dvgrn wrote:Here's a trial run that I did with the new search script, looking for cheaper constructions of the two-block 180-degree OTT -- those two blocks show up over a thousand times in the block-move table's intermediate targets, with and without lots of other junk:...
Here's the other half of that search: there are 561 more intermediate targets that include the 180-degree 2-Blockic OTT, oriented so that the input glider is 90 degrees from the construction gliders. Again, run
build-EO-lane-slow-salvo.py with one of the lines below copied to the clipboard. Or you can modify the script to cycle through the recipe list, or sort it -- if anyone wants a sample script that does that kind of thing, let me know.
Code: Select all
t3 block+:E9 E27 E17 E39 E41 E9
t3 block+:E9 E1 O19 O-19 E13 O-9
t4 block+:E9 E1 E-13 E-7 E-19 O17
t3 block+:E-9 E11 E1 E23 E25 E-7
t3 block+:E-9 E-9 O-3 O-29 O3 O1
t4 block+:E-9 E-7 O-13 O13 O-19 O-17
t3 block+:E-9 E-3 E-3 O11 E-13 E-7
t4 block+:E-9 E-3 E-3 E13 E13 E-7
t3 block+:E-9 E-15 O3 O-35 E-3 O-25
t4 block+:E-9 E-15 E-29 E-23 E-35 O1
t4 block+:E-9 E-13 E-13 O-27 E-3 E-9
t3 block+:E-9 E-13 E-13 E-29 E-29 E-9
t4 block+:E-9 E-1 O-19 E-13 O-11 O-13
t3 block++:E9 E9 O27 O33 E21 E-5 E-17
t3 block++:E9 E9 O-19 E-31 E-11 O19 O-1
t3 block++:E9 E9 E13 O27 E-21 E-27 E11
t3 block++:E9 E9 E-9 O19 O-7 O27
t4 block++:E9 E9 E-3 O-5 O-37 O19
t4 block++:E9 E7 E25 O-3 O23 O-11
t3 block++:E9 E27 E17 E39 E31 E29 E9
t4 block++:E9 E23 E7 E-25 E-39 O-41 O-15
t4 block++:E9 E23 E-7 E27 O25 O-9
t3 block++:E9 E17 O23 O-5 O-37 E-33 E11
t4 block++:E9 E15 O35 O17 O11 O7 O17
t3 block++:E9 E15 O-3 O31 O27 O17 O-5
t3 block++:E9 E15 E-1 E7 O19 O-15 O17
t4 block++:E9 E13 E27 E21 E3 E-5 E1
t4 block++:E9 E1 E-15 E3 O-25 E7 E-41
t3 block++:E9 E-7 E27 O29 E-1 O-13 O-31
t3 block++:E9 E-7 E23 O-21 E-33 E-13 O-3
t4 block++:E9 E-7 E23 E-5 O-7 O-41
t3 block++:E9 E-7 E23 E-11 O-9 O25
t4 block++:E-9 E7 E-9 E-41 E-55 O-57 O-31
t3 block++:E-9 E7 E-23 O-5 E-17 E3 O13
t4 block++:E-9 E7 E-23 E11 O9 O-25
t3 block++:E-9 E7 E-17 E-3 O-1 E-51 E-9
t3 block++:E-9 E11 E1 E23 E15 E13 E-7
t3 block++:E-9 E1 O7 O-21 O-53 E-49 E-5
t3 block++:E-9 E-9 O-19 O-7 E-19 E1 O11
t3 block++:E-9 E-9 O-13 O-5 E-35 E-27 O15
t4 block++:E-9 E-9 E9 O-19 O7 O-27
t4 block++:E-9 E-7 O3 O-9 E3 E-17 O-27
t3 block++:E-9 E-7 O11 O17 E5 E-21 E-33
t3 block++:E-9 E-7 O-35 E-47 E-27 O3 O-17
t4 block++:E-9 E-7 O-3 O-11 E19 E11 O-31
t3 block++:E-9 E-7 E-3 O11 E-37 E-43 E-5
t3 block++:E-9 E-7 E-25 O3 O-23 O11
t4 block++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O-53 O3
t4 block++:E-9 E-3 E11 E5 E-13 E-21 E-15
t3 block++:E-9 E-3 E-3 O11 E-11 E-7 E-1
t3 block++:E-9 E-23 E7 O-37 E-49 E-29 O-19
t4 block++:E-9 E-23 E7 O-11 E1 E-19 O-29
t3 block++:E-9 E-23 E7 E-27 O-25 O9
t4 block++:E-9 E-23 E7 E-21 O-23 O-57
t3 block++:E-9 E-23 E11 O13 E-17 O-29 O-47
t4 block++:E-9 E-23 E1 E-13 O-15 E35 E-7
t4 block++:E-9 E-15 O3 O-31 O-27 O-23 O5
t4 block++:E-9 E-15 O-23 O-37 O-23 O-37 O15
t4 block++:E-9 E-15 E-31 E-13 O-41 E-9 E-57
t4 block++:E-9 E-13 E-13 O-27 E-5 E-9 E-15
t3 block++:E-9 E-1 O7 O21 O7 O21 O-31
t4 block++:E-9 E-1 O19 O1 O-5 O-9 O1
t3 block++:E-9 E-1 O-19 O15 O11 O7 O-21
t3 block++:E-9 E-1 O-19 O15 O11 O1 O-21
t3 block++:E-9 E-1 E-17 E-9 O3 O-31 O1
t3 block+++:E9 E9 O27 O33 E21 E-5 O-19
t3 block+++:E9 E9 O27 O33 E21 E-5 E-25
t3 block+++:E9 E9 E-9 O19 O-7 O35
t3 block+++:E9 E9 E-9 O19 O-7
t4 block+++:E9 E9 E-3 O-5 O7 E9 E-37
t4 block+++:E9 E9 E-3 O-5 O19
t4 block+++:E9 E9 E-3 O-5 O-47 O19
t3 block+++:E9 E7 O-1 O9 O-17 O9 E-13
t3 block+++:E9 E7 O-1 O9 O-17 O9
t4 block+++:E9 E7 E25 O-3 O23 O-19
t4 block+++:E9 E7 E25 O-3 O23
t4 block+++:E9 E27 E13 O21 O-7 E-37 E-53
t4 block+++:E9 E23 E7 O-19 O23 E21 E-13
t3 block+++:E9 E23 E7 O-19 O17 E19 E51
t3 block+++:E9 E23 E7 E-41 E-15 O-47 E-39
t4 block+++:E9 E23 E-7 E27 O25
t4 block+++:E9 E23 E-1 O-17 O-25 E-1 E-5
t3 block+++:E9 E15 E33 E15 E19 O21 O65
t4 block+++:E9 E1 O-15 O-27 O-23 E3 O-17
t4 block+++:E9 E1 O-13 O-67 O-29 E5 O-67
t4 block+++:E9 E1 E17 O23 E1 O-29 O-45
t4 block+++:E9 E1 E17 E-11 O9 E29 O13
t4 block+++:E9 E-7 E9 O35 O-1 E-3 E-35
t4 block+++:E9 E-7 E23 E-5 O-7 O-49
t4 block+++:E9 E-7 E23 E-5 O-7
t3 block+++:E9 E-7 E23 E-11 O-9 O33
t3 block+++:E9 E-7 E23 E-11 O-9
t4 block+++:E9 E-7 E-11 E-9 E-9 E19 E29
t4 block+++:E-9 E7 E-9 O-35 O7 E5 E-29
t3 block+++:E-9 E7 E-9 O-35 O1 E3 E35
t3 block+++:E-9 E7 E-9 E-57 E-31 O-63 E-55
t4 block+++:E-9 E7 E-23 E11 O9 O-33
t4 block+++:E-9 E7 E-23 E11 O9
t4 block+++:E-9 E7 E-17 O-33 O-41 E-17 E-21
t4 block+++:E-9 E11 E-3 O5 O-23 E-53 E-69
t4 block+++:E-9 E-9 O-17 O-7 O-33 O1 E1
t3 block+++:E-9 E-9 O-17 O-7 O-33 O-7 E-29
t3 block+++:E-9 E-9 O-17 O-7 O-33 O-7
t4 block+++:E-9 E-9 E9 O-19 O7 O-35
t4 block+++:E-9 E-9 E9 O-19 O7
t3 block+++:E-9 E-7 O11 O17 E5 E-21 O-35
t3 block+++:E-9 E-7 O11 O17 E5 E-21 E-41
t3 block+++:E-9 E-7 O1 O-9 O17 O-17 E-17
t3 block+++:E-9 E-7 E-25 O3 O-23 O19
t3 block+++:E-9 E-7 E-25 O3 O-23
t4 block+++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O3
t4 block+++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O-9 E-7 E-53
t4 block+++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O-63 O3
t3 block+++:E-9 E-23 E7 E-27 O-25 O17
t3 block+++:E-9 E-23 E7 E-27 O-25
t4 block+++:E-9 E-23 E7 E-21 O-23 O-65
t4 block+++:E-9 E-23 E7 E-21 O-23
t3 block+++:E-9 E-23 E1 O17 O25 E1 E5
t4 block+++:E-9 E-23 E-7 O19 O-17 E-19 E-51
t4 block+++:E-9 E-23 E-27 E-25 E-25 E3 E13
t4 block+++:E-9 E-15 O-31 O-43 O-39 E-13 O-33
t4 block+++:E-9 E-15 O-29 O-83 O-45 E-11 O-83
t4 block+++:E-9 E-15 E1 O7 E-15 O-45 O-61
t4 block+++:E-9 E-15 E1 E-27 O-7 E13 O-3
t3 block+++:E-9 E-1 O13 O67 O29 E-5 O67
t3 block+++:E-9 E-1 E17 E-1 E3 O5 O49
t4 block++++:E9 E9 E-3 O-5 O7 E9
t4 block++++:E9 E9 E-3 O-5 O29 O5
t4 block++++:E9 E9 E-3 O-5 O1 O11
t3 block++++:E9 E7 E19 O21 O15 O5
t4 block++++:E9 E23 E7 O-19 O23 E21
t3 block++++:E9 E23 E7 O-19 O17 E19
t4 block++++:E9 E23 E7 E-41 E-13 E-19
t4 block++++:E9 E1 O-15 O-27 O-23 E3
t4 block++++:E9 E1 O-13 O-67 O-29 E5
t3 block++++:E9 E-7 E9 O35 O-7 E-5
t4 block++++:E9 E-7 E9 O35 O-1 E-3
t4 block++++:E-9 E7 E-9 O-35 O7 E5
t3 block++++:E-9 E7 E-9 O-35 O1 E3
t4 block++++:E-9 E7 E-9 E-57 E-29 E-35
t3 block++++:E-9 E-9 E3 O5 O-9 E-7
t3 block++++:E-9 E-9 E3 O5 O-7 O-3
t3 block++++:E-9 E-9 E3 O5 O-7 E-9
t3 block++++:E-9 E-9 E3 O5 O-1 O-11
t4 block++++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O13 O-11
t4 block++++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O-9 O-13
t4 block++++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O-9 E-7
t4 block++++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O-7 E-9
t4 block++++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O-15 O-5
t3 block++++:E-9 E-23 E-7 O19 O-23 E-21
t4 block++++:E-9 E-23 E-7 O19 O-17 E-19
t4 block++++:E-9 E-15 O-31 O-43 O-39 E-13
t4 block++++:E-9 E-15 O-29 O-83 O-45 E-11
t3 block++++:E-9 E-1 O15 O27 O23 E-3
t3 block++++:E-9 E-1 O13 O67 O29 E-5
t3 block++++ blinkerA boatA:E9 E15 O29 O83 O45
t3 block++++ blinkerA boatA:E-9 E-1 O13 O67 O29
t3 block++++ beehiveA:E-9 E7 E11 E9 E-25
t3 block++++ beehiveA beehiveB:E9 E23 E27 E25
t3 block++++ beehiveA beehiveB:E-9 E7 E11 E9
t3 block+++ shipB:E-9 E-9 E3 O5 O-9 E-19
t3 block+++ shipA:E9 E15 E11 E23 O25 E27
t3 block+++ shipA:E-9 E-1 E-5 E7 O9 E11
t3 block+++ boatD:E-9 E-9 O-17 O-41 E3 O5
t3 block+++ boatA:E9 E15 E33 E15 E19 O21
t4 block+++ boatA:E9 E15 E-1 E31 O31
t3 block+++ boatA:E-9 E-1 E17 E-1 E3 O5
t4 block+++ boatA:E-9 E-1 E-17 E15 O15
t4 block+++ blinkerB:E9 E1 O-15 O-23 O-19 E3
t4 block+++ blinkerB:E-9 E-15 O-31 O-39 O-35 E-13
t3 block+++ blinkerA:E9 E23 E11 E19 E9 O45
t3 block+++ blinkerA:E-9 E7 E-5 E3 E-7 O29
t3 block+++ beehiveB:E9 E17 O23 O-5 O-37 E-33
t3 block+++ beehiveB:E-9 E1 O7 O-21 O-53 E-49
t3 block+++ beehiveA:E9 E7 E19 O21 O15
t3 block+++ beehiveA:E-9 E-9 E3 O5 O-1
t3 block+++ beehiveA beehiveB:E9 E23 E27 E25 E25
t3 block+++ beehiveA beehiveB:E-9 E7 E11 E9 E9
t4 block++ pond:E9 E27 E27 E-7 E23 E-11
t4 block++ pond:E9 E23 E27 E23 E-7 E-11
t3 block++ pond:E9 E1 E-15 E3 E-3 O11
t4 block++ pond:E-9 E7 E11 E7 E-23 E-27
t4 block++ pond:E-9 E11 E11 E-23 E7 E-27
t3 block++ pond:E-9 E-15 E-31 E-13 E-19 O-5
t3 block++ boatD beehiveB blinkerA:E9 E1 O-7 E21 E19
t3 block++ boatD beehiveB blinkerA:E-9 E-15 O-23 E5 E3
t4 block++ boatA:E9 E15 O17 E33 O29 E15
t4 block++ boatA:E9 E15 E-1 E31 O31 O5
t4 block++ boatA:E-9 E-1 O1 E17 O13 E-1
t4 block++ boatA:E-9 E-1 E-17 E15 O15 O-11
t3 block++ blinkerB:E9 E-7 E5 E3 E-3 O3 O13
t3 block++ blinkerB:E-9 E-7 O11 O17 E5 E-21 O-31
t4 block++ blinkerB:E-9 E-7 O-3 O-11 E19 E11
t3 block++ blinkerB:E-9 E-23 E-11 E-13 E-19 O-13 O-3
t3 block++ blinkerB+ blinkerA:E9 E9 O13 E-3 E15
t3 block++ blinkerB+ blinkerA:E-9 E-7 O-3 E-19 E-1
t3 block++ blinkerA:E9 E9 O27 O33 E21 E-5
t4 block++ blinkerA:E9 E7 O-11 O-17 E-5 E21 O31
t4 block++ blinkerA:E-9 E-9 O-27 O-33 E-21 E5 O15
t3 block++ blinkerA:E-9 E-9 O-13 O-5 E-35 E-27
t3 block++ blinkerA:E-9 E-7 O11 O17 E5 E-21
t3 block++ blinkerA:E-9 E-15 O-31 O-9 E1 O-29 O13
t3 block++ blinkerA:E-9 E-15 E-31 O-21 O-9 E1 O13
t3 block++ beehiveB tub:E9 E17 O23 O-5 O-37 E-13
t3 block++ beehiveB tub:E-9 E1 O7 O-21 O-53 E-29
t3 block++ beehiveB pond:E9 E17 O23 O-5 O-37
t3 block++ beehiveB pond:E-9 E1 O7 O-21 O-53
t3 block++ beehiveA:E9 E15 O23 O37 O23
t4 block++ beehiveA:E9 E15 E31 O33 E43 E9
t3 block++ beehiveA:E-9 E-1 O7 O21 O7 O21
t3 block++ beehiveA:E-9 E-1 O7 O21 O7
t4 block++ beehiveA:E-9 E-1 E15 O17 E27 E-7
t4 block++ beehiveA tub:E9 E-1 O-7 O21 O53 E29
t4 block++ beehiveA tub:E-9 E-17 O-23 O5 O37 E13
t4 block++ beehiveA pond:E9 E-1 O-7 O21 O53
t4 block++ beehiveA pond:E-9 E-17 O-23 O5 O37
t3 block++ beaconA2 boatC blinkerA:E9 E9 O27 O33 E21
t3 block++ beaconA2 boatC blinkerA:E-9 E-7 O11 O17 E5
t4 block+ tub:E9 E15 E21 E11 E21 O-13 O7
t4 block+ tub:E-9 E-1 E5 E-5 E5 O-29 O-9
t3 block+ shipB:E9 E17 O23 O-5 O-37 E11 E-27
t3 block+ shipB:E-9 E1 O7 O-21 O-53 E-5 E-43
t4 block+ pond:E9 E9 E7 O17 O7 E17 E-5
t3 block+ pond:E9 E17 O23 O-5 O-37 E11
t3 block+ pond:E9 E-7 E27 O29 E-1 O-13 O-39
t4 block+ pond:E9 E-7 E19 E-11 E29
t3 block+ pond:E9 E-11 E3 O31 E-17 O23 E-29
t4 block+ pond:E-9 E7 E-5 E3 E-19 E-27 E-23
t3 block+ pond:E-9 E7 E-17 O-11 E-21 E-15 E-3
t3 block+ pond:E-9 E7 E-17 O-11 E-21 E-13 E-25
t3 block+ pond:E-9 E1 O7 O-21 O-53 E-5
t4 block+ pond:E-9 E-7 E-9 O1 O-9 E1 E-21
t3 block+ pond:E-9 E-27 E-13 O15 E-33 O7 E-45
t4 block+ pond:E-9 E-23 E3 E-27 E13
t3 block+ pond:E-9 E-23 E11 O13 E-17 O-29 O-55
t4 block+ pond:E-9 E-23 E1 O-5 E5 E-3 E9
t4 block+ pond:E-9 E-23 E1 O-5 E5 E-1 E-13
t3 block+ pond:E-9 E-23 E-11 E-19 E3 E11 E7
t4 block+ pond:E-9 E-15 E-29 O-29 O-3 E5 O-21
t4 block+ mangoA1:E9 E7 O23 O23 O23 O-5 O-23
t4 block+ mangoA1:E-9 E-9 O7 O7 O7 O-21 O-39
t4 block+ loafD:E9 E1 O19 O-15 O-11 O21
t4 block+ loafD:E-9 E-23 E1 E-13 O-15 E35
t4 block+ loafD:E-9 E-15 O3 O-31 O-27 O5
t4 block+ loafC blinkerB:E9 E1 O19 O-3 E23 O21
t4 block+ loafC blinkerB:E-9 E-15 O3 O-19 E7 O5
t4 block+ loafC blinkerA+:E9 E1 O19 O-15 E23 E21
t4 block+ loafC blinkerA+:E-9 E-15 O3 O-31 E7 E5
t3 block+ loafB:E9 E9 E13 O27 E-21 E-27 E7
t3 block+ loafB:E9 E1 E-13 O7 E17 O-15 O29
t3 block+ loafB:E-9 E-7 E-35 O3 E-39 O-7 E-23
t3 block+ loafB:E-9 E-7 E-3 O11 E-37 E-43 E-9
t3 block+ loafB:E-9 E-23 E7 E-37 E-41 O-9 E-25
t3 block+ loafB:E-9 E-15 E-29 O-9 E1 O-31 O13
t3 block+ loafA:E9 E1 O-13 O-39 E-15 E-11
t3 block+ loafA:E-9 E-15 O-29 O-55 E-31 E-27
t3 block+ boatD:E-9 E-15 O-23 E-37 O-25 O5 O3
t4 block+ boatB:E-9 E-3 E-3 O-3 E11 O-3 E-29
t4 block+ boatA blinkerA:E9 E15 O-3 E33 O5 O29 E15
t4 block+ boatA blinkerA:E-9 E-1 O-19 E17 O-11 O13 E-1
t3 block+ blinkerB:E9 E9 O19 O7 E-21 O-17 E-3
t3 block+ blinkerB:E9 E17 O25 O-47 O-9 O33 O-33
t4 block+ blinkerB:E9 E15 E31 O33 E43 E9 O21
t4 block+ blinkerB:E9 E1 O19 O-3 E23 O21 O23
t4 block+ blinkerB:E9 E1 E-15 O9 E-23 O-5 E21
t3 block+ blinkerB:E9 E-7 E27 O29 E-1 O-13
t3 block+ blinkerB:E9 E-7 E23 O5 E-23 O-19 E-5
t3 block+ blinkerB:E9 E-7 E23 E-21 O-23 O7 E13
t3 block+ blinkerB:E-9 E1 O9 O-63 O-25 O17 O-49
t3 block+ blinkerB:E-9 E-9 O-27 E-33 O-3 O3 O1
t3 block+ blinkerB:E-9 E-7 O3 O-9 E-37 O-33 E-19
t3 block+ blinkerB:E-9 E-7 E-35 O-37 O-7 O3 E-1
t3 block+ blinkerB:E-9 E-23 E7 O-11 E-39 O-35 E-21
t3 block+ blinkerB:E-9 E-23 E7 E-37 O-39 O-9 E-3
t3 block+ blinkerB:E-9 E-23 E11 O13 E-17 O-29
t4 block+ blinkerB:E-9 E-15 O3 O-19 E7 O5 O7
t4 block+ blinkerB:E-9 E-15 E-31 O-7 E-39 O-21 E5
t4 block+ blinkerB:E-9 E-1 O-19 E-11 O-29 E-19 E-25
t4 block+ blinkerB:E-9 E-1 E15 O17 E27 E-7 O5
t3 block+ blinkerB blinkerA:E9 E9 O13 E-3 E15 O-11
t3 block+ blinkerB blinkerA:E-9 E-7 O11 O17 E5 O-21
t3 block+ blinkerB blinkerA:E-9 E-7 O-3 E-19 E-1 O-27
t4 block+ blinkerA:E9 E9 O-19 E9 O5 O19 E-9
t4 block+ blinkerA:E9 E3 E3 O21 E27 E-11 O-9
t3 block+ blinkerA:E9 E23 E7 E-39 O-21 E-21 E-3
t3 block+ blinkerA:E9 E15 O35 E3 O-25 O7 O25
t3 block+ blinkerA:E9 E-7 E27 O29 E-1 O-13 O-35
t4 block+ blinkerA:E9 E-7 E23 O-21 E7 O3 E-11
t3 block+ blinkerA:E9 E-7 E23 E-23 E-7 O5 O-19
t3 block+ blinkerA:E-9 E7 E-9 E-55 O-37 E-37 E-19
t4 block+ blinkerA:E-9 E-7 O-35 E-7 O-11 O3 E-25
t3 block+ blinkerA:E-9 E-7 E-37 E-21 E3 O-9 O-33
t4 block+ blinkerA:E-9 E-23 E7 O-37 E-9 O-13 E-27
t3 block+ blinkerA:E-9 E-23 E7 E-39 E-23 O-11 O-35
t3 block+ blinkerA:E-9 E-23 E11 O13 E-17 O-29 O-51
t3 block+ blinkerA:E-9 E-15 O3 E-5 O13 E3 E9
t3 block+ blinkerA:E-9 E-15 E-29 O-9 E1 O13
t4 block+ blinkerA:E-9 E-13 E-13 O5 E11 E-27 O-25
t3 block+ blinkerA:E-9 E-1 O19 E-13 O-41 O-9 O9
t4 block+ blinkerA+:E9 E1 O19 O-15 E23 E21 E23
t3 block+ blinkerA+:E9 E1 O-15 O7 E17 O29
t4 block+ blinkerA+:E-9 E-15 O3 O-31 E7 E5 E7
t3 block+ blinkerA+:E-9 E-15 O-31 O-9 E1 O13
t3 block+ blinkerA+ blinkerB+:E9 E27 E17 E9 E27 E41
t4 block+ blinkerA+ blinkerB+:E9 E-11 E-1 E7 E-11 E-25
t3 block+ blinkerA+ blinkerB+:E-9 E11 E1 E-7 E11 E25
t4 block+ blinkerA+ blinkerB+:E-9 E-27 E-17 E-9 E-27 E-41
t3 block+ blinkerA blinkerB:E-9 E-15 O-31 O-9 E1 E-39 O13
t3 block+ blinkerA beehiveB:E9 E-7 E23 E-23 E-7 O5
t3 block+ blinkerA beehiveB:E-9 E-7 E-37 E-21 E3 O-9
t3 block+ blinkerA beehiveB:E-9 E-23 E7 E-39 E-23 O-11
t3 block+ beehiveB:E9 E7 O-11 O1 O13 O19 O17
t4 block+ beehiveB:E9 E3 E3 E15 O31 E27 O13
t3 block+ beehiveB:E9 E27 E17 E9 E19 E31 E41
t3 block+ beehiveB:E9 E15 E-1 E7 O-15 O-7 O11
t3 block+ beehiveB:E-9 E11 E1 E-7 E3 E15 E25
t3 block+ beehiveB:E-9 E-9 O-27 O-15 O-3 O3 O1
t4 block+ beehiveB:E-9 E-9 O-17 O-1 E-1 E-25 O-29
t4 block+ beehiveB:E-9 E-7 O-31 O-3 O-11 O-27 O-7
t3 block+ beehiveB:E-9 E-7 E-27 O-3 E11 E-13 E-7
t3 block+ beehiveB:E-9 E-3 E-3 E-33 E-7 E-1 E-31
t3 block+ beehiveB:E-9 E-15 O-35 O-31 O-9 E1 O13
t4 block+ beehiveB:E-9 E-13 E-13 E-1 O15 E11 O-3
t4 block+ beehiveB:E-9 E-1 E15 O23 O-27 O-17 E-5
t3 block+ beehiveB:E-9 E-1 E-17 E-9 O-31 O-23 O-5
t4 block+ beehiveA:E9 E3 E-1 E-19 E-23 E-25 E-27
t4 block+ beehiveA:E9 E29 E-21 E-35 E-37 E-23 O-33
t4 block+ beehiveA:E9 E23 E23 E-7 O7 E3 E-11
t3 block+ beehiveA:E9 E13 E13 O13 E-9 O-13 E-27
t4 block+ beehiveA:E9 E13 E13 E35 O15 O-1 E-13
t4 block+ beehiveA:E9 E1 O19 E13 E-3 O-15 E25
t4 block+ beehiveA:E9 E1 E-15 E3 O-21 E-29 O-13
t4 block+ beehiveA:E-9 E7 E7 E-23 O-9 E-13 E-27
t4 block+ beehiveA:E-9 E13 E-37 E-51 E-53 E-39 O-49
t3 block+ beehiveA:E-9 E-9 O15 O-13 O-5 O11 O-9
t4 block+ beehiveA:E-9 E-9 E11 O-13 E-27 E-3 E-9
t3 block+ beehiveA:E-9 E-3 E-3 O-3 E-25 O-29 E-43
t4 block+ beehiveA:E-9 E-3 E-3 E19 O-1 O-17 E-29
t4 block+ beehiveA:E-9 E-15 O3 E-3 E-19 O-31 E9
t3 block+ beehiveA:E-9 E-15 E-31 O-39 O11 O1 E-11
t4 block+ beehiveA:E-9 E-15 E-31 E-13 O-37 E-45 O-29
t4 block+ beehiveA:E-9 E-13 E-17 E-35 E-39 E-41 E-43
t4 block+ beehiveA shipB:E9 E3 E-1 E-19 E-23 E-25
t4 block+ beehiveA shipB:E-9 E-13 E-17 E-35 E-39 E-41
t4 block+ beehiveA pond:E9 E3 E-1 E-19 E-23
t4 block+ beehiveA pond:E-9 E-13 E-17 E-35 E-39
t4 block+ beehiveA mangoA1:E9 E7 O23 O23 O23 O-5
t4 block+ beehiveA mangoA1:E-9 E-9 O7 O7 O7 O-21
t4 block+ beehiveA blinkerA+ blinkerB+:E9 E-11 E-1 E7 E-11
t4 block+ beehiveA blinkerA+ blinkerB+:E-9 E-27 E-17 E-9 E-27
t3 block+ beehiveA beehiveB:E9 E23 E27 E29 E31
t4 block+ beehiveA beehiveB:E9 E-11 E-1 E7
t3 block+ beehiveA beehiveB:E-9 E7 E11 E13 E15
t4 block+ beehiveA beehiveB:E-9 E-27 E-17 E-9
t3 blinkerB+ block+:E9 E3 E3 O-1 O33 O33 E15
t3 blinkerB+ block+:E-9 E-13 E-13 O-17 O17 O17 E-1
t4 blinkerB+ block+:E-9 E-1 O15 O-7 E-17 O-29
t4 blinkerB+ block+ loafC beehiveB:E9 E-7 E5 E-3 E7
t4 blinkerB+ block+ loafC beehiveB:E-9 E-23 E-11 E-19 E-9
t4 blinkerB boatB block++ beehiveA:E9 E15 O23 E-5 E-3
t4 blinkerB boatB block++ beehiveA:E-9 E-1 O7 E-21 E-19
t4 blinkerB boatB beehiveA block+:E9 E15 O23 E-5 E-3 O25
t4 blinkerB boatB beehiveA block+:E-9 E-1 O7 E-21 E-19 O9
t4 blinkerB block+:E9 E9 E9 E-7 O19 O-19 O5
t4 blinkerB block+:E9 E15 E29 O9 E-1 O-13
t4 blinkerB block+:E9 E13 E13 O13 O-15 O-19 O23
t4 blinkerB block+:E9 E-7 E23 E7 E-9 O-21 O3
t4 blinkerB block+:E-9 E-9 E21 E5 E-19 O-7 O17
t4 blinkerB block+:E-9 E-7 E-7 E-23 O3 O-35 O-11
t4 blinkerB block+:E-9 E-3 E-3 O-3 O-31 O-35 O7
t4 blinkerB block+:E-9 E-23 E7 E-9 E-25 O-37 O-13
t4 blinkerB block+:E-9 E-1 E13 O-7 E-17 O-29
t4 blinkerB block++:E9 E7 O-11 O-17 E-5 E21 O25
t4 blinkerB block++:E9 E7 O-11 O-17 E-5 E21
t4 blinkerB block++:E-9 E-9 O-27 O-33 E-21 E5 O9
t4 blinkerB block++:E-9 E-9 O-27 O-33 E-21 E5
t4 blinkerB block++:E-9 E-1 O15 O-7 E-17 O13 O-29
t4 blinkerB block++:E-9 E-1 E15 O5 O-7 E-17 O-29
t4 blinkerB block+++:E9 E9 E-3 O-5 O9 E3
t4 blinkerB block+++:E9 E9 E-3 O-5 O7
t3 blinkerB block+++:E9 E7 E19 O21 O7
t4 blinkerB block+++:E9 E-7 E5 E-3 E7 O-29
t3 blinkerB block+++:E-9 E-9 E3 O5 O-9
t4 blinkerB block+++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O-9
t4 blinkerB block+++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O-7 E-13
t4 blinkerB block+++:E-9 E-23 E-11 E-19 E-9 O-45
t4 blinkerB block+++ boatA:E9 E15 O35 O9 O9
t4 blinkerB block+++ boatA:E-9 E-1 O19 O-7 O-7
t4 blinkerB block++ boatA beehiveA:E9 E15 E33 E17 O5
t4 blinkerB block++ boatA beehiveA:E-9 E-1 E17 E1 O-11
t4 blinkerB block+ blinkerA:E-9 E-1 O15 O-7 E-17 E23 O-29
t4 blinkerB block+ beehiveA:E9 E9 E9 E-7 O19 O-19
t4 blinkerB block+ beehiveA:E9 E-7 E23 E7 E-9 O-21
t4 blinkerB block+ beehiveA:E-9 E7 E-23 E23 E7 O-5
t4 blinkerB block+ beehiveA:E-9 E-9 E21 E5 E-19 O-7
t4 blinkerB block+ beehiveA:E-9 E-7 E-7 E-23 O3 O-35
t4 blinkerB block+ beehiveA:E-9 E-23 E7 E-9 E-25 O-37
t4 blinkerB blinkerA block+:E9 E15 O-3 E15 O-7 E-15 E-13
t4 blinkerB blinkerA block+:E-9 E-1 O-19 E-1 O-23 E-31 E-29
t4 blinkerA+ blinkerB block++:E9 E7 O3 E19 E1
t4 blinkerA+ blinkerB block++:E-9 E-9 O-13 E3 E-15
t4 blinkerA block+:E9 E9 E7 O19 O9 O-21 E-27
t4 blinkerA block+:E9 E-7 E23 E5 O7 O-23 E-29
t4 blinkerA block+:E-9 E-9 E19 O21 O-9 O-19 E-15
t4 blinkerA block+:E-9 E-7 O11 E17 O-13 O-19 O-17
t4 blinkerA block+:E-9 E-7 E-9 O3 O-7 O-37 E-43
t4 blinkerA block+:E-9 E-23 E7 E-11 O-9 O-39 E-45
t4 blinkerA block++:E9 E7 O-11 O-17 E-5 E21 E45
t4 blinkerA block++:E-9 E-9 O-27 O-33 E-21 E5 E29
t4 blinkerA block+++:E9 E9 E-3 O-5 O9
t3 blinkerA block+++:E9 E1 O33 O-7 O-25 E-21
t3 blinkerA block+++:E-9 E-9 E3 O5 O-7
t4 blinkerA block+++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O-7
t3 blinkerA block+++:E-9 E-15 O17 O-23 O-41 E-37
t4 blinkerA block+++ blinkerB:E9 E15 O35 O17 O11 O7
t4 blinkerA block+++ blinkerB:E-9 E-1 O19 O1 O-5 O-9
t3 blinkerA block++ blinkerB+:E9 E15 E21 O21 E19 E-5
t3 blinkerA block++ blinkerB+:E-9 E-1 E5 O5 E3 E-21
t4 blinkerA blinkerB block+:E9 E7 O-11 O-17 E-5 O21
t4 blinkerA blinkerB block+:E-9 E-9 O-27 O-33 E-21 O5
t3 beehiveB+ block+:E9 E27 E17 E9 E19 E31
t3 beehiveB+ block+:E-9 E11 E1 E-7 E3 E15
t3 beehiveB block+:E9 E27 E17 E9 E39
t3 beehiveB block+:E-9 E11 E1 E-7 E23
t3 beehiveB block++:E9 E27 E17 E9 E35
t3 beehiveB block++:E-9 E11 E1 E-7 E19
t4 beehiveB block++:E-9 E-15 O-23 O-37 O-23 O-37
t4 beehiveB block++:E-9 E-15 O-23 O-37 O-23
t4 beehiveB block+++:E9 E9 E-3 O-5 O1
t4 beehiveB block+++:E9 E-7 E-11 E-9 E-9 E19
t4 beehiveB block+++:E-9 E-9 E9 O-29 O7
t4 beehiveB block+++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O-15
t4 beehiveB block+++:E-9 E-23 E-27 E-25 E-25 E3
t4 beehiveB block++++:E9 E-7 E-11 E-9 E25
t4 beehiveB block++++:E-9 E-23 E-27 E-25 E9
t4 beehiveB block++++ beehiveA:E9 E-7 E-11 E-9
t4 beehiveB block++++ beehiveA:E-9 E-23 E-27 E-25
t3 beehiveB block+++ beehiveA:E9 E7 E19 O21
t4 beehiveB block+++ beehiveA:E9 E-7 E-11 E-9 E-9
t3 beehiveB block+++ beehiveA:E-9 E-9 E3 O5
t4 beehiveB block+++ beehiveA:E-9 E-23 E-27 E-25 E-25
t3 beehiveB block++ pond:E9 E27 E17 E9 E19
t3 beehiveB block++ pond:E-9 E11 E1 E-7 E3
t3 beehiveB block++ beehiveA:E9 E7 E19 O21 O53
t3 beehiveB block++ beehiveA:E-9 E-9 E3 O5 O37
t4 beehiveB block+ shipB:E9 E-7 E-11 E-13 E19
t4 beehiveB block+ shipB:E-9 E-23 E-27 E-29 E3
t4 beehiveB block+ pond:E9 E-7 E19 E-11
t4 beehiveB block+ pond:E-9 E-23 E3 E-27
t3 beehiveB block+ blinkerA+ blinkerB+:E9 E27 E17 E9 E27
t3 beehiveB block+ blinkerA+ blinkerB+:E-9 E11 E1 E-7 E11
t4 beehiveB block+ beehiveA:E9 E-7 E-11 E-13 E-15
t4 beehiveB block+ beehiveA:E-9 E-23 E-27 E-29 E-31
t4 beehiveB block+ beehiveA shipB:E9 E-7 E-11 E-13
t4 beehiveB block+ beehiveA shipB:E-9 E-23 E-27 E-29
t4 beehiveB block+ beehiveA pond:E9 E-7 E-11
t4 beehiveB block+ beehiveA pond:E-9 E-23 E-27
t4 beehiveB blinkerB block+:E9 E13 E13 O13 O-15 O-19
t4 beehiveB blinkerB block+:E-9 E-3 E-3 O-3 O-31 O-35
t3 beehiveB beehiveA block+:E9 E27 E17 E9
t3 beehiveB beehiveA block+:E-9 E11 E1 E-7
t4 beehiveB beehiveA block++:E9 E9 E-3 O-5 O-37
t4 beehiveB beehiveA block++:E9 E7 E25 O23 O-9
t4 beehiveB beehiveA block++:E-9 E-9 E9 O7 O-25
t3 beehiveB beehiveA block++:E-9 E-7 E-25 O-23 O9
t4 beehiveB beehiveA block++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O-53
t3 beehiveB beehiveA block+++:E9 E9 E-9 O-7
t4 beehiveB beehiveA block+++:E9 E9 E-3 O-5 O-47
t4 beehiveB beehiveA block+++:E9 E9 E-3 O-5
t4 beehiveB beehiveA block+++:E9 E7 E25 O23
t4 beehiveB beehiveA block+++:E-9 E-9 E9 O7
t3 beehiveB beehiveA block+++:E-9 E-7 E-25 O-23
t4 beehiveB beehiveA block+++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O-63
t4 beehiveB beehiveA block+++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21
t3 beehiveA block+:E9 E7 E19 O-1 E9 O-1 O-5
t3 beehiveA block+:E9 E23 E-1 E13 O15 E-35 E-5
t4 beehiveA block+:E9 E15 E21 O9 E-1 E21 E-15
t3 beehiveA block+:E-9 E7 E-17 E-3 O-1 E-51 E-21
t3 beehiveA block+:E-9 E-9 E3 O-17 E-7 O-17 O-21
t4 beehiveA block+:E-9 E-7 O11 O-1 O-13 O-19 O-17
t3 beehiveA block+:E-9 E-7 O1 O-15 E-15 E9 O13
t4 beehiveA block+:E-9 E-13 E-13 E17 E-9 E-15 E15
t4 beehiveA block+:E-9 E-1 O19 O15 O-7 E-17 O-29
t4 beehiveA block+:E-9 E-1 E5 O-7 E-17 E5 E-31
t4 beehiveA block+++:E9 E9 E-3 O-5 O29
t4 beehiveA block+++:E9 E7 E25 O23 O29
t4 beehiveA block+++:E-9 E-9 E9 O7 O13
t3 beehiveA block+++:E-9 E-7 E-25 O13 O-23
t4 beehiveA block+++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O13
t3 beehiveA block+ blinkerA+ loafC:E9 E23 E11 E19 E9
t3 beehiveA block+ blinkerA+ loafC:E-9 E7 E-5 E3 E-7
t3 tub block+:E9 E17 O23 O-5 O-37 E-13 E11
t3 tub block+:E-9 E1 O7 O-21 O-53 E-29 E-5
t3 shipB block+++:E-9 E-9 E3 O5 O-7 E3
t4 shipB block+++:E-9 E-7 E-19 O-21 O-9 E-19
t3 shipB block+ beehiveA:E9 E23 E27 E29 E-3
t3 shipB block+ beehiveA:E-9 E7 E11 E13 E-19
t3 shipB block+ beehiveA beehiveB:E9 E23 E27 E29
t3 shipB block+ beehiveA beehiveB:E-9 E7 E11 E13
t4 shipA block+:E-9 E-15 E-29 E-31 E-25 O1 E-9
t3 shipA block+:E-9 E-1 E13 E15 E9 O-17 E-7
t4 shipA block+++:E9 E1 E5 E-7 O-9 E-11
t4 shipA block+++:E-9 E-15 E-11 E-23 O-25 E-27
t3 pond+ block++:E9 E23 E-3 E27 E-11
t4 pond+ block++:E9 E-7 E19 E-11 E27
t3 pond+ block++:E-9 E7 E-19 E11 E-27
t4 pond+ block++:E-9 E-23 E3 E-27 E11
t3 pond block+:E-9 E7 E-19 E11 E-29
t3 pond block+:E-9 E-1 E13 O13 O-13 E-21 O5
t3 pond block++ boatA:E9 E27 E17 E35 E39
t3 pond block++ boatA:E-9 E11 E1 E19 E23
t3 pond block+ beehiveB:E9 E13 E17 E35 E39
t3 pond block+ beehiveB:E-9 E-3 E1 E19 E23
t3 pond block+ beehiveA:E9 E23 E-3 E27
t3 pond block+ beehiveA:E-9 E7 E-19 E11
t3 pond block+ beehiveA beehiveB:E9 E23 E27
t3 pond block+ beehiveA beehiveB:E-9 E7 E11
t3 longboatA block+:E9 E23 E7 E-11 E-5 O-9 O-27
t3 longboatA block+:E-9 E7 E-9 E-27 E-21 O-25 O-43
t4 loafD block+:E9 E9 E7 O19 E11 O-21 E-5
t4 loafD block+:E9 E-7 E23 E5 E9 O-23 E-7
t4 loafD block+:E-9 E7 E-23 E21 E25 O-7 E9
t4 loafD block+:E-9 E-9 E19 O-19 E23 O-9 E7
t4 loafD block+:E-9 E-7 E-9 O3 E-5 O-37 E-21
t4 loafD block+:E-9 E-23 E7 E-11 E-7 O-39 E-23
t3 loafB block+:E9 E9 E13 O27 E-21 E-27
t4 loafB block+:E9 E7 E11 O9 O17 E-13
t3 loafB block+:E9 E23 E-1 E13 O15 E-35
t3 loafB block+:E9 E15 O-3 O31 O27 O-5
t3 loafB block+:E-9 E7 E-17 E-3 O-1 E-51
t4 loafB block+:E-9 E-9 E-5 O-7 O1 E-29
t3 loafB block+:E-9 E-7 E-3 O11 E-37 E-43
t3 loafB block+:E-9 E-1 O-19 O15 O11 O-21
t3 boatD block+:E-9 E-13 E-13 O-13 E-27 O-13 E13
t4 boatC beaconA2 blinkerB block++:E9 E7 O-11 O-17 E-5
t4 boatC beaconA2 blinkerB block++:E-9 E-9 O-27 O-33 E-21
t4 boatB block+:E9 E15 O23 E37 O25 O-5 O-3
t4 boatB block+:E-9 E-1 O7 E21 O9 O-21 O-19
t4 boatB block+++:E9 E9 O17 O41 E-3 O-5
t4 boatB block+++:E-9 E-7 O1 O25 E-19 O-21
t4 boatA block+:E9 E3 E3 O-7 E-21 E1 O-17
t3 boatA block+:E-9 E-15 E-15 E-31 O-17 O-5 O-21
t4 boatA block+:E-9 E-15 E-15 E-31 O-17 E-11 O5
t4 boatA block+:E-9 E-13 E-13 O-23 E-37 E-15 O-33
t4 boatA block+:E-9 E-1 E-1 E15 O1 O-11 O5
t3 boatA block+:E-9 E-1 E-1 E15 O1 E-5 O-21
t3 boatA block+++:E9 E1 E5 O-29 E-27 O-25
t3 boatA block+++:E9 E1 E17 E-15 O-15
t3 boatA block+++:E-9 E-15 E1 E-31 O-31
t3 boatA block+++:E-9 E-15 E-11 O-45 E-43 O-41
t3 boatA block+++ blinkerA:E9 E1 O-19 O7 O7
t3 boatA block+++ blinkerA:E-9 E-15 O-35 O-9 O-9
t3 boatA block++ blinkerA:E9 E1 O-19 O7 O7 O-21
t3 boatA block++ blinkerA:E-9 E-15 O-35 O-9 O-9 O-37
t3 boatA block++ blinkerA beehiveB:E-9 E-15 E-33 E-17 O-5
t4 boatA blinkerB block++:E9 E1 E1 O-15 O-9 E1
t4 boatA blinkerB block++:E-9 E-15 E-15 O-31 O-25 E-15
t4 boatA blinkerB block++++:E9 E1 O-13 O-67 O-29
t4 boatA blinkerB block++++:E-9 E-15 O-29 O-83 O-45
t4 boatA blinkerB block+ beehiveA:E9 E1 O19 E13 E-3 O-15
t4 boatA blinkerB block+ beehiveA:E-9 E-15 O3 E-3 E-19 O-31
This is one of the possible adjustments to the definition of "Spartan", and one of the caveats to the usefulness of Blockic constructions, that I don't really want to think about too much right now! See, it's really more efficient sometimes to construct stable circuitry one small constellation at a time, instead of just one still life at a time:
Code: Select all
#C construct 3 blocks at once
#C -- two for a 180-degree turner triggered from the side, plus one elbow
#C orientaton #4 block++:E-9 E-23 E1 E-13 O-15 E35 E-7
x = 1032, y = 1958, rule = LifeHistory
1029.A$1029.A.A$1029.2A1033$2E$2E19$15.3A$15.A$16.A148$158.3A$158.A$
159.A148$320.3A$320.A$321.A148$463.3A$463.A$464.A148$613.2A$612.2A$
614.A148$787.3A$787.A$788.A148$916.3A$916.A$917.A!
Now, technically there's at least one orientation of boat that can be constructed with just four gliders from a block -- or five gliders, if you want to leave a block off to the side to continue the construction with. So even with this new constellation-construction trick, boats are now a little cheaper than Blockic turners. And if I can construct boats in constellation with other nearby still lifes sometimes, that will make them still cheaper.
Boats and Blockic turners can't be compared exactly, since the output gliders are different colors, and anyway in some cases a boat-construction won't fit in some particular location where a 2-block-OTT construction will. But in general I should probably stop assuming that Blockic one-time turners are going to be a particularly cheap option.
Instead, I should really make a new collection of OTTs, by running through (let's say) every six-gliders-or-less intermediate target in the p2 block-move table, hitting each one with every possible glider from every possible direction, and seeing which ones happen to be clean glider turners. One-time circuitry would then be built with those constellations -- a different group of OTTs for each trigger glider input direction.
Not sure when I'll get around to trying all those collisions and classifying the timing of the results -- it ends up being quite a bit of work, and for the replicator project I can get by just fine with the Blockic turners I've already collected. And the new list of inexpensive OTTs wouldn't be exhaustive, unfortunately. Intermediate targets can only be found in the block-move table if there's a way of reducing them to a single block with a total recipe of ten gliders or less.
So inevitably there will be some intermediate targets that Glue threw out because they're useless from a block-moving perspective, that turn out to be handy from a one-time-turner point of view... Ah, well. Once we have several thousand inexpensive one-time turners available, it probably won't matter too much if another few thousand are missing!
Some of these new OTTs may not actually be Spartan. See this
earlier post -- you can get aircraft carriers, snakes, shillelaghs, boat-ties, long barges, long ships, integrals, eleveners, canoes, hats, biponds, boats-with-tails, tubs-with-tails, etc. as part of these constellations. But because they're all just eight gliders or less away from a block, they're Just As Good As Spartan, or maybe better.
For now I'll call these hypothetical OTTs "BT-Spartan" (Better Than Spartan). The name probably won't stick, but you never know until you try...!
