-3 E3
t1 block+++ blinkerB+:E-9 E-23 E-27 E-39 O-19 E-13
t1 block+++ blinkerA:E9 E15 E11 E41 O45 E-7
t1 block+++ blinkerA:E-9 E-1 E-5 E25 O29 E-23
t1 block+++ beehiveB:E9 E1 O19 E13 E-9 E-17
t1 block+++ beehiveB:E9 E-13 E-7 E-15 O13
t1 block+++ beehiveB:E-9 E-29 E-23 E-31 O-3
t1 block+++ beehiveB:E-9 E-15 O3 E-3 E-25 E-33
t1 block+++ beehiveA:E9 E7 O17 O19 O21
t1 block+++ beehiveA:E9 E7 E19 O21 O15
t1 block+++ beehiveA:E-9 E-9 O1 O3 O5
t1 block+++ beehiveA:E-9 E-9 O1 O3 O-27
t1 block+++ beehiveA:E-9 E-9 E3 O5 O-1
t1 block++ tub:E9 E7 E11 O19 O19 E-7 E47
t2 block++ tub:E-9 E13 E-37 E-31 O-35 O7 O-59
t1 block++ tub:E-9 E-9 E-5 O3 O3 E-23 E31
t1 block++ shipB:E9 E15 E33 E11 O3 O-19
t2 block++ shipB:E9 E1 E-17 E5 O13 O35
t2 block++ shipB:E-9 E-15 E-33 E-11 O-3 O19
t1 block++ shipB:E-9 E-1 E17 E-5 O-13 O-35
t1 block++ pond:E9 E15 E33 E11 O3 E-17
t2 block++ pond:E9 E1 E-17 E5 O13 E33
t2 block++ pond:E-9 E-15 E-33 E-11 O-3 E17
t1 block++ pond:E-9 E-1 E17 E-5 O-13 E-33
t1 block++ loafD:E9 E15 E33 E11 O3 O-21
t1 block++ loafD:E-9 E-1 E17 E-5 O-13 O-37
t2 block++ loafC:E9 E23 E7 O-33 O-3 O-43
t2 block++ loafC:E-9 E7 E-9 O-49 O-19 O-59
t2 block++ loafB:E9 E1 E-17 E5 O13 O37
t2 block++ loafB:E-9 E-15 E-33 E-11 O-3 O21
t1 block++ boatD beehiveB blinkerA:E9 E1 O-7 E21 E19
t1 block++ boatD beehiveB blinkerA:E-9 E-15 O-23 E5 E3
t2 block++ boatB:E9 E23 E7 O-15 O-41 O-43
t2 block++ boatB:E-9 E7 E-9 O-31 O-57 O-59
t2 block++ boatB blinkerA:E-9 E-7 O-5 O13 E-39 O-33
t1 block++ boatA:E-9 E-1 E13 O3 E7 E-7
t1 block++ blinkerB:E9 E15 E33 E11 O3 O-53
t1 block++ blinkerB:E9 E15 E33 E11 O3 E-27
t1 block++ blinkerB:E9 E15 E33 E11 O3
t1 block++ blinkerB:E9 E13 E13 E1 E13 E11 O5
t1 block++ blinkerB:E9 E1 O-19 O17 O-13 E-3 E11
t2 block++ blinkerB:E9 E1 E1 O-1 E33 E41
t2 block++ blinkerB:E9 E1 E-17 E5 O13 E37
t2 block++ blinkerB:E9 E1 E-15 O-17 E-15 O27 O31
t1 block++ blinkerB:E-9 E-3 E-3 E-15 E-3 E-5 O-11
t1 block++ blinkerB:E-9 E-15 O-35 O1 O-29 E-19 E-5
t2 block++ blinkerB:E-9 E-15 E-33 E-11 O-3 E21
t2 block++ blinkerB:E-9 E-15 E-31 O-33 E-31 O11 O15
t2 block++ blinkerB:E-9 E-15 E-15 O-17 E17 E25
t1 block++ blinkerB:E-9 E-1 E17 E-5 O-13 O-69
t1 block++ blinkerB:E-9 E-1 E17 E-5 O-13 E-43
t1 block++ blinkerB:E-9 E-1 E17 E-5 O-13
t1 block++ blinkerB boatD:E-9 E-9 O-11 O-29 E23 O17
t2 block++ blinkerA:E9 E3 E3 E15 E3 E5 O11
t1 block++ blinkerA:E9 E15 E33 E11 O3 E-21
t1 block++ blinkerA:E9 E1 O-13 O-67 O-57 O-31 O9
t2 block++ blinkerA:E9 E1 E-17 E5 O13 E43
t2 block++ blinkerA:E9 E1 E-17 E5 O13
t1 block++ blinkerA:E9 E1 E-13 E13 E15 O23 O37
t1 block++ blinkerA:E-9 E-15 O-29 O-83 O-73 O-47 O-7
t2 block++ blinkerA:E-9 E-15 E-33 E-11 O-3 E27
t2 block++ blinkerA:E-9 E-15 E-33 E-11 O-3
t1 block++ blinkerA:E-9 E-15 E-29 E-3 E-1 O7 O21
t1 block++ blinkerA:E-9 E-15 E-15 E-35 O-13 O-19
t2 block++ blinkerA:E-9 E-13 E-13 E-1 E-13 E-11 O-5
t1 block++ blinkerA:E-9 E-1 E17 E-5 O-13 E-37
t1 block++ blinkerA boatA:E-9 E-1 E15 O17 E15
t2 block++ blinkerA blinkerB:E-9 E-15 O-35 O1 O-29 O-35
t2 block++ blinkerA blinkerB:E-9 E-15 O-35 O1 O-29 E-41
t1 block++ beehiveB:E9 E15 E33 E11 O3 E-51
t1 block++ beehiveB:E9 E-13 E-7 E-15 O13 O51
t1 block++ beehiveB:E-9 E-29 E-23 E-31 O-3 O35
t1 block++ beehiveB:E-9 E-17 E3 O31 O19 E9
t1 block++ beehiveB:E-9 E-1 E17 E-5 O-13 E-67
t2 block++ beehiveA:E9 E17 O-1 O-11 O23
t2 block++ beehiveA:E9 E15 O35 O25 E-17 E7
t1 block++ beehiveA:E9 E15 O31 O41 E15 E39
t2 block++ beehiveA:E9 E13 E13 E29 E-11 E-35
t1 block++ beehiveA:E9 E-7 E17 O9 O-1 O13
t2 block++ beehiveA:E-9 E1 O-17 O-27 O7
t2 block++ beehiveA:E-9 E1 E-19 O-47 O-35 E-25
t2 block++ beehiveA:E-9 E-3 E-3 E13 E-27 E-51
t1 block++ beehiveA:E-9 E-23 E1 O-7 O-17 O-3
t2 block++ beehiveA:E-9 E-1 O7 O7 O13 O29
t1 block++ beehiveA:E-9 E-1 O7 O21 O7 O-19
t2 block++ beehiveA:E-9 E-1 O19 O9 E-33 E-9
t1 block++ beehiveA:E-9 E-1 O15 O25 E-1 E23
t2 block++ beehiveA+:E9 E17 O-11
t2 block++ beehiveA+:E9 E17 O-1 O-11
t2 block++ beehiveA+:E-9 E1 O-27
t2 block++ beehiveA+:E-9 E1 O-17 O-27
t1 block++ beehiveA+:E-9 E1 O-17 O-17 O-13
t2 block++ beehiveA blinkerB:E9 E29 E-39 E-29 E5 O-57
t2 block++ beehiveA blinkerB:E-9 E13 E-55 E-45 E-11 O-73
t2 block++ beehiveA blinkerB+ blinkerA:E9 E17 O33 O27 O-11
t2 block++ beehiveA blinkerB+ blinkerA:E-9 E1 O17 O11 O-27
t1 block+ tub:E9 E9 O5 O21 O9 O5 O-41
t1 block+ tub:E9 E9 O5 O21 O9 O5 O-15
t2 block+ tub:E9 E23 E7 O-9 O-19 E-33 E-43
t2 block+ tub:E9 E23 E7 O-35 O-9 E-3 O-43
t2 block+ tub:E9 E23 E7 E-41 O-9 E-27 E-43
t2 block+ tub:E-9 E7 E-9 O-51 O-25 E-19 O-59
t2 block+ tub:E-9 E7 E-9 O-25 O-35 E-49 E-59
t2 block+ tub:E-9 E7 E-9 E-57 O-25 E-43 E-59
t1 block+ tub:E-9 E-7 O-11 O5 O-7 O-11 O-57
t1 block+ tub:E-9 E-7 O-11 O5 O-7 O-11 O-31
t2 block+ tub:E-9 E-15 O-31 E-35 E-19 O-49 O-55
t2 block+ toadB1:E9 E23 E7 O-39 E-29 O-29 O-43
t2 block+ toadB1:E-9 E7 E-9 O-55 E-45 O-45 O-59
t1 block+ shipB:E9 E9 O5 O21 O9 O5 O-27
t2 block+ shipB:E9 E23 E7 O-39 E-41 E-43 E-11
t2 block+ shipB:E9 E1 O-15 E-19 E-3 O-13
t2 block+ shipB:E9 E1 O-15 E-19 E-3 E-31
t2 block+ shipB:E-9 E7 E-9 O-55 E-57 E-59 E-27
t1 block+ shipB:E-9 E-7 O-11 O5 O-7 O-11 O-43
t1 block+ shipB:E-9 E-7 E-9 O3 O-7 O-37 E-9
t1 block+ shipB:E-9 E-23 E7 E-11 O-9 O-39 E-11
t2 block+ shipB:E-9 E-15 O-31 E-35 E-19 O-29
t2 block+ shipB:E-9 E-15 O-31 E-35 E-19 E-47
t1 block+ shipB:E-9 E-1 E17 E-5 O-13 O-55 O-35
t1 block+ shipB:E-9 E-1 E17 E-5 O-13 O-55 E-53
t1 block+ pond:E9 E9 O5 O21 O9 O5
t1 block+ pond:E9 E3 E-11 E17 E41 E11
t2 block+ pond:E9 E23 E7 O-39 E-41 E-43 O-9
t2 block+ pond:E9 E23 E7 O-39 E-41 E-31 E-43
t2 block+ pond:E9 E1 O-15 E-19 E-3 E-11
t2 block+ pond:E-9 E7 E-9 O-55 E-57 E-59 O-25
t2 block+ pond:E-9 E7 E-9 O-55 E-57 E-47 E-59
t1 block+ pond:E-9 E-7 O-11 O5 O-7 O-11
t2 block+ pond:E-9 E-15 O-31 E-35 E-19 O-49
t2 block+ pond:E-9 E-15 O-31 E-35 E-19 E-27
t1 block+ pond:E-9 E-13 E-27 E1 E25 E-5
t1 block+ pond:E-9 E-1 E17 E-5 O-13 O-55 E-33
t2 block+ pond:E-9 E-1 E-5 O13 O17 O-19 O-9
t2 block+ pond beehiveA:E9 E3 E3 O19 E-5 E9
t2 block+ pond beehiveA:E-9 E-13 E-13 O3 E-21 E-7
t2 block+ loafD:E9 E1 O-15 E-19 E-3 O-15
t1 block+ loafD:E-9 E-27 E-13 O-13 O-15 E-23 E15
t2 block+ loafD:E-9 E-15 O-31 E-35 E-19 O-31
t2 block+ loafB:E-9 E11 E-3 O-3 O-1 E7 E-31
t1 block+ loafB:E-9 E11 E-3 E7 O17 O-17
t2 block+ loafB:E-9 E-15 O-31 E-35 E-19 E-45
t2 block+ loafA:E9 E23 E7 E-41 E-27 E-27 E-43
t2 block+ loafA:E-9 E7 E-9 E-57 E-43 E-43 E-59
t1 block+ boatD:E9 E1 O-7 E-21 O13 O21 O19
t1 block+ boatD:E-9 E-15 O-23 E-37 O-3 O5 O3
t1 block+ boatD tub blinkerB:E9 E1 O-7 E21 E19 O1
t1 block+ boatD tub blinkerB:E-9 E-15 O-23 E5 E3 O-15
t2 block+ boatC:E9 E9 E5 E17 E25 E39
t2 block+ boatC:E9 E23 E7 O-23 O-33 O-49 O-43
t2 block+ boatC:E9 E23 E7 E-25 O-31 E-39 E-43
t2 block+ boatC:E-9 E7 E-9 O-39 O-49 O-65 O-59
t2 block+ boatC:E-9 E7 E-9 E-41 O-47 E-55 E-59
t2 block+ boatC:E-9 E-7 E-11 E1 E9 E23
t2 block+ boatB:E9 E23 E7 O-25 E-43 O-33 O-43
t2 block+ boatB:E9 E23 E7 O-15 O-41 O-43 O-23
t2 block+ boatB:E9 E23 E7 O-13 E-25 O-9 E-41
t2 block+ boatB:E9 E23 E7 E-21 E-27 O-25 E-43
t2 block+ boatB:E-9 E7 E-9 O-41 E-59 O-49 O-59
t2 block+ boatB:E-9 E7 E-9 O-31 O-57 O-59 O-39
t2 block+ boatB:E-9 E7 E-9 O-29 E-41 O-25 E-57
t2 block+ boatB:E-9 E7 E-9 E-37 E-43 O-41 E-59
t2 block+ boatB blinkerA:E9 E23 E7 O-15 O-39 O-37 O-43
t2 block+ boatB blinkerA:E-9 E7 E-9 O-31 O-55 O-53 O-59
t2 block+ boatA:E9 E23 E7 O-27 O-41 O-41 O-43
t2 block+ boatA:E9 E23 E7 O-23 O-23 E-9 E-43
t2 block+ boatA:E9 E23 E7 E-21 O-9 O-33 E-43
t1 block+ boatA:E9 E15 O17 E13 E7 O25
t2 block+ boatA:E9 E15 O-17 E29 E29 O21
t2 block+ boatA:E-9 E7 E-9 O-43 O-57 O-57 O-59
t2 block+ boatA:E-9 E7 E-9 O-39 O-39 E-25 E-59
t2 block+ boatA:E-9 E7 E-9 E-37 O-25 O-49 E-59
t1 block+ boatA:E-9 E-1 O1 E-3 E-9 O9
t2 block+ boatA:E-9 E-1 O-33 E13 E13 O5
t2 block+ boatA pond:E9 E23 E7 E-21 E-9 E-43
t2 block+ boatA pond:E-9 E7 E-9 E-37 E-25 E-59
t2 block+ boatA blinkerA:E9 E1 E5 O-13 E1 E43 E47
t2 block+ boatA blinkerA:E-9 E-15 E-11 O-29 E-15 E27 E31
t2 block+ blinkerB:E9 E23 E7 E-27 O-35 E-43 E-23
t1 block+ blinkerB:E9 E15 E33 E11 O3 O-39
t2 block+ blinkerB:E9 E1 O-15 E-19 E-3
t1 block+ blinkerB:E9 E1 O-1 E-17 O-13 O17 O31
t2 block+ blinkerB:E-9 E7 E-9 E-43 O-51 E-59 E-39
t2 block+ blinkerB:E-9 E-3 E-3 E19 E-3 E-5 E-25
t2 block+ blinkerB:E-9 E-15 O-31 E-35 E-19
t1 block+ blinkerB:E-9 E-15 O-17 E-33 O-29 O1 O15
t1 block+ blinkerB:E-9 E-15 E-29 O-29 O-3 O-21 E-29
t1 block+ blinkerB:E-9 E-1 E17 E-5 O-13 O-55
t2 block+ blinkerB+ blinkerA+:E9 E23 E7 O-27 E-25 O-43
t2 block+ blinkerB+ blinkerA+:E9 E-11 E3 E-7 O17 O59
t2 block+ blinkerB+ blinkerA+:E-9 E7 E-9 O-43 E-41 O-59
t2 block+ blinkerB+ blinkerA+:E-9 E-27 E-13 E-23 O1 O43
t2 block+ blinkerB boatD:E9 E23 E7 E-21 O-13 E-43
t2 block+ blinkerB boatD:E-9 E7 E-9 E-37 O-29 E-59
t1 block+ blinkerA:E9 E9 E7 O19 O9 E7
t1 block+ blinkerA:E9 E9 E13 O27 O7 E1 O11
t1 block+ blinkerA:E9 E7 O31 O-1 O3 O31 E13
t2 block+ blinkerA:E9 E23 E7 O-39 E-41 E-43
t2 block+ blinkerA:E9 E23 E7 O-27 O-33 E-27 O-43
t1 block+ blinkerA:E9 E15 E33 E11 O3 E-31
t1 block+ blinkerA:E9 E15 E-1 E-7 O65 O17
t2 block+ blinkerA:E9 E1 O-15 E-19 E-3 O-29
t2 block+ blinkerA:E9 E1 O-15 E-19 E-3 E-15
t1 block+ blinkerA:E9 E-7 E23 E5 O7 E5
t2 block+ blinkerA:E-9 E7 E-9 O-55 E-57 E-59
t2 block+ blinkerA:E-9 E7 E-9 O-43 O-49 E-43 O-59
t1 block+ blinkerA:E-9 E-9 O15 O-17 O-13 O15 E-3
t2 block+ blinkerA:E-9 E-7 O1 O-9 E9 O-31 E11
t1 block+ blinkerA:E-9 E-7 E-9 O3 O-7 E-9
t1 block+ blinkerA:E-9 E-7 E-3 O11 O-9 E-15 O-5
t1 block+ blinkerA:E-9 E-23 E7 E-11 O-9 E-11
t2 block+ blinkerA:E-9 E-15 O3 O-5 E9 O-7 O-27
t2 block+ blinkerA:E-9 E-15 O-35 O1 O-29 E-41 E-49
t2 block+ blinkerA:E-9 E-15 O-31 E-35 E-19 O-45
t2 block+ blinkerA:E-9 E-15 O-31 E-35 E-19 E-31
t1 block+ blinkerA:E-9 E-1 E17 E-5 O-13 O-55 O-51
t1 block+ blinkerA:E-9 E-1 E17 E-5 O-13 E-47
t2 block+ blinkerA:E-9 E-1 E13 O13 O-13 O5 E13
t1 block+ blinkerA:E-9 E-1 E-17 E-23 O49 O1
t2 block+ blinkerA+:E9 E23 E7 O-9 O-31 E-23 E-43
t2 block+ blinkerA+:E9 E23 E7 E-25 O-37 E-43
t2 block+ blinkerA+:E-9 E7 E-9 O-25 O-47 E-39 E-59
t2 block+ blinkerA+:E-9 E7 E-9 E-41 O-53 E-59
t2 block+ blinkerA+ blinkerB:E9 E1 O-19 O17 O-13
t2 block+ blinkerA+ blinkerB:E-9 E-15 O-35 O1 O-29
t2 block+ blinkerA+ blinkerB+:E9 E1 O-15 E-19 E-3 E-33
t2 block+ blinkerA+ blinkerB+:E-9 E-15 O-31 E-35 E-19 E-49
t2 block+ blinkerA blinkerB:E9 E23 E7 E-9 E-13 O-21 O-43
t1 block+ blinkerA blinkerB:E9 E1 O-13 O-67 O-57 O-31
t2 block+ blinkerA blinkerB:E-9 E7 E-9 E-25 E-29 O-37 O-59
t2 block+ blinkerA blinkerB:E-9 E-15 O-35 O1 O-29 O-43
t1 block+ blinkerA blinkerB:E-9 E-15 O-29 O-83 O-73 O-47
t2 block+ blinkerA blinkerB shipB:E-9 E-15 O-35 O1 O-29 O-47
t2 block+ blinkerA blinkerB pond:E-9 E-15 O-35 O1 O-29 E-49
t2 block+ blinkerA blinkerB loafB:E9 E1 O-19 O17 O-13 O-29
t2 block+ blinkerA blinkerB loafB:E-9 E-15 O-35 O1 O-29 O-45
t2 block+ beehiveB:E9 E23 E7 O-39 O-35 O-43
t2 block+ beehiveB:E9 E23 E7 O-35 O-25 E-43
t2 block+ beehiveB:E9 E23 E7 O-35 E-9 E-43
t2 block+ beehiveB:E9 E15 E-1 E1 E-25 O13
t1 block+ beehiveB:E9 E13 E13 O23 E19 O-9 E23
t2 block+ beehiveB:E9 E1 O-15 E-19 E-3 O-15 O-19
t1 block+ beehiveB:E9 E-1 O39 O37 O47 O37
t1 block+ beehiveB:E9 E-1 O15 O5 O-1 O27
t2 block+ beehiveB:E-9 E7 E-9 O-55 O-51 O-59
t2 block+ beehiveB:E-9 E7 E-9 O-51 O-41 E-59
t2 block+ beehiveB:E-9 E7 E-9 O-51 E-25 E-59
t1 block+ beehiveB:E-9 E-3 E-3 O7 E3 O-25 E7
t1 block+ beehiveB:E-9 E-17 O23 O21 O31 O21
t1 block+ beehiveB:E-9 E-17 O-1 O-11 O-17 O11
t2 block+ beehiveB:E-9 E-15 O-31 E-35 E-19 O-31 O-35
t2 block+ beehiveB:E-9 E-1 E-17 E-15 E-41 O-3
t1 block+ beehiveB+:E9 E-1 O15 O5 O27
t1 block+ beehiveB+:E-9 E-17 O-1 O-11 O11
t2 block+ beehiveB blinkerB:E-9 E-23 E-11 E-5 E-27 E-13
t1 block+ beehiveA:E9 E7 E27 O13 O9 O-3 E-13
t2 block+ beehiveA:E9 E23 E7 O-25 E-15 O-43
t2 block+ beehiveA:E-9 E7 E-9 O-41 E-31 O-59
t1 block+ beehiveA:E-9 E11 E-3 E7 O17 O-17 O-47
t1 block+ beehiveA:E-9 E-9 O-5 E29 O7 O-11 O-9
t1 block+ beehiveA:E-9 E-9 E11 O-3 O-7 O-19 E-29
t1 block+ beehiveA:E-9 E-1 E-17 O-31 O-9 O-9 O-11
t1 block+ beehiveA loafC blinkerA:E9 E15 O29 E31 O41
t1 block+ beehiveA loafC blinkerA:E-9 E-1 O13 E15 O25
t2 block+ bargeB:E9 E23 E7 E-25 O-11 E-51 E-43
t2 block+ bargeB:E-9 E7 E-9 E-41 O-27 E-67 E-59
t1 blinkerB+ blinkerA+ boatA block+:E-9 E-29 E19 E19 E27
t1 blinkerB+ blinkerA+ block+:E9 E27 E13 E23 O-1 O-43
t1 blinkerB+ blinkerA+ block+:E9 E15 O31 E35 E19 O27
t1 blinkerB+ blinkerA+ block+:E-9 E11 E-3 E7 O-17 O-59
t1 blinkerB+ blinkerA+ block+:E-9 E-1 O15 E19 E3 O11
t1 blinkerB+ blinkerA+ block+ loafB:E9 E27 E13 E23 O-1
t1 blinkerB+ blinkerA+ block+ loafB:E-9 E11 E-3 E7 O-17
t2 blinkerB loafC block++:E9 E1 O-13 O-71 E-15 O-25
t2 blinkerB loafC block++:E-9 E-15 O-29 O-87 E-31 O-41
t2 blinkerB loafC block+ beehiveB:E9 E1 O-13 E-15 O-25
t2 blinkerB loafC block+ beehiveB:E-9 E-15 O-29 E-31 O-41
t1 blinkerB boatC block+:E9 E15 E29 E35 E15 E31
t1 blinkerB boatC block+:E-9 E-1 E13 E19 E-1 E15
t2 blinkerB boatB block++ beehiveA:E9 E15 O23 E-5 E-3
t2 blinkerB boatB block++ beehiveA:E-9 E-1 O7 E-21 E-19
t2 blinkerB block+:E9 E9 E-19 O-21 E-19 O19
t1 blinkerB block+:E9 E15 O31 E35 E19 O45
t1 blinkerB block+:E9 E15 O31 E35 E19 E31
t1 blinkerB block+:E9 E15 E29 E3 O21 O7 E-15
t2 blinkerB block+:E9 E1 E-17 E5 O13 E47
t2 blinkerB block+:E9 E-7 E23 E-21 O-23 E-21
t2 blinkerB block+:E9 E-13 E57 E39 E33 O41 E5
t1 blinkerB block+:E-9 E-9 O-17 O-7 E-25 O15 E-27
t2 blinkerB block+:E-9 E-7 O-31 O1 O-3 O-31 E-13
t2 blinkerB block+:E-9 E-7 E-35 O-37 E-35 O3
t2 blinkerB block+:E-9 E-29 E41 E23 E17 O25 E-11
t2 blinkerB block+:E-9 E-23 E7 E-37 O-39 E-37
t2 blinkerB block+:E-9 E-15 E-33 E-11 O-3 O39 O35
t2 blinkerB block+:E-9 E-15 E-33 E-11 O-3 E31
t1 blinkerB block+:E-9 E-1 O19 O-17 O13 E25 E33
t1 blinkerB block+:E-9 E-1 O15 E19 E3 O29
t1 blinkerB block+:E-9 E-1 O15 E19 E3 E15
t1 blinkerB block+:E-9 E-1 O-19 O-11 E-25 O-9 O11
t1 blinkerB block+:E-9 E-1 E13 E-13 O5 O-9 E-31
t2 blinkerB block++:E9 E15 E21 E3 E-7 E13 O-7
t2 blinkerB block++:E9 E15 E15 E35 O13 O19
t2 blinkerB block++:E-9 E-1 E5 E-13 E-23 E-3 O-23
t2 blinkerB block++:E-9 E-1 E-1 E19 O-3 O3
t2 blinkerB block+++:E9 E9 E-3 O-5 O9 E3
t2 blinkerB block+++:E9 E9 E-3 O-5 O7
t1 blinkerB block+++:E9 E7 E19 O21 O7
t1 blinkerB block+++:E-9 E-9 E3 O5 O-9
t2 blinkerB block+++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O-9
t2 blinkerB block+++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O-7 E-13
t2 blinkerB block++ blinkerA boatA:E9 E15 O31 O29 O9
t2 blinkerB block++ blinkerA boatA:E9 E15 O31 E35 E15
t2 blinkerB block++ blinkerA boatA:E-9 E-1 O15 O13 O-7
t2 blinkerB block++ blinkerA boatA:E-9 E-1 O15 E19 E-1
t1 blinkerB block+ blinkerA:E-9 E-9 O-17 O-7 E-25 O15
t2 blinkerB block+ blinkerA:E-9 E-7 O1 O-9 E9 O-31
t2 blinkerB block+ blinkerA:E-9 E-23 E7 O-11 O-33 O-13
t2 blinkerB block+ blinkerA boatA:E-9 E-1 O15 O-7 O-27 O13
t1 blinkerB blinkerA+ boatA block+:E-9 E-29 E19 E19 E27 O29
t1 blinkerB blinkerA boatA block+:E9 E15 O17 E17 E19
t1 blinkerB blinkerA boatA block+:E-9 E-1 O1 E1 E3
t1 blinkerB blinkerA block+:E9 E23 E-1 E1 E3
t1 blinkerB blinkerA block+:E9 E-7 E23 O-21 O1 O-19
t1 blinkerB blinkerA block+:E-9 E7 E-23 O-5 O17 O-3
t1 blinkerB blinkerA block+:E-9 E7 E-17 E-15 E-13
t1 blinkerB blinkerA block+:E-9 E-23 E7 O-37 O-15 O-35
t1 blinkerB blinkerA block+ boatA:E-9 E-1 O-19 O-11 O11 O-9
t2 blinkerA+ block+ blinkerB:E9 E13 E13 O23 E29 O-19
t2 blinkerA+ block+ blinkerB:E-9 E-3 E-3 O7 E13 O-35
t1 blinkerA pond blinkerB block+:E-9 E-1 O19 O-17 O13 E33
t1 blinkerA loafD blinkerB block+:E-9 E-1 O19 O-17 O13 O29
t1 blinkerA boatA block+:E-9 E-1 O1 E1 E3 O13
t1 blinkerA block+:E9 E15 O31 E35 O3 O-37 E-29
t1 blinkerA block+:E9 E15 O31 E35 E19 E31 E37
t1 blinkerA block+:E9 E15 O31 E35 E19
t1 blinkerA block+:E9 E1 O33 O-7 O3 O-13 O-29
t2 blinkerA block+:E9 E1 E17 E-17 E25 O13
t1 blinkerA block+:E9 E1 E-13 O-15 E-1 O-3 O-7
t1 blinkerA block+:E-9 E-15 O17 O-23 O-13 O-29 O-45
t2 blinkerA block+:E-9 E-15 E1 E-33 E9 O-3
t2 blinkerA block+:E-9 E-15 E-33 E-11 O-3 O39
t1 blinkerA block+:E-9 E-15 E-29 O-31 E-17 O-19 O-23
t1 blinkerA block+:E-9 E-13 E-13 E-35 E-13 E-11 E9
t1 blinkerA block+:E-9 E-1 O15 E19 O-13 O-53 E-45
t1 blinkerA block+:E-9 E-1 O15 E19 E3 E15 E21
t1 blinkerA block+:E-9 E-1 O15 E19 E3
t2 blinkerA block+++:E9 E9 E-3 O-5 O9
t1 blinkerA block+++:E-9 E-9 E3 O5 O-7
t2 blinkerA block+++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O-7
t1 blinkerA block+ blinkerB:E9 E3 E3 O-7 E-13 O35 E5
t1 blinkerA block+ blinkerB:E-9 E-13 E-13 O-23 E-29 O19 E-11
t1 blinkerA block+ blinkerB+:E9 E3 E3 O-7 E-13 O35
t1 blinkerA block+ blinkerB+:E-9 E-13 E-13 O-23 E-29 O19
t2 blinkerA block+ blinkerB beehiveB:E9 E3 E3 E29 E27 E7
t2 blinkerA block+ blinkerB beehiveB:E-9 E-13 E-13 E13 E11 E-9
t1 blinkerA blinkerB+ block+:E-9 E-1 O19 O-17 O13
t1 blinkerA blinkerB shipB block+:E-9 E-1 O19 O-17 O13 O31
t1 blinkerA blinkerB block+:E9 E15 O31 O41 O47 E15 O17
t2 blinkerA blinkerB block+:E-9 E-23 E1 E-1 E-3
t1 blinkerA blinkerB block+:E-9 E-1 O19 O-17 O13 O27
t1 blinkerA blinkerB block+:E-9 E-1 O15 O25 O31 E-1 O1
t1 blinkerA blinkerB block++:E-9 E-1 O19 O-17 O13 O19
t1 blinkerA blinkerB block++:E-9 E-1 O19 O-17 O13 E25
t2 blinkerA blinkerB block+ beehiveB:E9 E3 E3 E29 O33 O13
t2 blinkerA blinkerB block+ beehiveB:E-9 E-13 E-13 E13 O17 O-3
t2 blinkerA beehiveA blinkerB++ block+:E9 E3 E3 O-7 O15
t2 blinkerA beehiveA blinkerB++ block+:E-9 E-13 E-13 O-23 O-1
t1 beehiveB+ block++:E9 E-1 O27
t1 beehiveB+ block++:E9 E-1 O17 O27
t1 beehiveB+ block++:E-9 E-17 O11
t1 beehiveB+ block++:E-9 E-17 O1 O11
t2 beehiveB+ block++:E-9 E-17 O1 O1 O-3
t2 beehiveB+ block+ beehiveA:E-9 E-17 O1 O1
t2 beehiveB block+:E9 E23 E11 E17 O1 O5 E-3
t2 beehiveB block+:E9 E13 E13 E-13 O-21 O-3 E19
t2 beehiveB block+:E-9 E7 E-5 E1 O-15 O-11 E-19
t2 beehiveB block+:E-9 E-7 O-11 E-45 O-23 O-5 O-7
t2 beehiveB block+:E-9 E-3 E-3 E-29 O-37 O-19 E3
t2 beehiveB block+:E-9 E-27 E-13 E-23 O-33 O1 O31
t2 beehiveB block+:E-9 E-15 E1 O15 O-7 O-7 O-5
t1 beehiveB block++:E9 E1 O-19 O-9 E33 E9
t2 beehiveB block++:E-9 E-23 E1 O1 O19 O5
t1 beehiveB block++:E-9 E-15 O-35 O-25 E17 E-7
t2 beehiveB block++:E-9 E-15 O-23 O-37 O-23 O3
t1 beehiveB block++:E-9 E-15 O-23 O-23 O-29 O-45
t2 beehiveB block+++:E9 E9 O-1 O-3 O27
t2 beehiveB block+++:E9 E9 E-3 O-5 O1
t2 beehiveB block+++:E-9 E-9 E9 O-29 O7
t2 beehiveB block+++:E-9 E-7 O-17 O-19 O11
t2 beehiveB block+++:E-9 E-7 O-17 O-19 O-21
t2 beehiveB block+++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O-15
t2 beehiveB block++++:E9 E9 O-1 O-3
t2 beehiveB block++++:E-9 E-7 O-17 O-19
t1 beehiveB block+++ beehiveA:E9 E7 E19 O21
t1 beehiveB block+++ beehiveA:E-9 E-9 E3 O5
t1 beehiveB block+ pond:E9 E13 E13 O-3 E21 E7
t1 beehiveB block+ pond:E-9 E-3 E-3 O-19 E5 E-9
t1 beehiveB block+ blinkerA++ blinkerB:E9 E13 E13 O23 O1
t1 beehiveB block+ blinkerA++ blinkerB:E-9 E-3 E-3 O7 O-15
t1 beehiveB beehiveA+ block+:E-9 E1 O-17 O-17
t2 beehiveB beehiveA boatC block+:E9 E-7 E-5 E-25 E5
t2 beehiveB beehiveA boatC block+:E-9 E-23 E-21 E-41 E-11
t2 beehiveB beehiveA block+:E9 E15 O17 E29 E-17 E29
t2 beehiveB beehiveA block+:E-9 E-1 O1 E13 E-33 E13
t2 beehiveB beehiveA block++:E9 E9 E-3 O-5 O-21
t2 beehiveB beehiveA block++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O-37
t1 beehiveB beehiveA block+++:E9 E9 E-9 O-7
t2 beehiveB beehiveA block+++:E9 E9 E-3 O-5
t2 beehiveB beehiveA block+++:E9 E7 E25 O23
t2 beehiveB beehiveA block+++:E-9 E-9 E9 O7
t1 beehiveB beehiveA block+++:E-9 E-7 E-25 O-23
t2 beehiveB beehiveA block+++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21
t2 beehiveB beehiveA blinkerB block+:E9 E9 E-19 O-21 E-19
t2 beehiveB beehiveA blinkerB block+:E-9 E-7 E-35 O-37 E-35
t2 beehiveB beehiveA blinkerB block+ blinkerA:E9 E7 O35 O33 O13
t2 beehiveB beehiveA blinkerB block+ blinkerA:E-9 E-9 O19 O17 O-3
t2 beehiveB beehiveA blinkerB block+ blinkerA:E-9 E-7 O-9 O-31 O-11
t1 beehiveB beehiveA blinkerB blinkerA block+:E9 E9 O-19 O-17 O3
t1 beehiveB beehiveA blinkerB blinkerA block+:E-9 E-9 O-7 O15 O-5
t1 beehiveB beehiveA blinkerB blinkerA block+:E-9 E-7 O-35 O-33 O-13
t2 beehiveA+ boatB block+:E9 E17 O19 O15 O-11
t2 beehiveA+ boatB block+:E-9 E1 O3 O-1 O-27
t2 beehiveA+ block+:E9 E17 O1 O11 O-11
t2 beehiveA+ block+:E-9 E1 O-15 O-5 O-27
t1 beehiveA boatA block+:E9 E15 O17 E13 E25
t1 beehiveA boatA block+:E-9 E-1 O1 E-3 E9
t1 beehiveA block+:E9 E9 O-15 O3 O15 E15 E1
t1 beehiveA block+:E9 E27 E13 O-15 E-21 O-5
t2 beehiveA block+:E9 E17 O-7 E-17 O-5 E-17 E1
t2 beehiveA block+:E9 E17 O-23 O-21 O-31 O-21
t1 beehiveA block+:E9 E15 O31 E35 E19 O31 O35
t1 beehiveA block+:E9 E15 O31 E35 E19 O27 E37
t2 beehiveA block+:E9 E15 O17 E29 E-17 E29 E57
t1 beehiveA block+:E9 E13 E13 E1 E1 O5 O-9
t2 beehiveA block+:E9 E13 E13 E-13 E-11 O-1 O-1
t1 beehiveA block+:E-9 E11 E-3 O-31 E-37 O-21
t2 beehiveA block+:E-9 E1 O-39 O-37 O-47 O-37
t2 beehiveA block+:E-9 E1 O-23 E-33 O-21 E-33 E-15
t1 beehiveA block+:E-9 E-7 O-31 O-13 O-1 E-1 E-15
t2 beehiveA block+:E-9 E-3 E-3 E-29 E-27 O-17 O-17
t1 beehiveA block+:E-9 E-3 E-3 E-15 E-15 O-11 O-25
t1 beehiveA block+:E-9 E-1 O15 E19 E3 O15 O19
t1 beehiveA block+:E-9 E-1 O15 E19 E3 O11 E21
t2 beehiveA block+:E-9 E-1 O1 E13 E-33 E13 E41
t2 beehiveA block++:E9 E29 E23 E31 O19 O3
t1 beehiveA block++:E-9 E7 E-17 O-17 O-35 O-21
t2 beehiveA block++:E-9 E13 E7 E15 O3 O-13
t2 beehiveA block+++:E9 E9 E-3 O-5 O29
t2 beehiveA block+++:E9 E7 E25 O23 O29
t2 beehiveA block+++:E-9 E-9 E9 O7 O13
t1 beehiveA block+++:E-9 E-7 E-25 O13 O-23
t2 beehiveA block+++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O13
t1 beehiveA block+ blinkerA:E9 E29 E-21 E-35 E-37 O-5
t1 beehiveA block+ blinkerA:E-9 E13 E-37 E-51 E-53 O-21
t2 beehiveA blinkerB block+:E9 E17 O19 O5 E55 O-11
t2 beehiveA blinkerB block+:E-9 E1 O3 O-11 E39 O-27
t2 beehiveA blinkerA block+:E9 E13 E13 O-13 E-15 O-13
t1 beehiveA blinkerA block+:E-9 E7 E-5 E-11 E11 E-3
t2 beehiveA blinkerA block+:E-9 E-3 E-3 O-29 E-31 O-29
t1 beehiveA blinkerA blinkerB block+:E9 E13 E13 E-13 E-11 E9
t1 beehiveA blinkerA blinkerB block+:E-9 E-3 E-3 E-29 O-33 O-13
t1 beehiveA blinkerA blinkerB block+:E-9 E-3 E-3 E-29 E-27 E-7
t1 tub block+:E9 E15 O31 E35 E19 O49 O55
t1 tub block+:E9 E15 O31 E35 E19 E27 O47
t1 tub block+:E-9 E-1 O15 E19 E3 O33 O39
t1 tub block+:E-9 E-1 O15 E19 E3 E11 O31
t1 tub block++:E-9 E-29 E21 E15 O19 O-23 O43
t2 shipB block+:E9 E9 O17 E25 E3 E23 E13
t1 shipB block+:E9 E9 E-9 O29 E-9 O19 E-31
t2 shipB block+:E9 E9 E-19 O-21 O9 O19 E-19
t1 shipB block+:E9 E15 O31 E35 E19 O45 E37
t1 shipB block+:E9 E15 O31 E35 E19 O29
t1 shipB block+:E9 E15 O31 E35 E19 E47
t1 shipB block+:E9 E15 O31 E35 E19 E31 O39
t2 shipB block+:E9 E1 E-17 E5 O13 E47 O73
t2 shipB block+:E9 E1 E-17 E5 O13 E47 E55
t2 shipB block+:E9 E-7 E23 E-21 O-23 O7 E-21
t2 shipB block+:E-9 E7 E-23 E-5 O-7 O23 E-5
t2 shipB block+:E-9 E-9 E-7 O-19 O-9 O21 E-7
t2 shipB block+:E-9 E-7 O1 E9 E-13 E7 E-3
t2 shipB block+:E-9 E-7 E-35 O-37 O-7 O3 E-35
t1 shipB block+:E-9 E-7 E-25 O13 E-25 O3 E-47
t2 shipB block+:E-9 E-23 E7 E-37 O-39 O-9 E-37
t2 shipB block+:E-9 E-15 E-33 E-11 O-3 O39 O19
t2 shipB block+:E-9 E-15 E-33 E-11 O-3 O39 E37
t2 shipB block+:E-9 E-15 E-33 E-11 O-3 E31 O57
t2 shipB block+:E-9 E-15 E-33 E-11 O-3 E31 E39
t1 shipB block+:E-9 E-1 O15 E19 E3 O29 E21
t1 shipB block+:E-9 E-1 O15 E19 E3 O13
t1 shipB block+:E-9 E-1 O15 E19 E3 E31
t1 shipB block+:E-9 E-1 O15 E19 E3 E15 O23
t1 shipB block+++:E-9 E-9 E3 O5 O-7 E3
t2 shipB block+++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O-9 E-19
t2 shipA block++:E9 E1 E5 E-11 O31 O-25
t2 shipA block++:E-9 E-15 E-11 E-27 O15 O-41
t1 shipA block++:E-9 E-1 E-5 E11 O-31 O25
t2 shipA block+++:E9 E1 E5 E-7 O-9 E-11
t2 shipA block+++:E-9 E-15 E-11 E-23 O-25 E-27
t1 pond block+:E9 E15 O31 E35 E19 O49
t1 pond block+:E9 E15 O31 E35 E19 E31 E41
t1 pond block+:E9 E15 O31 E35 E19 E27
t2 pond block+:E9 E13 E27 E-1 E-25 E5
t1 pond block+:E9 E1 E5 O-13 O-17 O19 O9
t2 pond block+:E-9 E-3 E11 E-17 E-41 E-11
t2 pond block+:E-9 E-15 E-33 E-11 O-3 O39 E17
t1 pond block+:E-9 E-15 E-11 O-29 O-33 O3 O-7
t1 pond block+:E-9 E-1 O15 E19 E3 O33
t1 pond block+:E-9 E-1 O15 E19 E3 E15 E25
t1 pond block+:E-9 E-1 O15 E19 E3 E11
t2 loafD block+:E-9 E-27 E-13 E-23 O-33 O1
t1 loafD block+:E-9 E-1 O15 E19 E3 E29
t2 loafD block+ blinkerB+ blinkerA+:E9 E-11 E3 E-7 O17
t2 loafD block+ blinkerB+ blinkerA+:E-9 E-27 E-13 E-23 O1
t2 loafB block+:E9 E9 O17 E25 E3 E25 E13
t1 loafB block+:E9 E15 O31 E35 E19 O31 O37
t1 loafB block+:E9 E15 O31 E35 E19 O31
t2 loafB block+:E9 E1 E-17 E5 O13 O37 O43
t2 loafB block+:E-9 E-7 O1 E9 E-13 E9 E-3
t2 loafB block+:E-9 E-15 E-33 E-11 O-3 O21 O27
t1 loafB block+:E-9 E-1 O15 E19 E3 O15 O21
t1 loafB block+:E-9 E-1 O15 E19 E3 O15
t2 boatD block+:E-9 E-15 O-31 E-13 O27 O-5 E-25
t1 boatC block+:E9 E7 E11 E-1 E-9 E-23
t1 boatC block+:E9 E1 O-19 E-9 O-1 E9 O3
t1 boatC block+:E-9 E-9 E-5 E-17 E-25 E-39
t1 boatC block+:E-9 E-15 O-35 E-25 O-17 E-7 O-13
t2 boatB block+:E9 E-11 E3 O31 E29 O9 E-13
t2 boatB block+:E-9 E-27 E-13 O15 E13 O-7 E-29
t2 boatB block+:E-9 E-1 O7 E21 O-13 O-21 O-19
t1 boatB block+:E-9 E-1 O15 E-3 O-43 O-11 E9
t2 boatB block+++:E9 E9 O17 O41 E-3 O-5
t2 boatB block+++:E-9 E-7 O1 O25 E-19 O-21
t2 boatA block+:E9 E29 E-19 E-19 E-27 O-37
t1 boatA block+:E9 E1 O33 E-5 E5 O-13 O-15
t1 boatA block+:E9 E1 O33 E-13 E-13 O-5
t2 boatA block+:E9 E1 O-15 O-13 E-3 E-3 E17
t2 boatA block+:E9 E1 E17 O-15 E1 O-13 O11
t2 boatA block+:E9 E1 E17 E11 E11 O15 O-5
t1 boatA block+:E9 E1 E17 E-17 E7 O-7 O-5
t2 boatA block+:E9 E1 E17 E-15 E7 E-19 O-19
t1 boatA block+:E9 E1 E-17 O-5 E9 O1
t2 boatA block+:E9 E1 E-13 O-3 E-7 E7 O17
t2 boatA block+:E9 E1 E-13 O-3 E-19 O11 E17
t2 boatA block+:E-9 E13 E-35 E-35 E-43 O-53
t1 boatA block+:E-9 E-15 O17 E-29 E-29 O-21
t1 boatA block+:E-9 E-15 O17 E-21 E-11 O-29 O-31
t2 boatA block+:E-9 E-15 O-31 O-29 E-19 E-19 E1
t2 boatA block+:E-9 E-15 E1 O-31 E-15 O-29 O-5
t2 boatA block+:E-9 E-15 E1 E-5 E-5 O-1 O-21
t1 boatA block+:E-9 E-15 E1 E-33 E-9 O-23 O-21
t2 boatA block+:E-9 E-15 E1 E-31 E-9 E-35 O-35
t1 boatA block+:E-9 E-15 E-33 O-21 E-7 O-15
t2 boatA block+:E-9 E-15 E-29 O-19 E-35 O-5 E1
t2 boatA block+:E-9 E-15 E-29 O-19 E-23 E-9 O1
t2 boatA block++:E9 E1 O-15 O-13 E-3 E-3
t2 boatA block++:E9 E1 E-13 O-3 E-7 E7
t2 boatA block++:E9 E-11 E3 O3 O1 E13
t2 boatA block++:E-9 E-27 E-13 O-13 O-15 E-3
t2 boatA block++:E-9 E-15 O-31 O-29 E-19 E-19
t2 boatA block++:E-9 E-15 E-29 O-19 E-23 E-9
t1 boatA block+++:E9 E1 E5 O-29 E-27 O-25
t1 boatA block+++:E-9 E-15 E-11 O-45 E-43 O-41
t1 boatA block+ loafA:E9 E1 E-7 O-5 E-15 O-23
t1 boatA block+ loafA:E-9 E-15 E-23 O-21 E-31 O-39
t2 boatA block+ blinkerB+ blinkerA:E9 E29 E-19 E-19 E-27 O-29
t2 boatA block+ blinkerB+ blinkerA:E-9 E13 E-35 E-35 E-43 O-45
t2 boatA block+ blinkerB+ blinkerA+:E9 E29 E-19 E-19 E-27
t2 boatA block+ blinkerB+ blinkerA+:E-9 E13 E-35 E-35 E-43
t2 boatA blinkerB block+:E9 E1 E-15 O-17 E-15 O27
t2 boatA blinkerB block+:E-9 E-15 O-17 E-17 E-19 O-29
t2 boatA blinkerB block+:E-9 E-15 E-31 O-33 E-31 O11
t2 boatA blinkerB block++:E9 E1 E-15 O-17 E-15 O11
t2 boatA blinkerB block++:E9 E1 E-15 O-17 E-15
t2 boatA blinkerB block++:E-9 E-15 E-31 O-33 E-31 O-5
t2 boatA blinkerB block++:E-9 E-15 E-31 O-33 E-31
t2 boatA blinkerB block++++:E9 E1 O-13 O-67 O-29
t2 boatA blinkerB block++++:E-9 E-15 O-29 O-83 O-45
t1 boatA blinkerB block++ blinkerA:E9 E1 O-15 O-13 O7
t1 boatA blinkerB block++ blinkerA:E9 E1 O-15 E-19 E1
t1 boatA blinkerB block++ blinkerA:E-9 E-15 O-31 O-29 O-9
t1 boatA blinkerB block++ blinkerA:E-9 E-15 O-31 E-35 E-15
t2 boatA blinkerB block+ blinkerA:E9 E1 O-1 E-1 E-3
t2 boatA blinkerB block+ blinkerA:E-9 E-15 O3 O-5 O-27 O-7
t2 boatA blinkerB block+ blinkerA:E-9 E-15 O-17 E-17 E-19
t1 boatA blinkerB blinkerA block+:E9 E1 O-15 O7 O27 O-13
t1 boatA blinkerB blinkerA block+:E-9 E-15 O-31 O-9 O11 O-29
t2 boatA beehiveB block+:E-9 E-15 O-17 E-13 E-25
dvgrn
Moderator
 
Posts: 3988
Joined: May 17th, 2009, 11:00 pm
Location: Madison, WI

Re: Geminoid Challenge

Postby dvgrn » October 27th, 2013, 6:10 pm

dvgrn wrote:Here's a trial run that I did with the new search script, looking for cheaper constructions of the two-block 180-degree OTT -- those two blocks show up over a thousand times in the block-move table's intermediate targets, with and without lots of other junk:...

Here's the other half of that search: there are 561 more intermediate targets that include the 180-degree 2-Blockic OTT, oriented so that the input glider is 90 degrees from the construction gliders. Again, run build-EO-lane-slow-salvo.py with one of the lines below copied to the clipboard. Or you can modify the script to cycle through the recipe list, or sort it -- if anyone wants a sample script that does that kind of thing, let me know.


t3 block+:E9 E27 E17 E39 E41 E9
t3 block+:E9 E1 O19 O-19 E13 O-9
t4 block+:E9 E1 E-13 E-7 E-19 O17
t3 block+:E-9 E11 E1 E23 E25 E-7
t3 block+:E-9 E-9 O-3 O-29 O3 O1
t4 block+:E-9 E-7 O-13 O13 O-19 O-17
t3 block+:E-9 E-3 E-3 O11 E-13 E-7
t4 block+:E-9 E-3 E-3 E13 E13 E-7
t3 block+:E-9 E-15 O3 O-35 E-3 O-25
t4 block+:E-9 E-15 E-29 E-23 E-35 O1
t4 block+:E-9 E-13 E-13 O-27 E-3 E-9
t3 block+:E-9 E-13 E-13 E-29 E-29 E-9
t4 block+:E-9 E-1 O-19 E-13 O-11 O-13
t3 block++:E9 E9 O27 O33 E21 E-5 E-17
t3 block++:E9 E9 O-19 E-31 E-11 O19 O-1
t3 block++:E9 E9 E13 O27 E-21 E-27 E11
t3 block++:E9 E9 E-9 O19 O-7 O27
t4 block++:E9 E9 E-3 O-5 O-37 O19
t4 block++:E9 E7 E25 O-3 O23 O-11
t3 block++:E9 E27 E17 E39 E31 E29 E9
t4 block++:E9 E23 E7 E-25 E-39 O-41 O-15
t4 block++:E9 E23 E-7 E27 O25 O-9
t3 block++:E9 E17 O23 O-5 O-37 E-33 E11
t4 block++:E9 E15 O35 O17 O11 O7 O17
t3 block++:E9 E15 O-3 O31 O27 O17 O-5
t3 block++:E9 E15 E-1 E7 O19 O-15 O17
t4 block++:E9 E13 E27 E21 E3 E-5 E1
t4 block++:E9 E1 E-15 E3 O-25 E7 E-41
t3 block++:E9 E-7 E27 O29 E-1 O-13 O-31
t3 block++:E9 E-7 E23 O-21 E-33 E-13 O-3
t4 block++:E9 E-7 E23 E-5 O-7 O-41
t3 block++:E9 E-7 E23 E-11 O-9 O25
t4 block++:E-9 E7 E-9 E-41 E-55 O-57 O-31
t3 block++:E-9 E7 E-23 O-5 E-17 E3 O13
t4 block++:E-9 E7 E-23 E11 O9 O-25
t3 block++:E-9 E7 E-17 E-3 O-1 E-51 E-9
t3 block++:E-9 E11 E1 E23 E15 E13 E-7
t3 block++:E-9 E1 O7 O-21 O-53 E-49 E-5
t3 block++:E-9 E-9 O-19 O-7 E-19 E1 O11
t3 block++:E-9 E-9 O-13 O-5 E-35 E-27 O15
t4 block++:E-9 E-9 E9 O-19 O7 O-27
t4 block++:E-9 E-7 O3 O-9 E3 E-17 O-27
t3 block++:E-9 E-7 O11 O17 E5 E-21 E-33
t3 block++:E-9 E-7 O-35 E-47 E-27 O3 O-17
t4 block++:E-9 E-7 O-3 O-11 E19 E11 O-31
t3 block++:E-9 E-7 E-3 O11 E-37 E-43 E-5
t3 block++:E-9 E-7 E-25 O3 O-23 O11
t4 block++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O-53 O3
t4 block++:E-9 E-3 E11 E5 E-13 E-21 E-15
t3 block++:E-9 E-3 E-3 O11 E-11 E-7 E-1
t3 block++:E-9 E-23 E7 O-37 E-49 E-29 O-19
t4 block++:E-9 E-23 E7 O-11 E1 E-19 O-29
t3 block++:E-9 E-23 E7 E-27 O-25 O9
t4 block++:E-9 E-23 E7 E-21 O-23 O-57
t3 block++:E-9 E-23 E11 O13 E-17 O-29 O-47
t4 block++:E-9 E-23 E1 E-13 O-15 E35 E-7
t4 block++:E-9 E-15 O3 O-31 O-27 O-23 O5
t4 block++:E-9 E-15 O-23 O-37 O-23 O-37 O15
t4 block++:E-9 E-15 E-31 E-13 O-41 E-9 E-57
t4 block++:E-9 E-13 E-13 O-27 E-5 E-9 E-15
t3 block++:E-9 E-1 O7 O21 O7 O21 O-31
t4 block++:E-9 E-1 O19 O1 O-5 O-9 O1
t3 block++:E-9 E-1 O-19 O15 O11 O7 O-21
t3 block++:E-9 E-1 O-19 O15 O11 O1 O-21
t3 block++:E-9 E-1 E-17 E-9 O3 O-31 O1
t3 block+++:E9 E9 O27 O33 E21 E-5 O-19
t3 block+++:E9 E9 O27 O33 E21 E-5 E-25
t3 block+++:E9 E9 E-9 O19 O-7 O35
t3 block+++:E9 E9 E-9 O19 O-7
t4 block+++:E9 E9 E-3 O-5 O7 E9 E-37
t4 block+++:E9 E9 E-3 O-5 O19
t4 block+++:E9 E9 E-3 O-5 O-47 O19
t3 block+++:E9 E7 O-1 O9 O-17 O9 E-13
t3 block+++:E9 E7 O-1 O9 O-17 O9
t4 block+++:E9 E7 E25 O-3 O23 O-19
t4 block+++:E9 E7 E25 O-3 O23
t4 block+++:E9 E27 E13 O21 O-7 E-37 E-53
t4 block+++:E9 E23 E7 O-19 O23 E21 E-13
t3 block+++:E9 E23 E7 O-19 O17 E19 E51
t3 block+++:E9 E23 E7 E-41 E-15 O-47 E-39
t4 block+++:E9 E23 E-7 E27 O25
t4 block+++:E9 E23 E-1 O-17 O-25 E-1 E-5
t3 block+++:E9 E15 E33 E15 E19 O21 O65
t4 block+++:E9 E1 O-15 O-27 O-23 E3 O-17
t4 block+++:E9 E1 O-13 O-67 O-29 E5 O-67
t4 block+++:E9 E1 E17 O23 E1 O-29 O-45
t4 block+++:E9 E1 E17 E-11 O9 E29 O13
t4 block+++:E9 E-7 E9 O35 O-1 E-3 E-35
t4 block+++:E9 E-7 E23 E-5 O-7 O-49
t4 block+++:E9 E-7 E23 E-5 O-7
t3 block+++:E9 E-7 E23 E-11 O-9 O33
t3 block+++:E9 E-7 E23 E-11 O-9
t4 block+++:E9 E-7 E-11 E-9 E-9 E19 E29
t4 block+++:E-9 E7 E-9 O-35 O7 E5 E-29
t3 block+++:E-9 E7 E-9 O-35 O1 E3 E35
t3 block+++:E-9 E7 E-9 E-57 E-31 O-63 E-55
t4 block+++:E-9 E7 E-23 E11 O9 O-33
t4 block+++:E-9 E7 E-23 E11 O9
t4 block+++:E-9 E7 E-17 O-33 O-41 E-17 E-21
t4 block+++:E-9 E11 E-3 O5 O-23 E-53 E-69
t4 block+++:E-9 E-9 O-17 O-7 O-33 O1 E1
t3 block+++:E-9 E-9 O-17 O-7 O-33 O-7 E-29
t3 block+++:E-9 E-9 O-17 O-7 O-33 O-7
t4 block+++:E-9 E-9 E9 O-19 O7 O-35
t4 block+++:E-9 E-9 E9 O-19 O7
t3 block+++:E-9 E-7 O11 O17 E5 E-21 O-35
t3 block+++:E-9 E-7 O11 O17 E5 E-21 E-41
t3 block+++:E-9 E-7 O1 O-9 O17 O-17 E-17
t3 block+++:E-9 E-7 E-25 O3 O-23 O19
t3 block+++:E-9 E-7 E-25 O3 O-23
t4 block+++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O3
t4 block+++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O-9 E-7 E-53
t4 block+++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O-63 O3
t3 block+++:E-9 E-23 E7 E-27 O-25 O17
t3 block+++:E-9 E-23 E7 E-27 O-25
t4 block+++:E-9 E-23 E7 E-21 O-23 O-65
t4 block+++:E-9 E-23 E7 E-21 O-23
t3 block+++:E-9 E-23 E1 O17 O25 E1 E5
t4 block+++:E-9 E-23 E-7 O19 O-17 E-19 E-51
t4 block+++:E-9 E-23 E-27 E-25 E-25 E3 E13
t4 block+++:E-9 E-15 O-31 O-43 O-39 E-13 O-33
t4 block+++:E-9 E-15 O-29 O-83 O-45 E-11 O-83
t4 block+++:E-9 E-15 E1 O7 E-15 O-45 O-61
t4 block+++:E-9 E-15 E1 E-27 O-7 E13 O-3
t3 block+++:E-9 E-1 O13 O67 O29 E-5 O67
t3 block+++:E-9 E-1 E17 E-1 E3 O5 O49
t4 block++++:E9 E9 E-3 O-5 O7 E9
t4 block++++:E9 E9 E-3 O-5 O29 O5
t4 block++++:E9 E9 E-3 O-5 O1 O11
t3 block++++:E9 E7 E19 O21 O15 O5
t4 block++++:E9 E23 E7 O-19 O23 E21
t3 block++++:E9 E23 E7 O-19 O17 E19
t4 block++++:E9 E23 E7 E-41 E-13 E-19
t4 block++++:E9 E1 O-15 O-27 O-23 E3
t4 block++++:E9 E1 O-13 O-67 O-29 E5
t3 block++++:E9 E-7 E9 O35 O-7 E-5
t4 block++++:E9 E-7 E9 O35 O-1 E-3
t4 block++++:E-9 E7 E-9 O-35 O7 E5
t3 block++++:E-9 E7 E-9 O-35 O1 E3
t4 block++++:E-9 E7 E-9 E-57 E-29 E-35
t3 block++++:E-9 E-9 E3 O5 O-9 E-7
t3 block++++:E-9 E-9 E3 O5 O-7 O-3
t3 block++++:E-9 E-9 E3 O5 O-7 E-9
t3 block++++:E-9 E-9 E3 O5 O-1 O-11
t4 block++++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O13 O-11
t4 block++++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O-9 O-13
t4 block++++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O-9 E-7
t4 block++++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O-7 E-9
t4 block++++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O-15 O-5
t3 block++++:E-9 E-23 E-7 O19 O-23 E-21
t4 block++++:E-9 E-23 E-7 O19 O-17 E-19
t4 block++++:E-9 E-15 O-31 O-43 O-39 E-13
t4 block++++:E-9 E-15 O-29 O-83 O-45 E-11
t3 block++++:E-9 E-1 O15 O27 O23 E-3
t3 block++++:E-9 E-1 O13 O67 O29 E-5
t3 block++++ blinkerA boatA:E9 E15 O29 O83 O45
t3 block++++ blinkerA boatA:E-9 E-1 O13 O67 O29
t3 block++++ beehiveA:E-9 E7 E11 E9 E-25
t3 block++++ beehiveA beehiveB:E9 E23 E27 E25
t3 block++++ beehiveA beehiveB:E-9 E7 E11 E9
t3 block+++ shipB:E-9 E-9 E3 O5 O-9 E-19
t3 block+++ shipA:E9 E15 E11 E23 O25 E27
t3 block+++ shipA:E-9 E-1 E-5 E7 O9 E11
t3 block+++ boatD:E-9 E-9 O-17 O-41 E3 O5
t3 block+++ boatA:E9 E15 E33 E15 E19 O21
t4 block+++ boatA:E9 E15 E-1 E31 O31
t3 block+++ boatA:E-9 E-1 E17 E-1 E3 O5
t4 block+++ boatA:E-9 E-1 E-17 E15 O15
t4 block+++ blinkerB:E9 E1 O-15 O-23 O-19 E3
t4 block+++ blinkerB:E-9 E-15 O-31 O-39 O-35 E-13
t3 block+++ blinkerA:E9 E23 E11 E19 E9 O45
t3 block+++ blinkerA:E-9 E7 E-5 E3 E-7 O29
t3 block+++ beehiveB:E9 E17 O23 O-5 O-37 E-33
t3 block+++ beehiveB:E-9 E1 O7 O-21 O-53 E-49
t3 block+++ beehiveA:E9 E7 E19 O21 O15
t3 block+++ beehiveA:E-9 E-9 E3 O5 O-1
t3 block+++ beehiveA beehiveB:E9 E23 E27 E25 E25
t3 block+++ beehiveA beehiveB:E-9 E7 E11 E9 E9
t4 block++ pond:E9 E27 E27 E-7 E23 E-11
t4 block++ pond:E9 E23 E27 E23 E-7 E-11
t3 block++ pond:E9 E1 E-15 E3 E-3 O11
t4 block++ pond:E-9 E7 E11 E7 E-23 E-27
t4 block++ pond:E-9 E11 E11 E-23 E7 E-27
t3 block++ pond:E-9 E-15 E-31 E-13 E-19 O-5
t3 block++ boatD beehiveB blinkerA:E9 E1 O-7 E21 E19
t3 block++ boatD beehiveB blinkerA:E-9 E-15 O-23 E5 E3
t4 block++ boatA:E9 E15 O17 E33 O29 E15
t4 block++ boatA:E9 E15 E-1 E31 O31 O5
t4 block++ boatA:E-9 E-1 O1 E17 O13 E-1
t4 block++ boatA:E-9 E-1 E-17 E15 O15 O-11
t3 block++ blinkerB:E9 E-7 E5 E3 E-3 O3 O13
t3 block++ blinkerB:E-9 E-7 O11 O17 E5 E-21 O-31
t4 block++ blinkerB:E-9 E-7 O-3 O-11 E19 E11
t3 block++ blinkerB:E-9 E-23 E-11 E-13 E-19 O-13 O-3
t3 block++ blinkerB+ blinkerA:E9 E9 O13 E-3 E15
t3 block++ blinkerB+ blinkerA:E-9 E-7 O-3 E-19 E-1
t3 block++ blinkerA:E9 E9 O27 O33 E21 E-5
t4 block++ blinkerA:E9 E7 O-11 O-17 E-5 E21 O31
t4 block++ blinkerA:E-9 E-9 O-27 O-33 E-21 E5 O15
t3 block++ blinkerA:E-9 E-9 O-13 O-5 E-35 E-27
t3 block++ blinkerA:E-9 E-7 O11 O17 E5 E-21
t3 block++ blinkerA:E-9 E-15 O-31 O-9 E1 O-29 O13
t3 block++ blinkerA:E-9 E-15 E-31 O-21 O-9 E1 O13
t3 block++ beehiveB tub:E9 E17 O23 O-5 O-37 E-13
t3 block++ beehiveB tub:E-9 E1 O7 O-21 O-53 E-29
t3 block++ beehiveB pond:E9 E17 O23 O-5 O-37
t3 block++ beehiveB pond:E-9 E1 O7 O-21 O-53
t3 block++ beehiveA:E9 E15 O23 O37 O23
t4 block++ beehiveA:E9 E15 E31 O33 E43 E9
t3 block++ beehiveA:E-9 E-1 O7 O21 O7 O21
t3 block++ beehiveA:E-9 E-1 O7 O21 O7
t4 block++ beehiveA:E-9 E-1 E15 O17 E27 E-7
t4 block++ beehiveA tub:E9 E-1 O-7 O21 O53 E29
t4 block++ beehiveA tub:E-9 E-17 O-23 O5 O37 E13
t4 block++ beehiveA pond:E9 E-1 O-7 O21 O53
t4 block++ beehiveA pond:E-9 E-17 O-23 O5 O37
t3 block++ beaconA2 boatC blinkerA:E9 E9 O27 O33 E21
t3 block++ beaconA2 boatC blinkerA:E-9 E-7 O11 O17 E5
t4 block+ tub:E9 E15 E21 E11 E21 O-13 O7
t4 block+ tub:E-9 E-1 E5 E-5 E5 O-29 O-9
t3 block+ shipB:E9 E17 O23 O-5 O-37 E11 E-27
t3 block+ shipB:E-9 E1 O7 O-21 O-53 E-5 E-43
t4 block+ pond:E9 E9 E7 O17 O7 E17 E-5
t3 block+ pond:E9 E17 O23 O-5 O-37 E11
t3 block+ pond:E9 E-7 E27 O29 E-1 O-13 O-39
t4 block+ pond:E9 E-7 E19 E-11 E29
t3 block+ pond:E9 E-11 E3 O31 E-17 O23 E-29
t4 block+ pond:E-9 E7 E-5 E3 E-19 E-27 E-23
t3 block+ pond:E-9 E7 E-17 O-11 E-21 E-15 E-3
t3 block+ pond:E-9 E7 E-17 O-11 E-21 E-13 E-25
t3 block+ pond:E-9 E1 O7 O-21 O-53 E-5
t4 block+ pond:E-9 E-7 E-9 O1 O-9 E1 E-21
t3 block+ pond:E-9 E-27 E-13 O15 E-33 O7 E-45
t4 block+ pond:E-9 E-23 E3 E-27 E13
t3 block+ pond:E-9 E-23 E11 O13 E-17 O-29 O-55
t4 block+ pond:E-9 E-23 E1 O-5 E5 E-3 E9
t4 block+ pond:E-9 E-23 E1 O-5 E5 E-1 E-13
t3 block+ pond:E-9 E-23 E-11 E-19 E3 E11 E7
t4 block+ pond:E-9 E-15 E-29 O-29 O-3 E5 O-21
t4 block+ mangoA1:E9 E7 O23 O23 O23 O-5 O-23
t4 block+ mangoA1:E-9 E-9 O7 O7 O7 O-21 O-39
t4 block+ loafD:E9 E1 O19 O-15 O-11 O21
t4 block+ loafD:E-9 E-23 E1 E-13 O-15 E35
t4 block+ loafD:E-9 E-15 O3 O-31 O-27 O5
t4 block+ loafC blinkerB:E9 E1 O19 O-3 E23 O21
t4 block+ loafC blinkerB:E-9 E-15 O3 O-19 E7 O5
t4 block+ loafC blinkerA+:E9 E1 O19 O-15 E23 E21
t4 block+ loafC blinkerA+:E-9 E-15 O3 O-31 E7 E5
t3 block+ loafB:E9 E9 E13 O27 E-21 E-27 E7
t3 block+ loafB:E9 E1 E-13 O7 E17 O-15 O29
t3 block+ loafB:E-9 E-7 E-35 O3 E-39 O-7 E-23
t3 block+ loafB:E-9 E-7 E-3 O11 E-37 E-43 E-9
t3 block+ loafB:E-9 E-23 E7 E-37 E-41 O-9 E-25
t3 block+ loafB:E-9 E-15 E-29 O-9 E1 O-31 O13
t3 block+ loafA:E9 E1 O-13 O-39 E-15 E-11
t3 block+ loafA:E-9 E-15 O-29 O-55 E-31 E-27
t3 block+ boatD:E-9 E-15 O-23 E-37 O-25 O5 O3
t4 block+ boatB:E-9 E-3 E-3 O-3 E11 O-3 E-29
t4 block+ boatA blinkerA:E9 E15 O-3 E33 O5 O29 E15
t4 block+ boatA blinkerA:E-9 E-1 O-19 E17 O-11 O13 E-1
t3 block+ blinkerB:E9 E9 O19 O7 E-21 O-17 E-3
t3 block+ blinkerB:E9 E17 O25 O-47 O-9 O33 O-33
t4 block+ blinkerB:E9 E15 E31 O33 E43 E9 O21
t4 block+ blinkerB:E9 E1 O19 O-3 E23 O21 O23
t4 block+ blinkerB:E9 E1 E-15 O9 E-23 O-5 E21
t3 block+ blinkerB:E9 E-7 E27 O29 E-1 O-13
t3 block+ blinkerB:E9 E-7 E23 O5 E-23 O-19 E-5
t3 block+ blinkerB:E9 E-7 E23 E-21 O-23 O7 E13
t3 block+ blinkerB:E-9 E1 O9 O-63 O-25 O17 O-49
t3 block+ blinkerB:E-9 E-9 O-27 E-33 O-3 O3 O1
t3 block+ blinkerB:E-9 E-7 O3 O-9 E-37 O-33 E-19
t3 block+ blinkerB:E-9 E-7 E-35 O-37 O-7 O3 E-1
t3 block+ blinkerB:E-9 E-23 E7 O-11 E-39 O-35 E-21
t3 block+ blinkerB:E-9 E-23 E7 E-37 O-39 O-9 E-3
t3 block+ blinkerB:E-9 E-23 E11 O13 E-17 O-29
t4 block+ blinkerB:E-9 E-15 O3 O-19 E7 O5 O7
t4 block+ blinkerB:E-9 E-15 E-31 O-7 E-39 O-21 E5
t4 block+ blinkerB:E-9 E-1 O-19 E-11 O-29 E-19 E-25
t4 block+ blinkerB:E-9 E-1 E15 O17 E27 E-7 O5
t3 block+ blinkerB blinkerA:E9 E9 O13 E-3 E15 O-11
t3 block+ blinkerB blinkerA:E-9 E-7 O11 O17 E5 O-21
t3 block+ blinkerB blinkerA:E-9 E-7 O-3 E-19 E-1 O-27
t4 block+ blinkerA:E9 E9 O-19 E9 O5 O19 E-9
t4 block+ blinkerA:E9 E3 E3 O21 E27 E-11 O-9
t3 block+ blinkerA:E9 E23 E7 E-39 O-21 E-21 E-3
t3 block+ blinkerA:E9 E15 O35 E3 O-25 O7 O25
t3 block+ blinkerA:E9 E-7 E27 O29 E-1 O-13 O-35
t4 block+ blinkerA:E9 E-7 E23 O-21 E7 O3 E-11
t3 block+ blinkerA:E9 E-7 E23 E-23 E-7 O5 O-19
t3 block+ blinkerA:E-9 E7 E-9 E-55 O-37 E-37 E-19
t4 block+ blinkerA:E-9 E-7 O-35 E-7 O-11 O3 E-25
t3 block+ blinkerA:E-9 E-7 E-37 E-21 E3 O-9 O-33
t4 block+ blinkerA:E-9 E-23 E7 O-37 E-9 O-13 E-27
t3 block+ blinkerA:E-9 E-23 E7 E-39 E-23 O-11 O-35
t3 block+ blinkerA:E-9 E-23 E11 O13 E-17 O-29 O-51
t3 block+ blinkerA:E-9 E-15 O3 E-5 O13 E3 E9
t3 block+ blinkerA:E-9 E-15 E-29 O-9 E1 O13
t4 block+ blinkerA:E-9 E-13 E-13 O5 E11 E-27 O-25
t3 block+ blinkerA:E-9 E-1 O19 E-13 O-41 O-9 O9
t4 block+ blinkerA+:E9 E1 O19 O-15 E23 E21 E23
t3 block+ blinkerA+:E9 E1 O-15 O7 E17 O29
t4 block+ blinkerA+:E-9 E-15 O3 O-31 E7 E5 E7
t3 block+ blinkerA+:E-9 E-15 O-31 O-9 E1 O13
t3 block+ blinkerA+ blinkerB+:E9 E27 E17 E9 E27 E41
t4 block+ blinkerA+ blinkerB+:E9 E-11 E-1 E7 E-11 E-25
t3 block+ blinkerA+ blinkerB+:E-9 E11 E1 E-7 E11 E25
t4 block+ blinkerA+ blinkerB+:E-9 E-27 E-17 E-9 E-27 E-41
t3 block+ blinkerA blinkerB:E-9 E-15 O-31 O-9 E1 E-39 O13
t3 block+ blinkerA beehiveB:E9 E-7 E23 E-23 E-7 O5
t3 block+ blinkerA beehiveB:E-9 E-7 E-37 E-21 E3 O-9
t3 block+ blinkerA beehiveB:E-9 E-23 E7 E-39 E-23 O-11
t3 block+ beehiveB:E9 E7 O-11 O1 O13 O19 O17
t4 block+ beehiveB:E9 E3 E3 E15 O31 E27 O13
t3 block+ beehiveB:E9 E27 E17 E9 E19 E31 E41
t3 block+ beehiveB:E9 E15 E-1 E7 O-15 O-7 O11
t3 block+ beehiveB:E-9 E11 E1 E-7 E3 E15 E25
t3 block+ beehiveB:E-9 E-9 O-27 O-15 O-3 O3 O1
t4 block+ beehiveB:E-9 E-9 O-17 O-1 E-1 E-25 O-29
t4 block+ beehiveB:E-9 E-7 O-31 O-3 O-11 O-27 O-7
t3 block+ beehiveB:E-9 E-7 E-27 O-3 E11 E-13 E-7
t3 block+ beehiveB:E-9 E-3 E-3 E-33 E-7 E-1 E-31
t3 block+ beehiveB:E-9 E-15 O-35 O-31 O-9 E1 O13
t4 block+ beehiveB:E-9 E-13 E-13 E-1 O15 E11 O-3
t4 block+ beehiveB:E-9 E-1 E15 O23 O-27 O-17 E-5
t3 block+ beehiveB:E-9 E-1 E-17 E-9 O-31 O-23 O-5
t4 block+ beehiveA:E9 E3 E-1 E-19 E-23 E-25 E-27
t4 block+ beehiveA:E9 E29 E-21 E-35 E-37 E-23 O-33
t4 block+ beehiveA:E9 E23 E23 E-7 O7 E3 E-11
t3 block+ beehiveA:E9 E13 E13 O13 E-9 O-13 E-27
t4 block+ beehiveA:E9 E13 E13 E35 O15 O-1 E-13
t4 block+ beehiveA:E9 E1 O19 E13 E-3 O-15 E25
t4 block+ beehiveA:E9 E1 E-15 E3 O-21 E-29 O-13
t4 block+ beehiveA:E-9 E7 E7 E-23 O-9 E-13 E-27
t4 block+ beehiveA:E-9 E13 E-37 E-51 E-53 E-39 O-49
t3 block+ beehiveA:E-9 E-9 O15 O-13 O-5 O11 O-9
t4 block+ beehiveA:E-9 E-9 E11 O-13 E-27 E-3 E-9
t3 block+ beehiveA:E-9 E-3 E-3 O-3 E-25 O-29 E-43
t4 block+ beehiveA:E-9 E-3 E-3 E19 O-1 O-17 E-29
t4 block+ beehiveA:E-9 E-15 O3 E-3 E-19 O-31 E9
t3 block+ beehiveA:E-9 E-15 E-31 O-39 O11 O1 E-11
t4 block+ beehiveA:E-9 E-15 E-31 E-13 O-37 E-45 O-29
t4 block+ beehiveA:E-9 E-13 E-17 E-35 E-39 E-41 E-43
t4 block+ beehiveA shipB:E9 E3 E-1 E-19 E-23 E-25
t4 block+ beehiveA shipB:E-9 E-13 E-17 E-35 E-39 E-41
t4 block+ beehiveA pond:E9 E3 E-1 E-19 E-23
t4 block+ beehiveA pond:E-9 E-13 E-17 E-35 E-39
t4 block+ beehiveA mangoA1:E9 E7 O23 O23 O23 O-5
t4 block+ beehiveA mangoA1:E-9 E-9 O7 O7 O7 O-21
t4 block+ beehiveA blinkerA+ blinkerB+:E9 E-11 E-1 E7 E-11
t4 block+ beehiveA blinkerA+ blinkerB+:E-9 E-27 E-17 E-9 E-27
t3 block+ beehiveA beehiveB:E9 E23 E27 E29 E31
t4 block+ beehiveA beehiveB:E9 E-11 E-1 E7
t3 block+ beehiveA beehiveB:E-9 E7 E11 E13 E15
t4 block+ beehiveA beehiveB:E-9 E-27 E-17 E-9
t3 blinkerB+ block+:E9 E3 E3 O-1 O33 O33 E15
t3 blinkerB+ block+:E-9 E-13 E-13 O-17 O17 O17 E-1
t4 blinkerB+ block+:E-9 E-1 O15 O-7 E-17 O-29
t4 blinkerB+ block+ loafC beehiveB:E9 E-7 E5 E-3 E7
t4 blinkerB+ block+ loafC beehiveB:E-9 E-23 E-11 E-19 E-9
t4 blinkerB boatB block++ beehiveA:E9 E15 O23 E-5 E-3
t4 blinkerB boatB block++ beehiveA:E-9 E-1 O7 E-21 E-19
t4 blinkerB boatB beehiveA block+:E9 E15 O23 E-5 E-3 O25
t4 blinkerB boatB beehiveA block+:E-9 E-1 O7 E-21 E-19 O9
t4 blinkerB block+:E9 E9 E9 E-7 O19 O-19 O5
t4 blinkerB block+:E9 E15 E29 O9 E-1 O-13
t4 blinkerB block+:E9 E13 E13 O13 O-15 O-19 O23
t4 blinkerB block+:E9 E-7 E23 E7 E-9 O-21 O3
t4 blinkerB block+:E-9 E-9 E21 E5 E-19 O-7 O17
t4 blinkerB block+:E-9 E-7 E-7 E-23 O3 O-35 O-11
t4 blinkerB block+:E-9 E-3 E-3 O-3 O-31 O-35 O7
t4 blinkerB block+:E-9 E-23 E7 E-9 E-25 O-37 O-13
t4 blinkerB block+:E-9 E-1 E13 O-7 E-17 O-29
t4 blinkerB block++:E9 E7 O-11 O-17 E-5 E21 O25
t4 blinkerB block++:E9 E7 O-11 O-17 E-5 E21
t4 blinkerB block++:E-9 E-9 O-27 O-33 E-21 E5 O9
t4 blinkerB block++:E-9 E-9 O-27 O-33 E-21 E5
t4 blinkerB block++:E-9 E-1 O15 O-7 E-17 O13 O-29
t4 blinkerB block++:E-9 E-1 E15 O5 O-7 E-17 O-29
t4 blinkerB block+++:E9 E9 E-3 O-5 O9 E3
t4 blinkerB block+++:E9 E9 E-3 O-5 O7
t3 blinkerB block+++:E9 E7 E19 O21 O7
t4 blinkerB block+++:E9 E-7 E5 E-3 E7 O-29
t3 blinkerB block+++:E-9 E-9 E3 O5 O-9
t4 blinkerB block+++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O-9
t4 blinkerB block+++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O-7 E-13
t4 blinkerB block+++:E-9 E-23 E-11 E-19 E-9 O-45
t4 blinkerB block+++ boatA:E9 E15 O35 O9 O9
t4 blinkerB block+++ boatA:E-9 E-1 O19 O-7 O-7
t4 blinkerB block++ boatA beehiveA:E9 E15 E33 E17 O5
t4 blinkerB block++ boatA beehiveA:E-9 E-1 E17 E1 O-11
t4 blinkerB block+ blinkerA:E-9 E-1 O15 O-7 E-17 E23 O-29
t4 blinkerB block+ beehiveA:E9 E9 E9 E-7 O19 O-19
t4 blinkerB block+ beehiveA:E9 E-7 E23 E7 E-9 O-21
t4 blinkerB block+ beehiveA:E-9 E7 E-23 E23 E7 O-5
t4 blinkerB block+ beehiveA:E-9 E-9 E21 E5 E-19 O-7
t4 blinkerB block+ beehiveA:E-9 E-7 E-7 E-23 O3 O-35
t4 blinkerB block+ beehiveA:E-9 E-23 E7 E-9 E-25 O-37
t4 blinkerB blinkerA block+:E9 E15 O-3 E15 O-7 E-15 E-13
t4 blinkerB blinkerA block+:E-9 E-1 O-19 E-1 O-23 E-31 E-29
t4 blinkerA+ blinkerB block++:E9 E7 O3 E19 E1
t4 blinkerA+ blinkerB block++:E-9 E-9 O-13 E3 E-15
t4 blinkerA block+:E9 E9 E7 O19 O9 O-21 E-27
t4 blinkerA block+:E9 E-7 E23 E5 O7 O-23 E-29
t4 blinkerA block+:E-9 E-9 E19 O21 O-9 O-19 E-15
t4 blinkerA block+:E-9 E-7 O11 E17 O-13 O-19 O-17
t4 blinkerA block+:E-9 E-7 E-9 O3 O-7 O-37 E-43
t4 blinkerA block+:E-9 E-23 E7 E-11 O-9 O-39 E-45
t4 blinkerA block++:E9 E7 O-11 O-17 E-5 E21 E45
t4 blinkerA block++:E-9 E-9 O-27 O-33 E-21 E5 E29
t4 blinkerA block+++:E9 E9 E-3 O-5 O9
t3 blinkerA block+++:E9 E1 O33 O-7 O-25 E-21
t3 blinkerA block+++:E-9 E-9 E3 O5 O-7
t4 blinkerA block+++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O-7
t3 blinkerA block+++:E-9 E-15 O17 O-23 O-41 E-37
t4 blinkerA block+++ blinkerB:E9 E15 O35 O17 O11 O7
t4 blinkerA block+++ blinkerB:E-9 E-1 O19 O1 O-5 O-9
t3 blinkerA block++ blinkerB+:E9 E15 E21 O21 E19 E-5
t3 blinkerA block++ blinkerB+:E-9 E-1 E5 O5 E3 E-21
t4 blinkerA blinkerB block+:E9 E7 O-11 O-17 E-5 O21
t4 blinkerA blinkerB block+:E-9 E-9 O-27 O-33 E-21 O5
t3 beehiveB+ block+:E9 E27 E17 E9 E19 E31
t3 beehiveB+ block+:E-9 E11 E1 E-7 E3 E15
t3 beehiveB block+:E9 E27 E17 E9 E39
t3 beehiveB block+:E-9 E11 E1 E-7 E23
t3 beehiveB block++:E9 E27 E17 E9 E35
t3 beehiveB block++:E-9 E11 E1 E-7 E19
t4 beehiveB block++:E-9 E-15 O-23 O-37 O-23 O-37
t4 beehiveB block++:E-9 E-15 O-23 O-37 O-23
t4 beehiveB block+++:E9 E9 E-3 O-5 O1
t4 beehiveB block+++:E9 E-7 E-11 E-9 E-9 E19
t4 beehiveB block+++:E-9 E-9 E9 O-29 O7
t4 beehiveB block+++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O-15
t4 beehiveB block+++:E-9 E-23 E-27 E-25 E-25 E3
t4 beehiveB block++++:E9 E-7 E-11 E-9 E25
t4 beehiveB block++++:E-9 E-23 E-27 E-25 E9
t4 beehiveB block++++ beehiveA:E9 E-7 E-11 E-9
t4 beehiveB block++++ beehiveA:E-9 E-23 E-27 E-25
t3 beehiveB block+++ beehiveA:E9 E7 E19 O21
t4 beehiveB block+++ beehiveA:E9 E-7 E-11 E-9 E-9
t3 beehiveB block+++ beehiveA:E-9 E-9 E3 O5
t4 beehiveB block+++ beehiveA:E-9 E-23 E-27 E-25 E-25
t3 beehiveB block++ pond:E9 E27 E17 E9 E19
t3 beehiveB block++ pond:E-9 E11 E1 E-7 E3
t3 beehiveB block++ beehiveA:E9 E7 E19 O21 O53
t3 beehiveB block++ beehiveA:E-9 E-9 E3 O5 O37
t4 beehiveB block+ shipB:E9 E-7 E-11 E-13 E19
t4 beehiveB block+ shipB:E-9 E-23 E-27 E-29 E3
t4 beehiveB block+ pond:E9 E-7 E19 E-11
t4 beehiveB block+ pond:E-9 E-23 E3 E-27
t3 beehiveB block+ blinkerA+ blinkerB+:E9 E27 E17 E9 E27
t3 beehiveB block+ blinkerA+ blinkerB+:E-9 E11 E1 E-7 E11
t4 beehiveB block+ beehiveA:E9 E-7 E-11 E-13 E-15
t4 beehiveB block+ beehiveA:E-9 E-23 E-27 E-29 E-31
t4 beehiveB block+ beehiveA shipB:E9 E-7 E-11 E-13
t4 beehiveB block+ beehiveA shipB:E-9 E-23 E-27 E-29
t4 beehiveB block+ beehiveA pond:E9 E-7 E-11
t4 beehiveB block+ beehiveA pond:E-9 E-23 E-27
t4 beehiveB blinkerB block+:E9 E13 E13 O13 O-15 O-19
t4 beehiveB blinkerB block+:E-9 E-3 E-3 O-3 O-31 O-35
t3 beehiveB beehiveA block+:E9 E27 E17 E9
t3 beehiveB beehiveA block+:E-9 E11 E1 E-7
t4 beehiveB beehiveA block++:E9 E9 E-3 O-5 O-37
t4 beehiveB beehiveA block++:E9 E7 E25 O23 O-9
t4 beehiveB beehiveA block++:E-9 E-9 E9 O7 O-25
t3 beehiveB beehiveA block++:E-9 E-7 E-25 O-23 O9
t4 beehiveB beehiveA block++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O-53
t3 beehiveB beehiveA block+++:E9 E9 E-9 O-7
t4 beehiveB beehiveA block+++:E9 E9 E-3 O-5 O-47
t4 beehiveB beehiveA block+++:E9 E9 E-3 O-5
t4 beehiveB beehiveA block+++:E9 E7 E25 O23
t4 beehiveB beehiveA block+++:E-9 E-9 E9 O7
t3 beehiveB beehiveA block+++:E-9 E-7 E-25 O-23
t4 beehiveB beehiveA block+++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O-63
t4 beehiveB beehiveA block+++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21
t3 beehiveA block+:E9 E7 E19 O-1 E9 O-1 O-5
t3 beehiveA block+:E9 E23 E-1 E13 O15 E-35 E-5
t4 beehiveA block+:E9 E15 E21 O9 E-1 E21 E-15
t3 beehiveA block+:E-9 E7 E-17 E-3 O-1 E-51 E-21
t3 beehiveA block+:E-9 E-9 E3 O-17 E-7 O-17 O-21
t4 beehiveA block+:E-9 E-7 O11 O-1 O-13 O-19 O-17
t3 beehiveA block+:E-9 E-7 O1 O-15 E-15 E9 O13
t4 beehiveA block+:E-9 E-13 E-13 E17 E-9 E-15 E15
t4 beehiveA block+:E-9 E-1 O19 O15 O-7 E-17 O-29
t4 beehiveA block+:E-9 E-1 E5 O-7 E-17 E5 E-31
t4 beehiveA block+++:E9 E9 E-3 O-5 O29
t4 beehiveA block+++:E9 E7 E25 O23 O29
t4 beehiveA block+++:E-9 E-9 E9 O7 O13
t3 beehiveA block+++:E-9 E-7 E-25 O13 O-23
t4 beehiveA block+++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O13
t3 beehiveA block+ blinkerA+ loafC:E9 E23 E11 E19 E9
t3 beehiveA block+ blinkerA+ loafC:E-9 E7 E-5 E3 E-7
t3 tub block+:E9 E17 O23 O-5 O-37 E-13 E11
t3 tub block+:E-9 E1 O7 O-21 O-53 E-29 E-5
t3 shipB block+++:E-9 E-9 E3 O5 O-7 E3
t4 shipB block+++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O-9 E-19
t3 shipB block+ beehiveA:E9 E23 E27 E29 E-3
t3 shipB block+ beehiveA:E-9 E7 E11 E13 E-19
t3 shipB block+ beehiveA beehiveB:E9 E23 E27 E29
t3 shipB block+ beehiveA beehiveB:E-9 E7 E11 E13
t4 shipA block+:E-9 E-15 E-29 E-31 E-25 O1 E-9
t3 shipA block+:E-9 E-1 E13 E15 E9 O-17 E-7
t4 shipA block+++:E9 E1 E5 E-7 O-9 E-11
t4 shipA block+++:E-9 E-15 E-11 E-23 O-25 E-27
t3 pond+ block++:E9 E23 E-3 E27 E-11
t4 pond+ block++:E9 E-7 E19 E-11 E27
t3 pond+ block++:E-9 E7 E-19 E11 E-27
t4 pond+ block++:E-9 E-23 E3 E-27 E11
t3 pond block+:E-9 E7 E-19 E11 E-29
t3 pond block+:E-9 E-1 E13 O13 O-13 E-21 O5
t3 pond block++ boatA:E9 E27 E17 E35 E39
t3 pond block++ boatA:E-9 E11 E1 E19 E23
t3 pond block+ beehiveB:E9 E13 E17 E35 E39
t3 pond block+ beehiveB:E-9 E-3 E1 E19 E23
t3 pond block+ beehiveA:E9 E23 E-3 E27
t3 pond block+ beehiveA:E-9 E7 E-19 E11
t3 pond block+ beehiveA beehiveB:E9 E23 E27
t3 pond block+ beehiveA beehiveB:E-9 E7 E11
t3 longboatA block+:E9 E23 E7 E-11 E-5 O-9 O-27
t3 longboatA block+:E-9 E7 E-9 E-27 E-21 O-25 O-43
t4 loafD block+:E9 E9 E7 O19 E11 O-21 E-5
t4 loafD block+:E9 E-7 E23 E5 E9 O-23 E-7
t4 loafD block+:E-9 E7 E-23 E21 E25 O-7 E9
t4 loafD block+:E-9 E-9 E19 O-19 E23 O-9 E7
t4 loafD block+:E-9 E-7 E-9 O3 E-5 O-37 E-21
t4 loafD block+:E-9 E-23 E7 E-11 E-7 O-39 E-23
t3 loafB block+:E9 E9 E13 O27 E-21 E-27
t4 loafB block+:E9 E7 E11 O9 O17 E-13
t3 loafB block+:E9 E23 E-1 E13 O15 E-35
t3 loafB block+:E9 E15 O-3 O31 O27 O-5
t3 loafB block+:E-9 E7 E-17 E-3 O-1 E-51
t4 loafB block+:E-9 E-9 E-5 O-7 O1 E-29
t3 loafB block+:E-9 E-7 E-3 O11 E-37 E-43
t3 loafB block+:E-9 E-1 O-19 O15 O11 O-21
t3 boatD block+:E-9 E-13 E-13 O-13 E-27 O-13 E13
t4 boatC beaconA2 blinkerB block++:E9 E7 O-11 O-17 E-5
t4 boatC beaconA2 blinkerB block++:E-9 E-9 O-27 O-33 E-21
t4 boatB block+:E9 E15 O23 E37 O25 O-5 O-3
t4 boatB block+:E-9 E-1 O7 E21 O9 O-21 O-19
t4 boatB block+++:E9 E9 O17 O41 E-3 O-5
t4 boatB block+++:E-9 E-7 O1 O25 E-19 O-21
t4 boatA block+:E9 E3 E3 O-7 E-21 E1 O-17
t3 boatA block+:E-9 E-15 E-15 E-31 O-17 O-5 O-21
t4 boatA block+:E-9 E-15 E-15 E-31 O-17 E-11 O5
t4 boatA block+:E-9 E-13 E-13 O-23 E-37 E-15 O-33
t4 boatA block+:E-9 E-1 E-1 E15 O1 O-11 O5
t3 boatA block+:E-9 E-1 E-1 E15 O1 E-5 O-21
t3 boatA block+++:E9 E1 E5 O-29 E-27 O-25
t3 boatA block+++:E9 E1 E17 E-15 O-15
t3 boatA block+++:E-9 E-15 E1 E-31 O-31
t3 boatA block+++:E-9 E-15 E-11 O-45 E-43 O-41
t3 boatA block+++ blinkerA:E9 E1 O-19 O7 O7
t3 boatA block+++ blinkerA:E-9 E-15 O-35 O-9 O-9
t3 boatA block++ blinkerA:E9 E1 O-19 O7 O7 O-21
t3 boatA block++ blinkerA:E-9 E-15 O-35 O-9 O-9 O-37
t3 boatA block++ blinkerA beehiveB:E-9 E-15 E-33 E-17 O-5
t4 boatA blinkerB block++:E9 E1 E1 O-15 O-9 E1
t4 boatA blinkerB block++:E-9 E-15 E-15 O-31 O-25 E-15
t4 boatA blinkerB block++++:E9 E1 O-13 O-67 O-29
t4 boatA blinkerB block++++:E-9 E-15 O-29 O-83 O-45
t4 boatA blinkerB block+ beehiveA:E9 E1 O19 E13 E-3 O-15
t4 boatA blinkerB block+ beehiveA:E-9 E-15 O3 E-3 E-19 O-31

This is one of the possible adjustments to the definition of "Spartan", and one of the caveats to the usefulness of Blockic constructions, that I don't really want to think about too much right now! See, it's really more efficient sometimes to construct stable circuitry one small constellation at a time, instead of just one still life at a time:

#C construct 3 blocks at once
#C -- two for a 180-degree turner triggered from the side, plus one elbow
#C orientaton #4 block++:E-9 E-23 E1 E-13 O-15 E35 E-7
x = 1032, y = 1958, rule = LifeHistory
1029.A$1029.A.A$1029.2A1033$2E$2E19$15.3A$15.A$16.A148$158.3A$158.A$
159.A148$320.3A$320.A$321.A148$463.3A$463.A$464.A148$613.2A$612.2A$
614.A148$787.3A$787.A$788.A148$916.3A$916.A$917.A!

Now, technically there's at least one orientation of boat that can be constructed with just four gliders from a block -- or five gliders, if you want to leave a block off to the side to continue the construction with. So even with this new constellation-construction trick, boats are now a little cheaper than Blockic turners. And if I can construct boats in constellation with other nearby still lifes sometimes, that will make them still cheaper.

Boats and Blockic turners can't be compared exactly, since the output gliders are different colors, and anyway in some cases a boat-construction won't fit in some particular location where a 2-block-OTT construction will. But in general I should probably stop assuming that Blockic one-time turners are going to be a particularly cheap option.

Instead, I should really make a new collection of OTTs, by running through (let's say) every six-gliders-or-less intermediate target in the p2 block-move table, hitting each one with every possible glider from every possible direction, and seeing which ones happen to be clean glider turners. One-time circuitry would then be built with those constellations -- a different group of OTTs for each trigger glider input direction.

Not sure when I'll get around to trying all those collisions and classifying the timing of the results -- it ends up being quite a bit of work, and for the replicator project I can get by just fine with the Blockic turners I've already collected. And the new list of inexpensive OTTs wouldn't be exhaustive, unfortunately. Intermediate targets can only be found in the block-move table if there's a way of reducing them to a single block with a total recipe of ten gliders or less.

So inevitably there will be some intermediate targets that Glue threw out because they're useless from a block-moving perspective, that turn out to be handy from a one-time-turner point of view... Ah, well. Once we have several thousand inexpensive one-time turners available, it probably won't matter too much if another few thousand are missing!

Some of these new OTTs may not actually be Spartan. See this earlier post -- you can get aircraft carriers, snakes, shillelaghs, boat-ties, long barges, long ships, integrals, eleveners, canoes, hats, biponds, boats-with-tails, tubs-with-tails, etc. as part of these constellations. But because they're all just eight gliders or less away from a block, they're Just As Good As Spartan, or maybe better.

For now I'll call these hypothetical OTTs "BT-Spartan" (Better Than Spartan). The name probably won't stick, but you never know until you try...!
dvgrn
Moderator
 
Posts: 3988
Joined: May 17th, 2009, 11:00 pm
Location: Madison, WI

Re: Geminoid Challenge

Postby dvgrn » October 28th, 2013, 5:03 pm

dvgrn wrote:In other news, the replicator's construction recipe is starting to take shape. I'm over halfway through building the SE reflector --

#C 157-glider P2 slow salvo constructs 12 still lifes (and hand block)...

Just about done with the SE reflector now. There were no difficulties at all in stringing known one-arm recipes together, even for the closest-spaced still lifes:

#C 313-glider P2 slow salvo constructs a Silver reflector, hand block,
#C and a honeyfarm which will be used to build a 180-degree one-time turner.
x = 46823, y = 47008, rule = B3/S23
2bo$obo$b2o137$152bo$150bobo$151b2o139$302bo$300bobo$301b2o132$452bo$
450bobo$451b2o141$600bobo$601b2o$601bo158$750bobo$751b2o$751bo140$902b
o$900bobo$901b2o154$1050bobo$1051b2o$1051bo137$1202bo$1200bobo$1201b2o
152$1350bobo$1351b2o$1351bo139$1502bo$1500bobo$1501b2o159$1652bo$1650b
obo$1651b2o148$1802bo$1800bobo$1801b2o150$1952bo$1950bobo$1951b2o137$
2102bo$2100bobo$2101b2o151$2250bobo$2251b2o$2251bo146$2402bo$2400bobo$
2401b2o149$2552bo$2550bobo$2551b2o148$2702bo$2700bobo$2701b2o152$2852b
o$2850bobo$2851b2o160$3002bo$3000bobo$3001b2o140$3150bobo$3151b2o$
3151bo151$3302bo$3300bobo$3301b2o129$3450bobo$3451b2o$3451bo154$3602bo
$3600bobo$3601b2o154$3752bo$3750bobo$3751b2o139$3902bo$3900bobo$3901b
2o160$4052bo$4050bobo$4051b2o141$4202bo$4200bobo$4201b2o139$4352bo$
4350bobo$4351b2o153$4500bobo$4501b2o$4501bo144$4652bo$4650bobo$4651b2o
150$4802bo$4800bobo$4801b2o145$4952bo$4950bobo$4951b2o136$5100bobo$
5101b2o$5101bo156$5250bobo$5251b2o$5251bo145$5402bo$5400bobo$5401b2o
167$5550bobo$5551b2o$5551bo142$5702bo$5700bobo$5701b2o142$5852bo$5850b
obo$5851b2o157$6002bo$6000bobo$6001b2o136$6152bo$6150bobo$6151b2o155$
6302bo$6300bobo$6301b2o149$6450bobo$6451b2o$6451bo140$6602bo$6600bobo$
6601b2o145$6752bo$6750bobo$6751b2o144$6900bobo$6901b2o$6901bo142$7050b
obo$7051b2o$7051bo153$7202bo$7200bobo$7201b2o148$7352bo$7350bobo$7351b
2o148$7502bo$7500bobo$7501b2o148$7652bo$7650bobo$7651b2o148$7802bo$
7800bobo$7801b2o148$7952bo$7950bobo$7951b2o155$8102bo$8100bobo$8101b2o
151$8252bo$8250bobo$8251b2o128$8402bo$8400bobo$8401b2o151$8550bobo$
8551b2o$8551bo146$8702bo$8700bobo$8701b2o149$8852bo$8850bobo$8851b2o
148$9002bo$9000bobo$9001b2o152$9152bo$9150bobo$9151b2o146$9302bo$9300b
obo$9301b2o146$9452bo$9450bobo$9451b2o158$9602bo$9600bobo$9601b2o147$
9750bobo$9751b2o$9751bo145$9900bobo$9901b2o$9901bo140$10052bo$10050bob
o$10051b2o156$10202bo$10200bobo$10201b2o148$10350bobo$10351b2o$10351bo
137$10502bo$10500bobo$10501b2o159$10652bo$10650bobo$10651b2o148$10802b
o$10800bobo$10801b2o150$10952bo$10950bobo$10951b2o176$11100bobo$11101b
2o$11101bo162$11250bobo$11251b2o$11251bo142$11402bo$11400bobo$11401b2o
148$11550bobo$11551b2o$11551bo142$11700bobo$11701b2o$11701bo154$11850b
obo$11851b2o$11851bo143$12002bo$12000bobo$12001b2o147$12152bo$12150bob
o$12151b2o131$12302bo$12300bobo$12301b2o171$12450bobo$12451b2o$12451bo
149$12600bobo$12601b2o$12601bo134$12752bo$12750bobo$12751b2o148$12902b
o$12900bobo$12901b2o151$13052bo$13050bobo$13051b2o152$13200bobo$13201b
2o$13201bo153$13350bobo$13351b2o$13351bo145$13500bobo$13501b2o$13501bo
148$13650bobo$13651b2o$13651bo140$13802bo$13800bobo$13801b2o148$13952b
o$13950bobo$13951b2o147$14100bobo$14101b2o$14101bo154$14252bo$14250bob
o$14251b2o149$14400bobo$14401b2o$14401bo159$14552bo$14550bobo$14551b2o
140$14702bo$14700bobo$14701b2o145$14852bo$14850bobo$14851b2o129$15002b
o$15000bobo$15001b2o154$15152bo$15150bobo$15151b2o159$15300bobo$15301b
2o$15301bo136$15452bo$15450bobo$15451b2o156$15600bobo$15601b2o$15601bo
150$15750bobo$15751b2o$15751bo139$15902bo$15900bobo$15901b2o151$16052b
o$16050bobo$16051b2o153$16202bo$16200bobo$16201b2o150$16352bo$16350bob
o$16351b2o144$16502bo$16500bobo$16501b2o142$16650bobo$16651b2o$16651bo
152$16800bobo$16801b2o$16801bo149$16952bo$16950bobo$16951b2o148$17102b
o$17100bobo$17101b2o155$17252bo$17250bobo$17251b2o146$17402bo$17400bob
o$17401b2o158$17552bo$17550bobo$17551b2o147$17700bobo$17701b2o$17701bo
145$17850bobo$17851b2o$17851bo140$18002bo$18000bobo$18001b2o156$18152b
o$18150bobo$18151b2o148$18300bobo$18301b2o$18301bo137$18452bo$18450bob
o$18451b2o159$18602bo$18600bobo$18601b2o148$18752bo$18750bobo$18751b2o
150$18902bo$18900bobo$18901b2o164$19050bobo$19051b2o$19051bo158$19200b
obo$19201b2o$19201bo140$19352bo$19350bobo$19351b2o154$19500bobo$19501b
2o$19501bo137$19652bo$19650bobo$19651b2o152$19800bobo$19801b2o$19801bo
139$19952bo$19950bobo$19951b2o159$20102bo$20100bobo$20101b2o148$20252b
o$20250bobo$20251b2o150$20402bo$20400bobo$20401b2o147$20550bobo$20551b
2o$20551bo148$20702bo$20700bobo$20701b2o150$20850bobo$20851b2o$20851bo
141$21002bo$21000bobo$21001b2o148$21152bo$21150bobo$21151b2o148$21302b
o$21300bobo$21301b2o164$21452bo$21450bobo$21451b2o148$21600bobo$21601b
2o$21601bo137$21752bo$21750bobo$21751b2o167$21902bo$21900bobo$21901b2o
144$22052bo$22050bobo$22051b2o145$22202bo$22200bobo$22201b2o155$22352b
o$22350bobo$22351b2o150$22502bo$22500bobo$22501b2o144$22652bo$22650bob
o$22651b2o156$22800bobo$22801b2o$22801bo143$22950bobo$22951b2o$22951bo
150$23100bobo$23101b2o$23101bo136$23252bo$23250bobo$23251b2o156$23402b
o$23400bobo$23401b2o152$23552bo$23550bobo$23551b2o127$23702bo$23700bob
o$23701b2o156$23850bobo$23851b2o$23851bo145$24002bo$24000bobo$24001b2o
167$24150bobo$24151b2o$24151bo142$24302bo$24300bobo$24301b2o142$24452b
o$24450bobo$24451b2o157$24602bo$24600bobo$24601b2o136$24752bo$24750bob
o$24751b2o155$24902bo$24900bobo$24901b2o146$25050bobo$25051b2o$25051bo
145$25202bo$25200bobo$25201b2o137$25350bobo$25351b2o$25351bo158$25502b
o$25500bobo$25501b2o151$25652bo$25650bobo$25651b2o136$25802bo$25800bob
o$25801b2o156$25950bobo$25951b2o$25951bo145$26102bo$26100bobo$26101b2o
167$26250bobo$26251b2o$26251bo142$26402bo$26400bobo$26401b2o142$26552b
o$26550bobo$26551b2o157$26702bo$26700bobo$26701b2o136$26852bo$26850bob
o$26851b2o155$27002bo$27000bobo$27001b2o172$27152bo$27150bobo$27151b2o
148$27302bo$27300bobo$27301b2o149$27450bobo$27451b2o$27451bo144$27602b
o$27600bobo$27601b2o137$27752bo$27750bobo$27751b2o159$27902bo$27900bob
o$27901b2o148$28052bo$28050bobo$28051b2o150$28202bo$28200bobo$28201b2o
162$28350bobo$28351b2o$28351bo142$28500bobo$28501b2o$28501bo160$28652b
o$28650bobo$28651b2o148$28802bo$28800bobo$28801b2o140$28952bo$28950bob
o$28951b2o140$29102bo$29100bobo$29101b2o133$29250bobo$29251b2o$29251bo
146$29400bobo$29401b2o$29401bo161$29552bo$29550bobo$29551b2o137$29702b
o$29700bobo$29701b2o150$29852bo$29850bobo$29851b2o155$30002bo$30000bob
o$30001b2o158$30152bo$30150bobo$30151b2o141$30302bo$30300bobo$30301b2o
159$30452bo$30450bobo$30451b2o140$30602bo$30600bobo$30601b2o137$30752b
o$30750bobo$30751b2o159$30900bobo$30901b2o$30901bo166$31052bo$31050bob
o$31051b2o145$31202bo$31200bobo$31201b2o141$31352bo$31350bobo$31351b2o
146$31502bo$31500bobo$31501b2o106$31652bo$31650bobo$31651b2o149$31802b
o$31800bobo$31801b2o157$31950bobo$31951b2o$31951bo144$32102bo$32100bob
o$32101b2o141$32252bo$32250bobo$32251b2o149$32402bo$32400bobo$32401b2o
145$32550bobo$32551b2o$32551bo146$32702bo$32700bobo$32701b2o155$32852b
o$32850bobo$32851b2o151$33002bo$33000bobo$33001b2o165$33150bobo$33151b
2o$33151bo151$33302bo$33300bobo$33301b2o162$33450bobo$33451b2o$33451bo
137$33602bo$33600bobo$33601b2o147$33752bo$33750bobo$33751b2o149$33902b
o$33900bobo$33901b2o129$34050bobo$34051b2o$34051bo165$34200bobo$34201b
2o$34201bo130$34350bobo$34351b2o$34351bo158$34502bo$34500bobo$34501b2o
153$34652bo$34650bobo$34651b2o156$34802bo$34800bobo$34801b2o116$34952b
o$34950bobo$34951b2o148$35102bo$35100bobo$35101b2o144$35250bobo$35251b
2o$35251bo158$35402bo$35400bobo$35401b2o154$35550bobo$35551b2o$35551bo
147$35702bo$35700bobo$35701b2o131$35852bo$35850bobo$35851b2o155$36002b
o$36000bobo$36001b2o159$36150bobo$36151b2o$36151bo151$36302bo$36300bob
o$36301b2o159$36450bobo$36451b2o$36451bo138$36602bo$36600bobo$36601b2o
145$36752bo$36750bobo$36751b2o150$36902bo$36900bobo$36901b2o135$37050b
obo$37051b2o$37051bo164$37202bo$37200bobo$37201b2o135$37350bobo$37351b
2o$37351bo148$37502bo$37500bobo$37501b2o148$37652bo$37650bobo$37651b2o
150$37802bo$37800bobo$37801b2o121$37952bo$37950bobo$37951b2o157$38100b
obo$38101b2o$38101bo138$38250bobo$38251b2o$38251bo155$38400bobo$38401b
2o$38401bo145$38550bobo$38551b2o$38551bo149$38702bo$38700bobo$38701b2o
149$38852bo$38850bobo$38851b2o182$39000bobo$39001b2o$39001bo131$39152b
o$39150bobo$39151b2o154$39302bo$39300bobo$39301b2o139$39452bo$39450bob
o$39451b2o151$39602bo$39600bobo$39601b2o152$39752bo$39750bobo$39751b2o
151$39902bo$39900bobo$39901b2o138$40052bo$40050bobo$40051b2o138$40202b
o$40200bobo$40201b2o149$40352bo$40350bobo$40351b2o135$40502bo$40500bob
o$40501b2o156$40652bo$40650bobo$40651b2o151$40802bo$40800bobo$40801b2o
155$40950bobo$40951b2o$40951bo188$41102bo$41100bobo$41101b2o150$41250b
obo$41251b2o$41251bo145$41400bobo$41401b2o$41401bo153$41552bo$41550bob
o$41551b2o150$41702bo$41700bobo$41701b2o149$41852bo$41850bobo$41851b2o
148$42002bo$42000bobo$42001b2o152$42152bo$42150bobo$42151b2o146$42300b
obo$42301b2o$42301bo188$42452bo$42450bobo$42451b2o150$42600bobo$42601b
2o$42601bo145$42750bobo$42751b2o$42751bo153$42902bo$42900bobo$42901b2o
150$43052bo$43050bobo$43051b2o149$43202bo$43200bobo$43201b2o148$43352b
o$43350bobo$43351b2o152$43502bo$43500bobo$43501b2o146$43650bobo$43651b
2o$43651bo188$43802bo$43800bobo$43801b2o150$43950bobo$43951b2o$43951bo
145$44100bobo$44101b2o$44101bo153$44252bo$44250bobo$44251b2o150$44402b
o$44400bobo$44401b2o149$44552bo$44550bobo$44551b2o148$44702bo$44700bob
o$44701b2o152$44852bo$44850bobo$44851b2o147$45002bo$45000bobo$45001b2o
171$45152bo$45150bobo$45151b2o148$45302bo$45300bobo$45301b2o164$45450b
obo$45451b2o$45451bo144$45602bo$45600bobo$45601b2o141$45752bo$45750bob
o$45751b2o151$45902bo$45900bobo$45901b2o166$46052bo$46050bobo$46051b2o
146$46200bobo$46201b2o$46201bo144$46350bobo$46351b2o$46351bo141$46502b
o$46500bobo$46501b2o155$46652bo$46650bobo$46651b2o147$46802bo$46800bob
o$46801b2o23$46821b2o$46821b2o!

This can be reduced considerably -- certainly to less than 300 gliders, probably to less than 250, possibly to under 200. But it's definitely a non-trivial project to write a compiler that can find a near-optimal combination of recipes.

Next up is a version of this same recipe run through the 66sL universal constructor, to show what the first part of the replicator's build cycle will look like (more or less).
dvgrn
Moderator
 
Posts: 3988
Joined: May 17th, 2009, 11:00 pm
Location: Madison, WI

PreviousNext

Return to Patterns

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 4 guests

cron