Spaceship Discussion Thread

[calcyman]

I believe this prevents ikpx2 from advancing to a new width, since i think ikpx2 will always find a new (repetitive) tail piece which can be attached. A maximum length option would be helpful in such a case.

This shouldn't happen: ikpx2 stores the entire search progress in memory to avoid ever performing the same work twice. As such, it doesn't produce spaceships containing multiple copies of a repeatable component.

[dexter1]

I believe this prevents ikpx2 from advancing to a new width, since i think ikpx2 will always find a new (repetitive) tail piece which can be attached. A maximum length option would be helpful in such a case.

This shouldn't happen: ikpx2 stores the entire search progress in memory to avoid ever performing the same work twice. As such, it doesn't produce spaceships containing multiple copies of a repeatable component.

Thanks for the clarification: i wasn't completely sure about the program handling repeating components, hence the brackets.
Well, even if the amount of tail variations and orientations are finite, it will still take a lot of time to go through all the combinations.

PS: i found in yesterdays logs another c/5 ship:

Code: Select all

x = 23, y = 61, rule = B3/S23
2b2ob2o9b2ob2o$bobo3bo7bo3bobo$bobobobo7bobobobo$2b2ob2o9b2ob2o2$2b2o
15b2o2$3o17b3o$2ob3o11b3ob2o$2b2o2b2o7b2o2b2o$2bo3bobo5bobo3bo$3bob2ob
2o3b2ob2obo$4bo4b2ob2o4bo$5bobobo3bobobo$6bo9bo$8bobobobo$9bo3bo$7b3o
3b3o$6bo3bobo3bo2$5bobo7bobo$3bo4b3ob3o4bo$3bo6bobo6bo$4o3bo7bo3b4o$6b
2o7b2o$bobo3b2o5b2o3bobo$2bo2b2o2b2ob2o2b2o2bo$2bo2b3ob2ob2ob3o2bo$5bo
3b2ob2o3bo$5bo2b2o3b2o2bo$2b3o4bo3bo4b3o$bobo3b3o3b3o3bobo$bobobo3bo3b
o3bobobo$7b3o3b3o$4bo3bo5bo3bo$3bo2bo9bo2bo$3obo13bob3o$2obob2ob2o3b2o
b2obob2o$2bo3bo3bobo3bo3bo$3o4bobo3bobo4b3o$8bo5bo2$2b3o13b3o$2obo2b4o
3b4o2bob2o$o2b2o2bobo3bobo2b2o2bo$3bo3b2o5b2o3bo$b2o17b2o2$5bo11bo$3b
2ob2o7b2ob2o$3b3o11b3o$2bo5bo5bo5bo$2b3o3b3ob3o3b3o$bo19bo$2bob2o2bo5b
o2b2obo$4b2o2bo5bo2b2o$3b2obobo5bobob2o$3bo2b2o7b2o2bo$b3o6bobo6b3o$bo
4b3obobob3o4bo$bo4b2o7b2o4bo!

[bubblegum]

PS: i found in yesterdays logs another c/5 ship:

Hm. Is this the first known ship pushing two of the GD components at the front?

Oh, and are you using ikpx2 for these? I would recommend you create a payosha256 key if you haven't already and upload your results to Catagolue.

Also, flipping the GDs around leads to two more distinct ships:

Code: Select all

x = 103, y = 61, rule = B3/S23
2b2ob2o9b2ob2o21b2ob2o9b2ob2o21b2ob2o9b2ob2o$bobo3bo7bo3bobo19bo3bobo
7bo3bobo19bo3bobo7bobo3bo$bobobobo7bobobobo19bobobobo7bobobobo19bobobo
bo7bobobobo$2b2ob2o9b2ob2o21b2ob2o9b2ob2o21b2ob2o9b2ob2o2$2b2o15b2o21b
2o15b2o21b2o15b2o2$3o17b3o17b3o17b3o17b3o17b3o$2ob3o11b3ob2o17b2ob3o
11b3ob2o17b2ob3o11b3ob2o$2b2o2b2o7b2o2b2o21b2o2b2o7b2o2b2o21b2o2b2o7b
2o2b2o$2bo3bobo5bobo3bo21bo3bobo5bobo3bo21bo3bobo5bobo3bo$3bob2ob2o3b
2ob2obo23bob2ob2o3b2ob2obo23bob2ob2o3b2ob2obo$4bo4b2ob2o4bo25bo4b2ob2o
4bo25bo4b2ob2o4bo$5bobobo3bobobo27bobobo3bobobo27bobobo3bobobo$6bo9bo
29bo9bo29bo9bo$8bobobobo33bobobobo33bobobobo$9bo3bo35bo3bo35bo3bo$7b3o
3b3o31b3o3b3o31b3o3b3o$6bo3bobo3bo29bo3bobo3bo29bo3bobo3bo2$5bobo7bobo
27bobo7bobo27bobo7bobo$3bo4b3ob3o4bo23bo4b3ob3o4bo23bo4b3ob3o4bo$3bo6b
obo6bo23bo6bobo6bo23bo6bobo6bo$4o3bo7bo3b4o17b4o3bo7bo3b4o17b4o3bo7bo
3b4o$6b2o7b2o29b2o7b2o29b2o7b2o$bobo3b2o5b2o3bobo19bobo3b2o5b2o3bobo
19bobo3b2o5b2o3bobo$2bo2b2o2b2ob2o2b2o2bo21bo2b2o2b2ob2o2b2o2bo21bo2b
2o2b2ob2o2b2o2bo$2bo2b3ob2ob2ob3o2bo21bo2b3ob2ob2ob3o2bo21bo2b3ob2ob2o
b3o2bo$5bo3b2ob2o3bo27bo3b2ob2o3bo27bo3b2ob2o3bo$5bo2b2o3b2o2bo27bo2b
2o3b2o2bo27bo2b2o3b2o2bo$2b3o4bo3bo4b3o21b3o4bo3bo4b3o21b3o4bo3bo4b3o$
bobo3b3o3b3o3bobo19bobo3b3o3b3o3bobo19bobo3b3o3b3o3bobo$bobobo3bo3bo3b
obobo19bobobo3bo3bo3bobobo19bobobo3bo3bo3bobobo$7b3o3b3o31b3o3b3o31b3o
3b3o$4bo3bo5bo3bo25bo3bo5bo3bo25bo3bo5bo3bo$3bo2bo9bo2bo23bo2bo9bo2bo
23bo2bo9bo2bo$3obo13bob3o17b3obo13bob3o17b3obo13bob3o$2obob2ob2o3b2ob
2obob2o17b2obob2ob2o3b2ob2obob2o17b2obob2ob2o3b2ob2obob2o$2bo3bo3bobo
3bo3bo21bo3bo3bobo3bo3bo21bo3bo3bobo3bo3bo$3o4bobo3bobo4b3o17b3o4bobo
3bobo4b3o17b3o4bobo3bobo4b3o$8bo5bo33bo5bo33bo5bo2$2b3o13b3o21b3o13b3o
21b3o13b3o$2obo2b4o3b4o2bob2o17b2obo2b4o3b4o2bob2o17b2obo2b4o3b4o2bob
2o$o2b2o2bobo3bobo2b2o2bo17bo2b2o2bobo3bobo2b2o2bo17bo2b2o2bobo3bobo2b
2o2bo$3bo3b2o5b2o3bo23bo3b2o5b2o3bo23bo3b2o5b2o3bo$b2o17b2o19b2o17b2o
19b2o17b2o2$5bo11bo27bo11bo27bo11bo$3b2ob2o7b2ob2o23b2ob2o7b2ob2o23b2o
b2o7b2ob2o$3b3o11b3o23b3o11b3o23b3o11b3o$2bo5bo5bo5bo21bo5bo5bo5bo21bo
5bo5bo5bo$2b3o3b3ob3o3b3o21b3o3b3ob3o3b3o21b3o3b3ob3o3b3o$bo19bo19bo
19bo19bo19bo$2bob2o2bo5bo2b2obo21bob2o2bo5bo2b2obo21bob2o2bo5bo2b2obo$
4b2o2bo5bo2b2o25b2o2bo5bo2b2o25b2o2bo5bo2b2o$3b2obobo5bobob2o23b2obobo
5bobob2o23b2obobo5bobob2o$3bo2b2o7b2o2bo23bo2b2o7b2o2bo23bo2b2o7b2o2bo
$b3o6bobo6b3o19b3o6bobo6b3o19b3o6bobo6b3o$bo4b3obobob3o4bo19bo4b3obobo
b3o4bo19bo4b3obobob3o4bo$bo4b2o7b2o4bo19bo4b2o7b2o4bo19bo4b2o7b2o4bo!

[HartmutHolzwart]

Width2 c/2 chicken "triangle":...



Maybe someone is more lucky with this one than me.

width 8 rectangular c/2 chicken ship

Code: Select all

x = 201, y = 125, rule = B3/S23
5$16bo4bo154bo4bo$15b3ob2ob2ob4o2b3o13bo6bo8bo6bo8bo6bo8bo6bo8bo6bo8bo
6bo8bo6bo13b3o2b4ob2ob2ob3o$14b4o7b4obo3bo11b3o4b3o6b3o4b3o6b3o4b3o6b
3o4b3o6b3o4b3o6b3o4b3o6b3o4b3o11bo3bob4o7b4o$13b2o2b2obobob2o2bo6bo9bo
2b2o2bo2b2o4bo2b2o2bo2b2o4bo2b2o2bo2b2o4bo2b2o2bo2b2o4bo2b2o2bo2b2o4bo
2b2o2bo2b2o4bo2b2o2bo2b2o9bo6bo2b2obobob2o2b2o$14bo10bo4b2o3bo17bobo
13bobo13bobo13bobo13bobo13bobo13bobo10bo3b2o4bo10bo$13b2o10bo7bo11b2o
3b7o4b2o3b7o4b2o3b7o4b2o3b7o4b2o3b7o4b2o3b7o4b2o3b7o11bo7bo10b2o$11b2o
bob2o16bobo15bo15bo15bo15bo15bo15bo15bo12bobo16b2obob2o$12bobo2b2o6b2o
4b2obob2o7bo2bob2o2b3o4bo2bob2o2b3o4bo2bob2o2b3o4bo2bob2o2b3o4bo2bob2o
2b3o4bo2bob2o2b3o4bo2bob2o2b3o7b2obob2o4b2o6b2o2bobo$9b2obo2bo2bo5bo6b
o2bobob2o6b2o5bo8b2o5bo8b2o5bo8b2o5bo8b2o5bo8b2o5bo8b2o5bo8b2obobo2bo
6bo5bo2bo2bob2o$9b2obo5b2o7b3obo4bobo6bo5bo2bobo4bo5bo2bobo4bo5bo2bobo
4bo5bo2bobo4bo5bo2bobo4bo5bo2bobo4bo5bo2bobo6bobo4bob3o7b2o5bob2o$9bob
o12b2o3bobob2obobob2o2bob2o3bo2bo2bo2bob2o3bo2bo2bo2bob2o3bo2bo2bo2bob
2o3bo2bo2bo2bob2o3bo2bo2bo2bob2o3bo2bo2bo2bob2o3bo2bo2bo2b2obobob2obob
o3b2o12bobo$8b2ob2o18bo4bobob2o2b2o3bo6bo3b2o3bo6bo3b2o3bo6bo3b2o3bo6b
o3b2o3bo6bo3b2o3bo6bo3b2o3bo6bo3b2obobo4bo18b2ob2o$28b2o2bo2bo2bobob2o
b4ob4o3b3ob4ob4o3b3ob4ob4o3b3ob4ob4o3b3ob4ob4o3b3ob4ob4o3b3ob4ob4o3b3o
bobo2bo2bo2b2o$38bo10bobo2b4o7bobo2b4o7bobo2b4o7bobo2b4o7bobo2b4o7bobo
2b4o7bobo2b4o5bo$39bo6bo4b2o3b2o4bo4b2o3b2o4bo4b2o3b2o4bo4b2o3b2o4bo4b
2o3b2o4bo4b2o3b2o4bo4b2o3b2o4bo$16b3o11b3o13b3o2bo3b2o5b3o2bo3b2o5b3o
2bo3b2o5b3o2bo3b2o5b3o2bo3b2o5b3o2bo3b2o5b3o2bo3b2o12b3o11b3o$15bo2bo
10bo2bo16b4o2b2o8b4o2b2o8b4o2b2o8b4o2b2o8b4o2b2o8b4o2b2o8b4o2b2o11bo2b
o10bo2bo$15bo3bo9b2o2bo2b3o8b2o2bo3bo7b2o2bo3bo7b2o2bo3bo7b2o2bo3bo7b
2o2bo3bo7b2o2bo3bo7b2o2bo3bo7b3o2bo3bo7bo4bo$9b3o8b4obob2o2b3o2bo2bo
12b2obo12b2obo12b2obo12b2obo12b2obo12b2obo12b2obo7bo2bobo2b3ob3ob5o6b
3o$9bo2bo3bo2b2obobobob4obobo3bo5b2o6b4o4b2o6b4o4b2o6b4o4b2o6b4o4b2o6b
4o4b2o6b4o4b2o6b4o4bo4bob2o4b2obobo3bo6bo2bo$9bo7bobobo2bo3bob2obobobo
2bo4bo15bo15bo15bo15bo15bo15bo15b4obob2o3bo6b4o6bo$9bo3bo8bo9b2o2bob4o
6bobo3b4o6bobo3b4o6bobo3b4o6bobo3b4o6bobo3b4o6bobo3b4o6bobo3b4o8bo7b4o
b6o5bo3bo$9bo5b2o6bo3bo4b2o8b10o2bo3b10o2bo3b10o2bo3b10o2bo3b10o2bo3b
10o2bo3b10o2bo3b10o10bo5b2o4bo$10bobo2bo5bo5bo5bo3b7o3bob2o5b4o3bob2o
5b4o3bob2o5b4o3bob2o5b4o3bob2o5b4o3bob2o5b4o3bob2o5b4o8bo9b2o5bobo3bob
o$17bo22bo3b2obo7b2o3b2obo7b2o3b2obo7b2o3b2obo7b2o3b2obo7b2o3b2obo7b2o
3b2obo7b2o3b4o4bo18bo$16bo20bo6b4o5b2o5b4o5b2o5b4o5b2o5b4o5b2o5b4o5b2o
5b4o5b2o5b4o5b2o5b2obo$45bo2bo4b2o6bo2bo4b2o6bo2bo4b2o6bo2bo4b2o6bo2bo
4b2o6bo2bo4b2o6bo2bo4b2o$45b2ob3o2bobo5b2ob3o2bobo5b2ob3o2bobo5b2ob3o
2bobo5b2ob3o2bobo5b2ob3o2bobo5b2ob3o2bobo$36b3o9bo2b2o2b2o7bo2b2o2b2o
7bo2b2o2b2o7bo2b2o2b2o7bo2b2o2b2o7bo2b2o2b2o7bo2b2o2b2o6b3o$35bo2bo5bo
2b3o6bo3bo2b3o6bo3bo2b3o6bo3bo2b3o6bo3bo2b3o6bo3bo2b3o6bo3bo2b3o6bo5bo
3bo$34bo4bo4bo6b6o3bo6b6o3bo6b6o3bo6b6o3bo6b6o3bo6b6o3bo6b6o5b2o3bo$
33bo2b5obob7o6b2ob7o6b2ob7o6b2ob7o6b2ob7o6b2ob7o6b2ob7o6bo2b2o5bo$18bo
17bob2o2bo8b7obo7b7obo7b7obo7b7obo7b7obo7b7obo7b8ob2o2bo3bo14bo$17b3o
5bo7b2obobobo2b8o9b7o9b7o9b7o9b7o9b7o9b7o8b2o3b2o2bo7bo5b3o$16b2obo4b
3o4bo2b4o13b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o6bo9b3o3b2obo$16b3o4b2o2bo2bobo
13b5o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o6b2o5b2obob4ob2obo3b3o$16b3o4b2ob3obo2b2o
16b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b4o9b3o9bo4b3o$17b2o2b3o12bo10b4o8b8o8b8o8b
8o8b8o8b8o8b8o4bo13b2o4b4o3b2o$36bo9bo4b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b4obo
17bob4o$21bo22b2ob4o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o4b2o21b2o$44b2o5b8o8b8o8b
8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b4o3bo$42bo4b4o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o4b4o$42b5o4b8o8b
8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b4o5bo$25b3o4b3o5bo6b4o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o4b6o
6b3o4b3o$25bo2bo3bo2bo4b7o4b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b4o6bo5bo2bo3bo2bo$
17bo6bo7bo7b2o5b4o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o4b4ob3o4bo6bo2bo6bo$16b3o6b
2o2bo2bo10b4o4b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b4o4b4o4bo5bo3b2o4b3o$15b2obo4b
3ob3o2bo5bo2b2o4b4o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o4b3o5bo4bobobo5bo3b2obo$15b
3o5bo13b3ob6o4b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b4o4bo4bo3bobo7b2o2b3o$16b2o12b
4o9b2o2b4o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o5bo3bo4bob2ob2o2bo2b2o4b2o$20b3o11b
2o2bo12b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b6o5bobo2bob2o7b3o$20bobo8bobo10b7o8b8o
8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o6bo8b2ob2o7b2obo$35bo7bo7b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b
8o$42b9o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8bo$30bo10bo9b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b
10o10bo$29b3o8b11o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o10bo8b3o$29bob2o6bo11b8o8b8o
8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b12o7bob2o$30b3o5b13o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o12bo7b3o
$30b2o5bo13b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b13o7b2o$35b16o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o
8b8o14b2o$33b2o16b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b14o2b2o$38b13o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b
8o8b8o8b8o16bo$33b5o13b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b13o$38b13o8b8o8b8o8b8o
8b8o8b8o8b8o16bo$51b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b12o4bo$39b12o8b8o8b8o8b8o
8b8o8b8o8b8o14b2o$40bo10b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b10o2bo$43b8o8b8o8b8o
8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o11bo$30b3o9bo8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o10b3o$30bo2bo
9b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8bo9bo2bo$30bo7b5o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o
8b8o2b3o5bo$30bo6b2obo2b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o10bob2o4bo$31bobob2o
bobo10b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b9obobob2o3bobo$35b2o4b10o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b
8o8b8o8b8o15bo$34bo2bo13b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b10o4bobo$43b8o8b8o8b
8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o$30b3o9bo8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o10b3o$30bo2bo9b
8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8bo9bo2bo$30bo7b5o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b
8o2b3o5bo$30bo6b2obo2b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o10bob2o4bo$31bobob2obo
bo10b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b9obobob2o3bobo$35b2o4b10o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o
8b8o8b8o15bo$34bo2bo13b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b10o4bobo$43b8o8b8o8b8o
8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o$30b3o9bo8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o10b3o$30bo2bo9b8o
8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8bo9bo2bo$30bo7b5o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o
2b3o5bo$30bo6b2obo2b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o10bob2o4bo$31bobob2obobo
10b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b9obobob2o3bobo$35b2o4b10o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b
8o8b8o15bo$34bo2bo13b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b10o4bobo$43b8o8b8o8b8o8b
8o8b8o8b8o8b8o$30b3o9bo8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o10b3o$30bo2bo9b8o8b
8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8bo9bo2bo$30bo7b5o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o2b
3o5bo$30bo6b2obo2b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o10bob2o4bo$31bobob2obobo
10b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b9obobob2o3bobo$35b2o4b10o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b
8o8b8o15bo$34bo2bo13b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b10o4bobo$43b8o8b8o8b8o8b
8o8b8o8b8o8b8o$42bo8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o$43b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o
8b8o8b8o8bo$41b2o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8obo$40bo2b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b
8o8b8o8b8o9b2o$7b3o5bo7bo5bo9b3o9b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o3bo9bo5bo
7bo5b3o$7bo2bo3b3o5b3o3b3o7bo4b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b5o7b3o3b3o
5b3o4bo2bo$7bo6bob2o3b2obo2b2o2bo6b5o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o5bo5b
2obo2b2obo4bo2b2o3bo$7bo10bo2b3o3b2ob2o4bo6b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o
8b8o2bo2bo3b3o5b2ob2o3bo3bo$7bo5bob2ob2obo5bo5b3ob6o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b8o8b
8o8b8o8b8o8bobo2bo5bo3bo2bob2o3bo3bo$7bo3b6o3b2o2b4o2b2o11b6ob2o7b6ob
2o7b6ob2o7b6ob2o7b6ob2o7b6ob2o7b6ob2o7b5o5bo3bo2bob2ob4o7bo$8bobo2b2o
2b2obo3b5obo5bo2bob2o8bob2o2b2o8bob2o2b2o8bob2o2b2o8bob2o2b2o8bob2o2b
2o8bob2o2b2o8bob2o2b2o8b2ob3o3b5o8bo3bobo$17bobo5bo2b4o7bo2b2o4bo3b2o
4b2o4bo3b2o4b2o4bo3b2o4b2o4bo3b2o4b2o4bo3b2o4b2o4bo3b2o4b2o4bo3b2o4b2o
5b2o4b2o7b5o$24bo5b2o3bo5bobo3bo2bo3bo2bobo3bo2bo3bo2bobo3bo2bo3bo2bob
o3bo2bo3bo2bobo3bo2bo3bo2bobo3bo2bo3bo2bobo3bo2bo3bo2bobo21b2obo$49bo
15bo15bo15bo15bo15bo15bo!

And a partial width3 obtuse triangle (front is missing):

Code: Select all

x = 151, y = 70, rule = B3/S23
9$74bo4bo$73b2o4b2o$70b4o6b4o$68bo2bo2b2o2b2o2bo2bo$67b2o3b3o6bo3b2o$
64b4o3bo2b3o2bobo4b4o$62bo2bo2b2ob2o4b3o4b2o2bo2bo$61b2o3bo4bo2b3o3b3o
2b3o3b2o$58b4o4bobo2b3o3b3o3b3o2bo3b4o$56bo2bo2b2o4b3o3b3o3b3o4b2ob2o
2bo2bo$55b2o3b3o2b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o2bo4bo3b2o$52b4o3bo2b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b
3o2bobo4b4o$50bo2bo2b2ob2o4b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o4b2o2bo2bo$49b2o3bo4bo2b
3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o2b3o3b2o$46b4o4bobo2b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o
2bo3b4o$44bo2bo2b2o4b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o4b2ob2o2bo2bo$15bo27b2o
3b3o2b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o2bo4bo3b2o27bo$14b3o23b4o3bo2b3o3b
3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o2bobo4b4o23b3o$12b2ob3o20bo2bo2b2ob2o4b
3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o4b2o2bo2bo20b3ob2o$13bo2bob2o4bo4bo
4bo2b2o3bo4bo2b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o2b3o3b2o2bo4bo4bo
4b2obo2bo$10b2obo4bobob2ob2ob3ob2ob3o4bobo2b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o
3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o2bo3b3ob2ob3ob2ob2obobo4bob2o$10b2obobo2bobo7b3o6b3o4b
3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o4b2ob2obo5b3o7bobo2bobob2o$
10bo8b3obobob2ob2obo2b3o2b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b
3o2bo7bob2ob2obobob3o8bo$9b2o7b2o14bobo2b2o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b
3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o2b3o16b2o7b2o$36bo4b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b
3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o$38b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b
3o3b3o5bo$35b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3bo4bo$
40bo3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o4bo$37bo2b4o3b3o3b
3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o$35b2o7b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b
3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b4o3b2o$34b2ob7o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b
3o3b3o3b3o3b3o5b4o$11b3o5bo9bo4b2o2bo5b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o
3b3o3b3o3b3o3b6o3bo4bo9bo5b3o$11bo2bo3b3o7b3o3bo2b7o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b
3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o7bob3ob3o7b3o4bo2bo$6bo4bo6bob2o5bo2b2o2bobo
7b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b8obo2bo2b2o5bo2b2o3bo6bo
$5b3o3bo7bobo5bobo2b2o2b8o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o
12b2o2bo5bo2b2o3bo5b3o$5bob2o2bo7bo3bo2b2o2bo3bo9b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b
3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b8obo4bobo4b2o2b2o3bo5bob2o$6b3o2bo5bo6b2obobo
8b6o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o6bo2b4o3bob3o4bo4bo6b
3o$6b2o3bo3bo2b2obo5bobo14b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o
3b4o9b2obo3bo2bo6bo6b2o$11bo3bo2bo6b2o8b2o3b4o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o
3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o4bo9bo4bo6bo3bo$11bo11bo2bo2bo2bo6bo4b3o3b3o3b3o3b
3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b4o11bo3bo4bo5bo3bo$12bobo9bo13bob4o3b
3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o4b2o11bo13bobo$37b2o5b3o3b3o
3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b4o2bo$36bo3b4o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b
3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o5b3o$15b3o4b3o3b3o4b5o4b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b
3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b4o4bo4b3o3b3o4b3o$15bo2bo2bo2bo3bo2bo2bo5b4o3b
3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o4b5o4bo2bobo2bo4bo2bo$15bo2b
o6bobo3b3o2b5o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o3b3o6bo3bo2b
obo2bo3bo$10bo4b2obobo2b3obobob4o7bo5bo5bo5bo5bo5bo5bo5bo5bo5bo5bo5bo
7b3ob2o3b2obo3bo2b3o5bo$9b3o4b2o3b2ob2o3bo12bo5bo5bo5bo5bo5bo5bo5bo5bo
5bo5bo5bo7b2ob4o3bobobob4o2bo3b3o$8b2obo2b3o20b2o76bo4b3o7bob2obo2b2ob
2obo$8b3o3b2o110b2o11b5o$8b3o15b3o97bo11bo2b3o$9b2o15bobo96bobo14b2o!

[Sokwe]

I have confirmed with qfind that there are no period-7 2c/7 width-23 gutter-symmetric spaceships. The longest partial result is very similar to the one found by Andrew J. Wade here. Here are some other long partials:

Code: Select all

x = 143, y = 88, rule = B3/S23
6bo9bo27bo13bo24bo13bo24bo17bo$5b3o7b3o25b3o11b3o22b3o11b3o22b3o15b3o$
5b3o7b3o25b3o11b3o22b3o11b3o22b3o15b3o3$4b2ob2o5b2ob2o21b3o17b3o16b3o
17b3o18b2ob2o13b2ob2o$3bobobobo3bobobobo20b2o3b2obo5bob2o3b2o16b2o3b2o
bo5bob2o3b2o18b2obo15bob2o$42b2ob3obo3bob3ob2o20b2ob3obo3bob3ob2o24b3o
9b3o$5bobo2bobo2bobo24b4o11b4o20b4o11b4o27bo7bo$3b3o4bobo4b3o28b2o3b2o
32b2o3b2o30b2o11b2o$5bobob2ob2obobo24bo5bo5bo5bo20bo5bo5bo5bo24b4ob2ob
2ob4o$4bo2b2o5b2o2bo25b2ob2o5b2ob2o24b2ob2o5b2ob2o28bo3bobo3bo$6b4o3b
4o30b2o5b2o30b2o5b2o33bobobobo$3b2obob2o3b2obob2o24bo13bo24bo13bo31b2o
b2o$7bo7bo27b2o2b2o5b2o2b2o22b2o2b2o5b2o2b2o30b2ob2o$10bobo29bo2bobobo
3bobobo2bo20bo2bobobo3bobobo2bo24b3o9b3o$8bo5bo30bo11bo26bo11bo$5b5o3b
5o27bo2b2o3b2o2bo26bo2b2o3b2o2bo27bobo9bobo$5bob2o5b2obo29b2o5b2o30b2o
5b2o29bobo9bobo$7b2o5b2o27bob2o9b2obo22bob2o9b2obo26bo11bo$4b2ob2o5b2o
b2o24bo2b2o7b2o2bo22bo2b2o7b2o2bo25bo2bo7bo2bo$4b2ob2o5b2ob2o106bob2o
5b2obo$5b2ob2o3b2ob2o28b3o5b3o28b3o5b3o26bo4bo7bo4bo$4b3o9b3o26bobo7bo
bo26bobo7bobo25b6o7b6o$5bo11bo26bo13bo24bo13bo24bo4bo7bo4bo$5bobo7bobo
26b2ob2o5b2ob2o24b2ob2o5b2ob2o25b2obo9bob2o$6b2o7b2o27b2o11b2o24b2o11b
2o29bo7bo$5bo11bo105bo15bo$5bob2o5b2obo26bobobo5bobobo24bobobo5bobobo
25bo3bo7bo3bo$4bo4bo3bo4bo29b2o3b2o32b2o3b2o30bo2bo7bo2bo$3bo3bobo3bob
o3bo21b3o2b2ob2ob2ob2o2b3o18b3o2b2ob2ob2ob2o2b3o23bo2bo7bo2bo$4b2ob2o
5b2ob2o22b2o5bobobobo5b2o18b2o5bobobobo5b2o24bo11bo$2b2o2bo9bo2b2o19bo
6b2obobob2o6bo16bo6b2obobob2o6bo20bo3bo9bo3bo$5b2ob3ob3ob2o32bobo36bob
o31b2obo9bob2o$2b2o15b2o24b2o9b2o26b2o9b2o$bo3b2o9b2o3bo23b2o3bobo3b2o
26b2o3bobo3b2o28b2obo5bob2o$b4o13b4o22bo2bo2bobo2bo2bo24bo2bo2bobo2bo
2bo25b2o13b2o$b2ob3obo5bob3ob2o22b3o2bo3bo2b3o24b3o2bo3bo2b3o25b2o13b
2o$b3o3bo7bo3b3o23b2o9b2o26b2o9b2o27bo2bo7bo2bo$6b3o5b3o29bobo5bobo28b
obo5bobo29bo2bo5bo2bo$6bobo5bobo29b3o5b3o28b3o5b3o30b2ob2ob2ob2o$5b3o
7b3o28b2o2bobo2b2o28b2o2bobo2b2o31bo2bobo2bo$5b2o2b2ob2o2b2o29bo2bobo
2bo30b3o3b3o34bo3bo$6b2ob2ob2ob2o30bobo3bobo29bo9bo32b2o3b2o$4bo2bobo
3bobo2bo29b2o3b2o29b5o3b5o32bo3bo$3bobo2b2o3b2o2bobo28bo5bo29bo4bobo4b
o30bobo3bobo$3bo2b3o5b3o2bo26bo2bo3bo2bo27b5o3b5o30bo7bo$6b3o5b3o29bob
o5bobo68bo2b3ob3o2bo$2b2obob2o5b2obob2o63bo11bo28b3o2bobo2b3o$2bobo3bo
5bo3bobo23bo3bo5bo3bo24bo13bo26bo5bobo5bo$5bo11bo26bo2bobo3bobo2bo24b
3o9b3o27b2o9b2o$9b2ob2o29b2ob2obo3bob2ob2o26b2o5b2o30b2ob2o3b2ob2o$43b
3o2bo5bo2b3o22bo4bo5bo4bo$9bo3bo30bobo9bobo23bo2bobo5bobo2bo$5b3o7b3o
27b2o9b2o24bo3bo7bo3bo26b4o5b4o$9bo3bo67b5obo5bob5o24bo2bo7bo2bo$7bo7b
o27bob2o9b2obo20b2o2bo2bo5bo2bo2b2o22b2o4b2ob2o4b2o$4bo3b2o3b2o3bo23b
6o7b6o18bo5b3o5b3o5bo21bo2b2ob2ob2ob2o2bo$5bob2o5b2obo24bo5bo5bo5bo19b
o5b2o5b2o5bo20b2obob2obo3bob2obob2o$5bob2o5b2obo23bo2bo2b2o5b2o2bo2bo
20bob2obo5bob2obo25b2o11b2o$6b3o5b3o28bobobo3bobobo24bo3bobo3bobo3bo
22bo4bo9bo4bo$9bo3bo28bo2b3ob2ob2ob3o2bo22bo3bo5bo3bo24b2o3bo7bo3b2o$
5b2o9b2o25bo2bo2b2ob2o2bo2bo27bo5bo31bo11bo$7b3o3b3o33b2ob2o29b2o2b2o
3b2o2b2o28b2o7b2o$3b2o13b2o26b3o5b3o26b2obobo3bobob2o25b2o13b2o$b2o2bo
11bo2b2o23b2ob2o3b2ob2o24b2obo2bo3bo2bob2o24bob5o3b5obo$b2obo2b3o3b3o
2bob2o22bo3bo5bo3bo24bobo9bobo24bo3bo3bobo3bo3bo$o3bob2o2bobo2b2obo3bo
21b6o3b6o24bo13bo25b2o2bo2bobo2bo2b2o$b3o2bob2o3b2obo2b3o22bo3b2o3b2o
3bo25b2obo5bob2o28bo2bo5bo2bo$3b2ob2obo3bob2ob2o23b4o9b4o23b2o2bo5bo2b
2o26bo3bo5bo3bo$5b5o3b5o26bobobo5bobobo22bobo2b2o5b2o2bobo23bo5b2ob2o
5bo$10bobo28b2obo3bo5bo3bob2o62b2o3bo3bo3b2o$6bo3bobo3bo25bo2bo2bo5bo
2bo2bo20b2o4bo5bo4b2o24bobobo5bobobo$3b3obob2ob2obob3o23bobob2o5b2obob
o21b3o3b2o3b2o3b3o23bobo3bo3bo3bobo$2b2obo3bo3bo3bob2o25bo9bo29bob2ob
2obo27b2obo3bo3bo3bob2o$bo3b2obo5bob2o3bo19bo2bob2o7b2obo2bo22bo3b2ob
2o3bo24bo3bo11bo3bo$bo5b3o3b3o5bo24bobo5bobo27bo3b2ob2o3bo24bo3bob2o5b
2obo3bo$3b5ob2ob2ob5o20bob2obo11bob2obo18bob2o11b2obo21bo4b3o5b3o4bo$
2b2o3bo7bo3b2o23bo2bo7bo2bo21b2o2bo2bobobobo2bo2b2o20bo3bobo7bobo3bo$
2bo5b2o3b2o5bo19bo3b4o7b4o3bo17b3obo11bob3o21bob3o9b3obo$b6ob2o3b2ob6o
18bo6bo7bo6bo17bo2b2o2b2o3b2o2b2o2bo21b2o4bo5bo4b2o$41bo2bo2b2o5b2o2bo
2bo22bob3o3b3obo28bo2bo5bo2bo$40b3o3b2obo3bob2o3b3o21bo11bo25bo17bo$
40bob3o2bo7bo2b3obo20b2o3bo3bo3b2o24bo2b2ob3ob3ob2o2bo$49b2ob2o25b3obo
bob2o3b2obobob3o20b2o6bobo6b2o$79bobo3bo9bo3bobo22b6o3b6o$80b4o5bobo5b
4o23bobob2o3b2obobo$81bobobo2b2ob2o2bobobo!

I think there's a decent chance that a width-25 gutter ship exists, but it would probably need to be found with LSSS, as qfind can't handle logical-width-12 searches due to excessive memory usage.

[wwei47]

Here are some other long partials:

1. The last partial has a single-generation interaction, and the arms are near the edge of the box. Try widening the search there, but making the gutter 3 cells wide. The width should be equivalent.
2. Are you sure you want to use LSSS? I'm pretty sure it's still bugged. ikpx2 seems like it might be useful, but I don't know if it can do that kind of floating row stuff where both halves float away from each other. If not, then JLS might actually be useful here, because those arms are only 9 cells wide, and the loafer (c/7, w10a), which is wider and slower, was found with WLS.

[Sokwe]

Are you sure you want to use LSSS? I'm pretty sure it's still bugged.

It may be buggy, and it may miss things, but it can also finds things that nothing else can. From what I've seen, it's the fastest program for wide, high-speed ships.

ikpx2 seems like it might be useful, but I don't know if it can do that kind of floating row stuff where both halves float away from each other. If not, then JLS might actually be useful here, because those arms are only 9 cells wide, and the loafer (c/7, w10a), which is wider and slower, was found with WLS.

You would need a lot of luck to find anything with JLS or WLS, but it's possible. However, If I were trying an asymmetric extension of the pieces below the wings, I would simply use qfind (I haven't tried this). I do have an idea for using ikpx2: If I can input all of my width-23 gutter partials, then it might be able to find a non-gutter solution. However, I have millions of partials, and I would rather input the rows directly, rather than having ikpx parse a bunch of RLEs. Is this reasonably possible?

[wwei47]

You would need a lot of luck to find anything with JLS or WLS, but it's possible. However, If I were trying an asymmetric extension of the pieces below the wings, I would simply use qfind (I haven't tried this). I do have an idea for using ikpx2: If I can input all of my width-23 gutter partials, then it might be able to find a non-gutter solution. However, I have millions of partials, and I would rather input the rows directly, rather than having ikpx parse a bunch of RLEs. Is this reasonably possible?

1. I'm saying that someone succeeded at a harder search in WLS.
2. I don't think qfind knows how to keep the gutter 3 cells wide, instead of the usual 1 cell. The entire point of me recommending JLS for this search was to force the 3-cell gutter.
3. How did you find millions of partials?
4. I don't know. Ask calcyman, I guess.

[Sokwe]

I'm saying that someone succeeded at a harder search in WLS.

And that required a lot of luck. JLS and WLS can definitely find ships with shapes that couldn't be searched for with qfind, LSSS, or ikpx2, so there's a possibility that this could allow it to find something where those others fail.

I don't think qfind knows how to keep the gutter 3 cells wide, instead of the usual 1 cell

Just do an asymmetric extension of one side that's properly aligned so that its inner edge is 1 column away from the gutter.

How did you find millions of partials?

Every time the search adds a new row, you get a new partial. Even after eliminating rows that can't be extended more than a depth of 28, this leaves me with millions of partial results of varying lengths. Most of these partials are short (depth less than 140, so length less than 20). I could possibly leave out the partials that have width less than 23, as they are less likely to lead to a ship.

[shuich01]

Nothing found for 3c/7 w16e,w17e and w18e via LSSS(seedcolumn=05)
longest partials:

Code: Select all

x = 154, y = 73, rule = B3/S23
10bo10bo48bo10bo48bo10bo$9bobo8bobo46bobo8bobo46bobo8bobo$8b2ob2o6b2ob
2o44b2ob2o6b2ob2o44b2ob2o6b2ob2o$8bo14bo44bo14bo44bo14bo$8b3o2bo4bo2b
3o44b3o2bo4bo2b3o44b3o2bo4bo2b3o$6bo7bo2bo7bo40bo7bo2bo7bo40bo7bo2bo7b
o$7b2o2b2ob4ob2o2b2o42b2o2b2ob4ob2o2b2o42b2o2b2ob4ob2o2b2o$7bobo4bo2bo
4bobo42bobo4bo2bo4bobo42bobo4bo2bo4bobo$4b3ob3o2bo4bo2b3ob3o36b3ob3o2b
o4bo2b3ob3o36b3ob3o2bo4bo2b3ob3o$4b2ob3obobo4bobob3ob2o36b2ob3obobo4bo
bob3ob2o36b2ob3obobo4bobob3ob2o$5b3o2bo2bo4bo2bo2b3o38b3o2bo2bo4bo2bo
2b3o38b3o2bo2bo4bo2bo2b3o$6bob3o3bo2bo3b3obo40bob3o3bo2bo3b3obo40bob3o
3bo2bo3b3obo$8b3o2bo4bo2b3o45b2o2bo4bo2b2o45b3o2bo4bo2b3o$8b3o4b2o4b3o
51b2o51b3o4b2o4b3o$15b2o51bob2o3b2o3b2obo51b2o$8bo2bo8bo2bo39bo3b4o10b
4o3bo38bo2bo10bo2bo$8bo2bo8bo2bo38bobo2bob3o8b3obo2bobo41bo8bo$8b2obo
8bob2o37bo3bob2o2b2o6b2o2b2obo3bo29b3o3bob4o8b4obo3b3o$6b2o3bobo4bobo
3b2o35bo5b2o14b2o5bo28bo2bo3bo3b2o8b2o3bo3bo2bo$6bo2bo2b2o4b2o2bo2bo
35bo9bo8bo9bo28b2ob2o2b2o16b2o2b2ob2o$5bo2bo14bo2bo34bobobobo6bo2bo6bo
bobobo34b3o4bo6bo4b3o$6b2o3b3o4b3o3b2o40bo4b2obo2bob2o4bo39b4ob2o8b2ob
4o$5b3obo2b2o4b2o2bob3o45b2o4b2o45b2obo2bo8bo2bob2o$5bob2o14b2obo37b2o
2b2o12b2o2b2o42bobo6bobo$3b2o3bob5o2b5obo3b2o35bob4o12b4obo34bob3o6bo
4bo6b3obo$3b2o3b3o3bo2bo3b3o3b2o37b2o4b2o4b2o4b2o35b3o2bo4bobo4bobo4bo
2b3o$3b2ob4o2b3o2b3o2b4ob2o35b3ob2o12b2ob3o32b3ob2o5bobo4bobo5b2ob3o$
6bobob2o8b2obobo36b3o5bo2bo4bo2bo5b3o29b3ob3o6bo6bo6b3ob3o$10bo10bo40b
2obo6bo6bo6bob2o$8bo5b4o5bo37bob3o3b2o10b2o3b3obo31b3o4bo12bo4b3o$6b2o
5b6o5b2o35b5o3bo12bo3b5o32b3o2b3o10b3o2b3o$2b2obo8bo2bo8bob2o31b3obo3b
obo8bobo3bob3o31bo5bob2o8b2obo5bo$3bo2bo2bobobo4bobobo2bo2bo33bobobob
3obo6bob3obobobo29bo2bobo3bo14bo3bobo2bo$4b4o3b2ob4ob2o3b4o39bobo3bo4b
o3bobo35bobo2bo2bo14bo2bo2bobo$4b2o4b12o4b2o31bob4o5bo10bo5b4obo30bo6b
2o8b2o6bo$5bob4o3b4o3b4obo33b2ob2o8bo4bo8b2ob2o29b2ob2o4b2o8b2o4b2ob2o
$3b2obo4bo8bo4bob2o32b4o6b3o4b3o6b4o30bo7bo12bo7bo$3b2obo2bobo8bobo2bo
b2o33bo2b5o12b5o2bo35bobo16bobo$3b3o3bobo8bobo3b3o34b3o2b2o3bo4bo3b2o
2b3o34bob2o2bo12bo2b2obo$3bo3b2o14b2o3bo33bo2bobo2bo2b6o2bo2bobo2bo33b
o3bo2bo10bo2bo3bo$bo2bob3o14b3obo2bo31bo2bobo2bo3b4o3bo2bobo2bo33bobob
o16bobobo$b3o7b3ob2ob3o7b3o34bo3bo5b2o5bo3bo36b3o4bo10bo4b3o$3bo2b2o3b
o2bo2bo2bo3b2o2bo34bobo9b2o9bobo37bobo6b2o6bobo$3b3o3bobo3b2o3bobo3b3o
33b2o10bo2bo10b2o34bo10b2o10bo$o2b3o4bob2o4b2obo4b3o2bo31b3ob2o2b2obo
2bob2o2b2ob3o35bo4bob2obo2bob2obo4bo$3bo4b2ob10ob2o4bo34b2o2b2o14b2o2b
2o34bobo4bobo6bobo4bobo$2bo2bo2b2ob2o6b2ob2o2bo2bo33b2obo3bo10bo3bob2o
32bobo4bobo4b2o4bobo4bobo$2bob2o2bo14bo2b2obo33bo7b2o6b2o7bo32b2o4bo2b
12o2bo4b2o$3o2bo4bobo6bobo4bo2b3o28b2obobo6b3o2b3o6bobob2o29b2o3bo2bo
2bo6bo2bo2bo3b2o$2o2b2o4bobo6bobo4b2o2b2o28bo4b8ob4ob8o4bo32b2o4bobo6b
obo4b2o$2bob2ob2obo4b2o4bob2ob2obo30bo5bobo4bo4bo4bobo5bo29b2o3bo2bo2b
o6bo2bo2bo3b2o$5bo2bo3b2ob2ob2o3bo2bo33bo3bo5b2o2bo2bo2b2o5bo3bo28b4o
5bo4b4o4bo5b4o$65b2o4bo8bo4b2o32b5o6b2o2b4o2b2o6b5o$121b3o7bobob2obobo
7b3o$121bo28bo$122bo12b2o12bo$119b2ob2o3bob3o3b2o3b3obo3b2ob2o$119b2o
3bo2bobob2obo2bob2obobo2bo3b2o$120bo3b2obo3bob2o2b2obo3bob2o3bo$121b2o
2bob2ob3obo2bob3ob2obo2b2o$121b2o2bob2o6b2o6b2obo2b2o$122bo2bo2b2o2bo
6bo2b2o2bo2bo$122bo6bo2b8o2bo6bo$123bo2bo2bo3b6o3bo2bo2bo$124b3o18b3o$
124b3o4bo2bo2bo2bo4b3o$123bobo4bobobo2bobobo4bobo$121bo3b2o3bob2o4b2ob
o3b2o3bo$121b2o3bo3b2o8b2o3bo3b2o$121b3ob3o3bobo4bobo3b3ob3o$126bob3o
2b2o2b2o2b3obo$118b3ob2o4bo14bo4b2ob3o$118b3obo26bob3o!

[shuich01]

now report some results I've completed via qfind:
4c/12 w7 o:no ships
4c/12 w6 e:no p12 ships(and the turtle is the only found for the search)
6c/12 w5 o:no ships
6c/12 w6 o:2 ships(the lightweight Shick engine and lightweight Shick engine on two LWSSes)
6c/12 w7 e:no p12 ships
p.s. the 4c/12 w8 o is still ongoing because it runs very slowly. if the search ends with no p12 results, and the following ship will be the narrowest odd symmetric 4c/12 ship.

Code: Select all

x = 17, y = 35, rule = B3/S23
8bo$7bobo$6bo3bo$7b3o2$5b2o3b2o$2b2o3bobo3b2o$2b2o3bobo3b2o$2o5bobo5b
2o$4b2obobob2o$o6bobo6bo$3b2o2bobo2b2o$bo2bobo3bobo2bo$b2o11b2o$b2o11b
2o$4bo7bo$4b3o3b3o$6bo3bo$3b2obo3bob2o$5b2o3b2o$5bobobobo2$5bo2bo2bo$
6b2ob2o$5b2o3b2o$2b2obo5bob2o$2b2o3b3o3b2o$2bob9obo$6b2ob2o$6bo3bo$4bo
2bobo2bo$5bobobobo$7bobo2$6b2ob2o!

Edit: 6c/12 w8 e completed just now and no p12 ships found.

[wwei47]

6c/12 w6 o:2 ships(the lightweight Shick engine and lightweight Shick engine on two LWSSes)

Lightweight Schick engine on two LWSSes? Show me please.

[shuich01]

6c/12 w6 o:2 ships(the lightweight Shick engine and lightweight Shick engine on two LWSSes)

Lightweight Schick engine on two LWSSes? Show me please.

sure.

Code: Select all

x = 9, y = 28, rule = B3/S23
bo5bo$3o3b3o$ob2ob2obo$b3ob3o$b2o3b2o2$4bo$3bobo$2bo3bo$3bobo$4bo$4bo$
3bobo$3bobo$4bo3$b2o3b2o4$4bo$4bo$bo5bo$3o3b3o$ob2ob2obo$b3ob3o$b2o3b
2o!

[Sokwe]

now report some results I've completed via qfind:

Which version of qfind are you using?

[HartmutHolzwart]

Here is another vesion of an incomplete 2c/6 against the grain grey ship, a triangle with only the back corner completed. But that's at least something.

Code: Select all

x = 216, y = 254, rule = B3/S23
12$188b3o$187bo$186b2o4bo$188b2ob3o$180b3o5bo5bob3o$179bo12bo6bo$178b
2o4bob3o4b2ob2obo$180b2ob3obo4b2ob3obo$172b3o5bo5b2o6bo3bo$171bo12bo2b
o2bo3bo3b2o$170b2o4bob3o4b3obobo$172b2ob3obo6bo2bob2o2b2o$164b3o5bo5b
2o7b2ob3o$163bo12bo2bo2bo13bo$162b2o4bob3o4b3obobo6bo5bo$164b2ob3obo6b
o2bob2o4b2o4bobo$156b3o5bo5b2o7b2ob3o4b3o3bo$155bo12bo2bo2bo14bo2bo$
154b2o4bob3o4b3obobo6bo9b2o$156b2ob3obo6bo2bob2o4b2o9b2o$148b3o5bo5b2o
7b2ob3o4b3o9bobo$147bo12bo2bo2bo14bo2bo10b2o$146b2o4bob3o4b3obobo6bo9b
2o8bo2bo$148b2ob3obo6bo2bob2o4b2o9b2o11bo$140b3o5bo5b2o7b2ob3o4b3o9bob
o11bo$139bo12bo2bo2bo14bo2bo10b2o10bo$138b2o4bob3o4b3obobo6bo9b2o8bo2b
o4b2obo$140b2ob3obo6bo2bob2o4b2o9b2o11bo4b2o$132b3o5bo5b2o7b2ob3o4b3o
9bobo11bo2bobo$131bo12bo2bo2bo14bo2bo10b2o10bo5b2o$130b2o4bob3o4b3obob
o6bo9b2o8bo2bo4b2obo5b3o$132b2ob3obo6bo2bob2o4b2o9b2o11bo4b2o5b2o2bo$
124b3o5bo5b2o7b2ob3o4b3o9bobo11bo2bobo5b2o$123bo12bo2bo2bo14bo2bo10b2o
10bo5b2o3bobo$122b2o4bob3o4b3obobo6bo9b2o8bo2bo4b2obo5b3o24b2o$124b2ob
3obo6bo2bob2o4b2o9b2o11bo4b2o5b2o2bo5b2o7b3o6bo$116b3o5bo5b2o7b2ob3o4b
3o9bobo11bo2bobo5b2o8bo6bo4b3o2b3o$115bo12bo2bo2bo14bo2bo10b2o10bo5b2o
3bobo7bo4b3o5bob3o$114b2o4bob3o4b3obobo6bo9b2o8bo2bo4b2obo5b3o13b2ob2o
b2o2bob2o4bo$116b2ob3obo6bo2bob2o4b2o9b2o11bo4b2o5b2o2bo5b2o4b2obo3bob
obo6b2o$108b3o5bo5b2o7b2ob3o4b3o9bobo11bo2bobo5b2o8bo3bo6bo$107bo12bo
2bo2bo14bo2bo10b2o10bo5b2o3bobo7bo$106b2o4bob3o4b3obobo6bo9b2o8bo2bo4b
2obo5b3o13b2ob7o$108b2ob3obo6bo2bob2o4b2o9b2o11bo4b2o5b2o2bo5b2o4b2obo
4b2ob2o$100b3o5bo5b2o7b2ob3o4b3o9bobo11bo2bobo5b2o8bo3bo6bo6b2o$99bo
12bo2bo2bo14bo2bo10b2o10bo5b2o3bobo7bo17bo$98b2o4bob3o4b3obobo6bo9b2o
8bo2bo4b2obo5b3o13b2ob7o10bo$100b2ob3obo6bo2bob2o4b2o9b2o11bo4b2o5b2o
2bo5b2o4b2obo4b2ob2o8bo$92b3o5bo5b2o7b2ob3o4b3o9bobo11bo2bobo5b2o8bo3b
o6bo6b2o$91bo12bo2bo2bo14bo2bo10b2o10bo5b2o3bobo7bo17bo7b2o$90b2o4bob
3o4b3obobo6bo9b2o8bo2bo4b2obo5b3o13b2ob7o10bo5bo2bo$92b2ob3obo6bo2bob
2o4b2o9b2o11bo4b2o5b2o2bo5b2o4b2obo4b2ob2o8bo6bo$84b3o5bo5b2o7b2ob3o4b
3o9bobo11bo2bobo5b2o8bo3bo6bo6b2o11bo$83bo12bo2bo2bo14bo2bo10b2o10bo5b
2o3bobo7bo17bo7b2o3bo$82b2o4bob3o4b3obobo6bo9b2o8bo2bo4b2obo5b3o13b2ob
7o10bo5bo2bo4bob2o$84b2ob3obo6bo2bob2o4b2o9b2o11bo4b2o5b2o2bo5b2o4b2ob
o4b2ob2o8bo6bo9b2o$76b3o5bo5b2o7b2ob3o4b3o9bobo11bo2bobo5b2o8bo3bo6bo
6b2o11bo10bobo$75bo12bo2bo2bo14bo2bo10b2o10bo5b2o3bobo7bo17bo7b2o3bo8b
2o$74b2o4bob3o4b3obobo6bo9b2o8bo2bo4b2obo5b3o13b2ob7o10bo5bo2bo4bob2o
4b3o$76b2ob3obo6bo2bob2o4b2o9b2o11bo4b2o5b2o2bo5b2o4b2obo4b2ob2o8bo6bo
9b2o4bo2b2o$68b3o5bo5b2o7b2ob3o4b3o9bobo11bo2bobo5b2o8bo3bo6bo6b2o11bo
10bobo6b2o$67bo12bo2bo2bo14bo2bo10b2o10bo5b2o3bobo7bo17bo7b2o3bo8b2o9b
2o$66b2o4bob3o4b3obobo6bo9b2o8bo2bo4b2obo5b3o13b2ob7o10bo5bo2bo4bob2o
4b3o8bo$68b2ob3obo6bo2bob2o4b2o9b2o11bo4b2o5b2o2bo5b2o4b2obo4b2ob2o8bo
6bo9b2o4bo2b2o4b2obo$60b3o5bo5b2o7b2ob3o4b3o9bobo11bo2bobo5b2o8bo3bo6b
o6b2o11bo10bobo6b2o4bobobo$59bo12bo2bo2bo14bo2bo10b2o10bo5b2o3bobo7bo
17bo7b2o3bo8b2o9b2o3b2obobo$58b2o4bob3o4b3obobo6bo9b2o8bo2bo4b2obo5b3o
13b2ob7o10bo5bo2bo4bob2o4b3o8bo2bobobobo$60b2ob3obo6bo2bob2o4b2o9b2o
11bo4b2o5b2o2bo5b2o4b2obo4b2ob2o8bo6bo9b2o4bo2b2o4b2obobobo2b4o$52b3o
5bo5b2o7b2ob3o4b3o9bobo11bo2bobo5b2o8bo3bo6bo6b2o11bo10bobo6b2o4bobobo
bobo5bo$51bo12bo2bo2bo14bo2bo10b2o10bo5b2o3bobo7bo17bo7b2o3bo8b2o9b2o
3b2obobo2b5o2b2o$50b2o4bob3o4b3obobo6bo9b2o8bo2bo4b2obo5b3o13b2ob7o10b
o5bo2bo4bob2o4b3o8bo2bobobobo5bobobobo$52b2ob3obo6bo2bob2o4b2o9b2o11bo
4b2o5b2o2bo5b2o4b2obo4b2ob2o8bo6bo9b2o4bo2b2o4b2obobobo2b8obo2bo$44b3o
5bo5b2o7b2ob3o4b3o9bobo11bo2bobo5b2o8bo3bo6bo6b2o11bo10bobo6b2o4bobobo
bobo9bobo4b2o$43bo12bo2bo2bo14bo2bo10b2o10bo5b2o3bobo7bo17bo7b2o3bo8b
2o9b2o3b2obobo2b9o2bo2bobo3b2ob2o$42b2o4bob3o4b3obobo6bo9b2o8bo2bo4b2o
bo5b3o13b2ob7o10bo5bo2bo4bob2o4b3o8bo2bobobobo11bobo4b4o3b2o$44b2ob3ob
o6bo2bob2o4b2o9b2o11bo4b2o5b2o2bo5b2o4b2obo4b2ob2o8bo6bo9b2o4bo2b2o4b
2obobobo2b14ob2o3b2o4bo2bo$36b3o5bo5b2o7b2ob3o4b3o9bobo11bo2bobo5b2o8b
o3bo6bo6b2o11bo10bobo6b2o4bobobobobo13bobobobo3b2o$35bo12bo2bo2bo14bo
2bo10b2o10bo5b2o3bobo7bo17bo7b2o3bo8b2o9b2o3b2obobo2b16obo2bo$34b2o4bo
b3o4b3obobo6bo9b2o8bo2bo4b2obo5b3o13b2ob7o10bo5bo2bo4bob2o4b3o8bo2bobo
bobo17bobo4b2o$36b2ob3obo6bo2bob2o4b2o9b2o11bo4b2o5b2o2bo5b2o4b2obo4b
2ob2o8bo6bo9b2o4bo2b2o4b2obobobo2b17o2bo2bobo3b2ob2o$10bo10b2o5b3o5bo
5b2o7b2ob3o4b3o9bobo11bo2bobo5b2o8bo3bo6bo6b2o11bo10bobo6b2o4bobobobob
o19bobo4b4o3b2o$6b2obobo4bob2ob2o4bo12bo2bo2bo14bo2bo10b2o10bo5b2o3bob
o7bo17bo7b2o3bo8b2o9b2o3b2obobo2b22ob2o3b2o4bo2bo$6b2o4bo2b2ob2o3bo2b
2o4bob3o4b3obobo6bo9b2o8bo2bo4b2obo5b3o13b2ob7o10bo5bo2bo4bob2o4b3o8bo
2bobobobo21bobobobo3b2o$5bo2bo5bo3b2o8b2ob3obo6bo2bob2o4b2o9b2o11bo4b
2o5b2o2bo5b2o4b2obo4b2ob2o8bo6bo9b2o4bo2b2o4b2obobobo2b2ob21obo2bo$11b
2obobo11bo5b2o7b2ob3o4b3o9bobo11bo2bobo5b2o8bo3bo6bo6b2o11bo10bobo6b2o
4bobobobobo25bobo4b2o$10bo3bobo15bo2bo2bo14bo2bo10b2o10bo5b2o3bobo7bo
17bo7b2o3bo8b2o9b2o3b2obobo2b25o2bo2bobo3b2ob2o$9b2o2bo4bo5bob3o2b2ob
2obobo6bo9b2o8bo2bo4b2obo5b3o13b2ob7o10bo5bo2bo4bob2o4b3o8bo2bobobobo
27bobo4b4o3b2o$7b2obob2o2bo6b3obo6bo2bob2o4b2o9b2o11bo4b2o5b2o2bo5b2o
4b2obo4b2ob2o8bo6bo9b2o4bo2b2o4b2obobobo2b30ob2o3b2o4bo2bo$5b2obo3bobo
4b2o5b2o5bob2ob3o4b3o9bobo11bo2bobo5b2o8bo3bo6bo6b2o11bo10bobo6b2o4bob
obobobo29bobobobo3b2o$4bo3bo3bobo2b2obo3bo2bo2b2o13bo2bo10b2o10bo5b2o
3bobo7bo17bo7b2o3bo8b2o9b2o3b2obobo2b32obo2bo$5bobo3bo6bobo4b3obobo6bo
9b2o8bo2bo4b2obo5b3o13b2ob7o10bo5bo2bo4bob2o4b3o8bo2bobobobo33bobo4b2o
$11bob2o6bo4bo2bob2o4b2o9b2o11bo4b2o5b2o2bo5b2o4b2obo4b2ob2o8bo6bo9b2o
4bo2b2o4b2obobobo2b33o2bo2bobo3b2ob2o$27b2ob3o4b3o9bobo11bo2bobo5b2o8b
o3bo6bo6b2o11bo10bobo6b2o4bobobobobo35bobo4b4o3b2o$37bo2bo10b2o10bo5b
2o3bobo7bo17bo7b2o3bo8b2o9b2o3b2obobo2b38ob2o3b2o4bo2bo$30bo9b2o8bo2bo
4b2obo5b3o13b2ob7o10bo5bo2bo4bob2o4b3o8bo2bobobobo37bobobobo3b2o$29b2o
9b2o11bo4b2o5b2o2bo5b2o4b2obo4b2ob2o8bo6bo9b2o4bo2b2o4b2obobobob41obo
2bo$29b3o9bobo11bo2bobo5b2o8bo3bo6bo6b2o11bo10bobo6b2o4bobobobobo41bob
o4b2o$29bo2bo10b2o10bo5b2o3bobo7bo17bo7b2o3bo8b2o9b2o3b2obobo2b41o2bo
2bobo3b2ob2o$32b2o8bo2bo4b2obo5b3o13b2ob7o10bo5bo2bo4bob2o4b3o8bo2bobo
bobo43bobo4b4o3b2o$32b2o11bo4b2o5b2o2bo5b2o4b2obo4b2ob2o8bo6bo9b2o4bo
2b2o4b2obobobo2b46ob2o3b2o4bo2bo$33bobo11bo2bobo5b2o8bo3bo6bo6b2o11bo
10bobo6b2o4bobobobobo45bobobobo3b2o$35b2o10bo5b2o3bobo7bo17bo7b2o3bo8b
2o9b2o3b2obobo2b48obo2bo$34bo2bo4b2obo5b3o13b2ob7o10bo5bo2bo4bob2o4b3o
8bo2bobobobo49bobo4b2o$37bo4b2o5b2o2bo5b2o4b2obo4b2ob2o8bo6bo9b2o4bo2b
2o4b2obobobo2b49o2bo2bobo3b2ob2o$39bo2bobo5b2o8bo3bo6bo6b2o11bo10bobo
6b2o4bobobobobo51bobo4b4o3b2o$39bo5b2o3bobo7bo17bo7b2o3bo8b2o9b2o3b2ob
obo2b54ob2o3b2o4bo2bo$34b2obo5b3o13b2ob7o10bo5bo2bo4bob2o4b3o8bo2bobob
obo53bobobobo3b2o$34b2o5b2o2bo5b2o4b2obo4b2ob2o8bo6bo9b2o4bo2b2o4b2obo
bobo2b56obo2bo$34bobo5b2o8bo3bo6bo6b2o11bo10bobo6b2o4bobobobobo57bobo
4b2o$37b2o3bobo7bo17bo7b2o3bo8b2o9b2o3b2obobo2b57o2bo2bobo3b2ob2o$35b
3o13b2ob7o10bo5bo2bo4bob2o4b3o8bo2bobobobo59bobo4b4o3b2o$33b2o2bo5b2o
4b2obo4b2ob2o8bo6bo9b2o4bo2b2o4b2obobobo2b62ob2o3b2o4bo2bo$34b2o8bo3bo
6bo6b2o11bo10bobo6b2o4bobobobobo61bobobobo3b2o$34bobo7bo17bo7b2o3bo8b
2o9b2o3b2obobo2b64obo2bo$43b2ob7o10bo5bo2bo4bob2o4b3o8bo2bobobobo65bob
o4b2o$35b2o4b2obo4b2ob2o8bo6bo9b2o4bo2b2o4b2obobobo2b65o2bo2bobo3b2ob
2o$36bo3bo6bo6b2o11bo10bobo6b2o4bobobobobo67bobo4b4o3b2o$36bo17bo7b2o
3bo8b2o9b2o3b2obobo2b70ob2o3b2o4bo2bo$32b2ob2ob7o10bo5bo2bo4bob2o4b3o
8bo2bobobobo69bobobobo3b2o$30bobobobo4b2ob2o8bo6bo9b2o4bo2b2o4b2obobob
o2b72obo2bo$24b3o2b2o8bo6b2o11bo10bobo6b2o4bobobobobo73bobo4b2o$23bobo
b3ob2o13bo7b2o3bo8b2o9b2o3b2obobo2b73o2bo2bobo3b2ob2o$24bo4bob6o10bo5b
o2bo4bob2o4b3o8bo2bobobobo75bobo4b4o3b2o$27b2o4b2ob2o8bo6bo9b2o4bo2b2o
4b2obobobo2b78ob2o3b2o4bo2bo$38b2o11bo10bobo6b2o4bobobobobo77bobobobo
3b2o$38bo7b2o3bo8b2o9b2o3b2obobo2b80obo2bo$39bo5bo2bo4bob2o4b3o8bo2bob
obobo81bobo4b2o$38bo6bo9b2o4bo2b2o4b2obobobo2b81o2bo2bobo3b2ob2o$43bo
10bobo6b2o4bobobobobo83bobo4b4o3b2o$38b2o3bo8b2o9b2o3b2obobo2b86ob2o3b
2o4bo2bo$37bo2bo4bob2o4b3o8bo2bobobobo85bobobobo3b2o$37bo9b2o4bo2b2o4b
2obobobo2b88obo2bo$35bo10bobo6b2o4bobobobobo89bobo4b2o$35bo8b2o9b2o3b
2obobo2b89o2bo2bobo3b2ob2o$37bob2o4b3o8bo2bobobobo91bobo4b4o3b2o$39b2o
4bo2b2o4b2obobobo2b94ob2o3b2o4bo2bo$38bobo6b2o4bobobobobo93bobobobo3b
2o$36b2o9b2o3b2obobo2b96obo2bo$37b3o8bo2bobobobo97bobo4b2o$37bo2b2o4b
2obobobo2b97o2bo2bobo3b2ob2o$39b2o4bobobobobo99bobo4b4o3b2o$39b2o3b2ob
obo2b102ob2o3b2o4bo2bo$40bo2bobobobo101bobobobo3b2o$38b2obobobo2b104ob
o2bo$37bobobobobo105bobo4b2o$36b2obobo2b105o2bo2bobo3b2ob2o$35bobobobo
107bobo4b4o3b2o$35bobo2b110ob2o3b2o4bo2bo$35bobo109bobobobo3b2o$36b
112obo2bo$147bobo4b2o$36b109o2bo2bobo3b2ob2o$35bo109bobo4b4o3b2o$35b
111ob2o3b2o4bo2bo$35bobo105bobobobo3b2o$32bo2bob107obo2bo$29b2o4bobo
105bobo4b2o$24b2ob2o3bobo2bo2b101o2bo2bobo3b2ob2o$24b2o3b4o4bobo101bob
o4b4o3b2o$23bo2bo4b2o3b2ob103ob2o3b2o4bo2bo$30b2o3bobobobo97bobobobo3b
2o$36bo2bob99obo2bo$33b2o4bobo97bobo4b2o$28b2ob2o3bobo2bo2b93o2bo2bobo
3b2ob2o$28b2o3b4o4bobo93bobo4b4o3b2o$27bo2bo4b2o3b2ob95ob2o3b2o4bo2bo$
34b2o3bobobobo89bobobobo3b2o$40bo2bob91obo2bo$37b2o4bobo89bobo4b2o$32b
2ob2o3bobo2bo2b85o2bo2bobo3b2ob2o$32b2o3b4o4bobo85bobo4b4o3b2o$31bo2bo
4b2o3b2ob87ob2o3b2o4bo2bo$38b2o3bobobobo81bobobobo3b2o$44bo2bob83obo2b
o$41b2o4bobo81bobo4b2o$36b2ob2o3bobo2bo2b77o2bo2bobo3b2ob2o$36b2o3b4o
4bobo77bobo4b4o3b2o$35bo2bo4b2o3b2ob79ob2o3b2o4bo2bo$42b2o3bobobobo73b
obobobo3b2o$48bo2bob75obo2bo$45b2o4bobo73bobo4b2o$40b2ob2o3bobo2bo2b
69o2bo2bobo3b2ob2o$40b2o3b4o4bobo69bobo4b4o3b2o$39bo2bo4b2o3b2ob71ob2o
3b2o4bo2bo$46b2o3bobobobo65bobobobo3b2o$52bo2bob67obo2bo$49b2o4bobo65b
obo4b2o$44b2ob2o3bobo2bo2b61o2bo2bobo3b2ob2o$44b2o3b4o4bobo61bobo4b4o
3b2o$43bo2bo4b2o3b2ob63ob2o3b2o4bo2bo$50b2o3bobobobo57bobobobo3b2o$56b
o2bob59obo2bo$53b2o4bobo57bobo4b2o$48b2ob2o3bobo2bo2b53o2bo2bobo3b2ob
2o$48b2o3b4o4bobo53bobo4b4o3b2o$47bo2bo4b2o3b2ob55ob2o3b2o4bo2bo$54b2o
3bobobobo49bobobobo3b2o$60bo2bob51obo2bo$57b2o4bobo49bobo4b2o$52b2ob2o
3bobo2bo2b45o2bo2bobo3b2ob2o$52b2o3b4o4bobo45bobo4b4o3b2o$51bo2bo4b2o
3b2ob47ob2o3b2o4bo2bo$58b2o3bobobobo41bobobobo3b2o$64bo2bob43obo2bo$
61b2o4bobo41bobo4b2o$56b2ob2o3bobo2bo2b37o2bo2bobo3b2ob2o$56b2o3b4o4bo
bo37bobo4b4o3b2o$55bo2bo4b2o3b2ob39ob2o3b2o4bo2bo$62b2o3bobobobo33bobo
bobo3b2o$68bo2bob35obo2bo$65b2o4bobo33bobo4b2o$60b2ob2o3bobo2bo2b29o2b
o2bobo3b2ob2o$60b2o3b4o4bobo29bobo4b4o3b2o$59bo2bo4b2o3b2ob31ob2o3b2o
4bo2bo$66b2o3bobobobo25bobobobo3b2o$72bo2bob27obo2bo$69b2o4bobo25bobo
4b2o$64b2ob2o3bobo2bo2b21o2bo2bobo3b2ob2o$64b2o3b4o4bobo21bobo4b4o3b2o
$63bo2bo4b2o3b2ob23ob2o3b2o4bo2bo$70b2o3bobobobo17bobobobo3b2o$76bo2bo
b19obo2bo$73b2o4bobo17bobo4b2o$68b2ob2o3bobo2bo2b13o2bo2bobo3b2ob2o$
68b2o3b4o4bobo13bobo4b4o3b2o$67bo2bo4b2o3b2ob15ob2o3b2o4bo2bo$74b2o3bo
bobobo9bobobobo3b2o$80bo2bob4o3b4obo2bo$77b2o4bobo9bobo4b2o$72b2ob2o3b
obo5bobobo5bobo3b2ob2o$72b2o3b4o5bo7bo5b4o3b2o$71bo2bo4b2o19b2o4bo2bo$
78b2o21b2o2$78b2o21b2o$70b2o7b2o19b2o7b2o$67b2obob2o5b2o19b2o5b2obob2o
$64b4o2bo4b2ob3o19b3ob2o4bo2b4o$63bo4bo6b2obo23bob2o6bo4bo$64b2o7bo2bo
bo23bobo2bo7b2o!

Edit (copy&paste error in the first version):

Code: Select all

x = 222, y = 290, rule = B3/S23
21$185b3o$184bo$183b2o4bo$185b2ob3o$177b3o5bo5bob3o$176bo12bo6bo$175b
2o4bob3o4b2ob2obo$177b2ob3obo4b2ob3obo$169b3o5bo5b2o6bo3bo$168bo12bo2b
o2bo3bo3b2o$167b2o4bob3o4b3obobo$169b2ob3obo6bo2bob2o2b2o$161b3o5bo5b
2o7b2ob3o$160bo12bo2bo2bo13bo$159b2o4bob3o4b3obobo6bo5bo$161b2ob3obo6b
o2bob2o4b2o4bobo$153b3o5bo5b2o7b2ob3o4b3o3bo$152bo12bo2bo2bo14bo2bo$
151b2o4bob3o4b3obobo6bo9b2o$153b2ob3obo6bo2bob2o4b2o9b2o$145b3o5bo5b2o
7b2ob3o4b3o9bobo$144bo12bo2bo2bo14bo2bo10b2o$143b2o4bob3o4b3obobo6bo9b
2o8bo2bo$145b2ob3obo6bo2bob2o4b2o9b2o11bo$137b3o5bo5b2o7b2ob3o4b3o9bob
o11bo$136bo12bo2bo2bo14bo2bo10b2o10bo$135b2o4bob3o4b3obobo6bo9b2o8bo2b
o4b2obo$137b2ob3obo6bo2bob2o4b2o9b2o11bo4b2o$129b3o5bo5b2o7b2ob3o4b3o
9bobo11bo2bobo$128bo12bo2bo2bo14bo2bo10b2o10bo5b2o$127b2o4bob3o4b3obob
o6bo9b2o8bo2bo4b2obo5b3o$129b2ob3obo6bo2bob2o4b2o9b2o11bo4b2o5b2o2bo$
121b3o5bo5b2o7b2ob3o4b3o9bobo11bo2bobo5b2o$120bo12bo2bo2bo14bo2bo10b2o
10bo5b2o3bobo19b3ob2o$119b2o4bob3o4b3obobo6bo9b2o8bo2bo4b2obo5b3o24b2o
4b2o$121b2ob3obo6bo2bob2o4b2o9b2o11bo4b2o5b2o2bo5b2o7b3o6bo3bobo2bo$
113b3o5bo5b2o7b2ob3o4b3o9bobo11bo2bobo5b2o8bo6bo4b3o2b3o$112bo12bo2bo
2bo14bo2bo10b2o10bo5b2o3bobo7bo4b3o5bob3o$111b2o4bob3o4b3obobo6bo9b2o
8bo2bo4b2obo5b3o13b2ob2ob2o2bob2o4bo$113b2ob3obo6bo2bob2o4b2o9b2o11bo
4b2o5b2o2bo5b2o4b2obo3bobobo6b2o$105b3o5bo5b2o7b2ob3o4b3o9bobo11bo2bob
o5b2o8bo3bo6bo$104bo12bo2bo2bo14bo2bo10b2o10bo5b2o3bobo7bo$103b2o4bob
3o4b3obobo6bo9b2o8bo2bo4b2obo5b3o13b2ob7o$105b2ob3obo6bo2bob2o4b2o9b2o
11bo4b2o5b2o2bo5b2o4b2obo4b2ob2o$97b3o5bo5b2o7b2ob3o4b3o9bobo11bo2bobo
5b2o8bo3bo6bo6b2o$96bo12bo2bo2bo14bo2bo10b2o10bo5b2o3bobo7bo17bo$95b2o
4bob3o4b3obobo6bo9b2o8bo2bo4b2obo5b3o13b2ob7o10bo$97b2ob3obo6bo2bob2o
4b2o9b2o11bo4b2o5b2o2bo5b2o4b2obo4b2ob2o8bo$89b3o5bo5b2o7b2ob3o4b3o9bo
bo11bo2bobo5b2o8bo3bo6bo6b2o$88bo12bo2bo2bo14bo2bo10b2o10bo5b2o3bobo7b
o17bo7b2o$87b2o4bob3o4b3obobo6bo9b2o8bo2bo4b2obo5b3o13b2ob7o10bo5bo2bo
$89b2ob3obo6bo2bob2o4b2o9b2o11bo4b2o5b2o2bo5b2o4b2obo4b2ob2o8bo6bo$81b
3o5bo5b2o7b2ob3o4b3o9bobo11bo2bobo5b2o8bo3bo6bo6b2o11bo$80bo12bo2bo2bo
14bo2bo10b2o10bo5b2o3bobo7bo17bo7b2o3bo$79b2o4bob3o4b3obobo6bo9b2o8bo
2bo4b2obo5b3o13b2ob7o10bo5bo2bo4bob2o$81b2ob3obo6bo2bob2o4b2o9b2o11bo
4b2o5b2o2bo5b2o4b2obo4b2ob2o8bo6bo9b2o$73b3o5bo5b2o7b2ob3o4b3o9bobo11b
o2bobo5b2o8bo3bo6bo6b2o11bo10bobo$72bo12bo2bo2bo14bo2bo10b2o10bo5b2o3b
obo7bo17bo7b2o3bo8b2o$71b2o4bob3o4b3obobo6bo9b2o8bo2bo4b2obo5b3o13b2ob
7o10bo5bo2bo4bob2o4b3o$73b2ob3obo6bo2bob2o4b2o9b2o11bo4b2o5b2o2bo5b2o
4b2obo4b2ob2o8bo6bo9b2o4bo2b2o$65b3o5bo5b2o7b2ob3o4b3o9bobo11bo2bobo5b
2o8bo3bo6bo6b2o11bo10bobo6b2o$64bo12bo2bo2bo14bo2bo10b2o10bo5b2o3bobo
7bo17bo7b2o3bo8b2o9b2o$63b2o4bob3o4b3obobo6bo9b2o8bo2bo4b2obo5b3o13b2o
b7o10bo5bo2bo4bob2o4b3o8bo$65b2ob3obo6bo2bob2o4b2o9b2o11bo4b2o5b2o2bo
5b2o4b2obo4b2ob2o8bo6bo9b2o4bo2b2o4b2obo$57b3o5bo5b2o7b2ob3o4b3o9bobo
11bo2bobo5b2o8bo3bo6bo6b2o11bo10bobo6b2o4bobobo$56bo12bo2bo2bo14bo2bo
10b2o10bo5b2o3bobo7bo17bo7b2o3bo8b2o9b2o3b2obobo$55b2o4bob3o4b3obobo6b
o9b2o8bo2bo4b2obo5b3o13b2ob7o10bo5bo2bo4bob2o4b3o8bo2bobobobo$57b2ob3o
bo6bo2bob2o4b2o9b2o11bo4b2o5b2o2bo5b2o4b2obo4b2ob2o8bo6bo9b2o4bo2b2o4b
2obobobo2b4o$49b3o5bo5b2o7b2ob3o4b3o9bobo11bo2bobo5b2o8bo3bo6bo6b2o11b
o10bobo6b2o4bobobobobo5bo$48bo12bo2bo2bo14bo2bo10b2o10bo5b2o3bobo7bo
17bo7b2o3bo8b2o9b2o3b2obobo2b5o2b2o$47b2o4bob3o4b3obobo6bo9b2o8bo2bo4b
2obo5b3o13b2ob7o10bo5bo2bo4bob2o4b3o8bo2bobobobo5bobobobo$49b2ob3obo6b
o2bob2o4b2o9b2o11bo4b2o5b2o2bo5b2o4b2obo4b2ob2o8bo6bo9b2o4bo2b2o4b2obo
bobo2b8obo2bo$41b3o5bo5b2o7b2ob3o4b3o9bobo11bo2bobo5b2o8bo3bo6bo6b2o
11bo10bobo6b2o4bobobobobo9bobo4b2o$40bo12bo2bo2bo14bo2bo10b2o10bo5b2o
3bobo7bo17bo7b2o3bo8b2o9b2o3b2obobo2b9o2bo2bobo3b2ob2o$39b2o4bob3o4b3o
bobo6bo9b2o8bo2bo4b2obo5b3o13b2ob7o10bo5bo2bo4bob2o4b3o8bo2bobobobo11b
obo4b4o3b2o$41b2ob3obo6bo2bob2o4b2o9b2o11bo4b2o5b2o2bo5b2o4b2obo4b2ob
2o8bo6bo9b2o4bo2b2o4b2obobobo2b14ob2o3b2o4bo2bo$33b3o5bo5b2o7b2ob3o4b
3o9bobo11bo2bobo5b2o8bo3bo6bo6b2o11bo10bobo6b2o4bobobobobo13bobobobo3b
2o$32bo12bo2bo2bo14bo2bo10b2o10bo5b2o3bobo7bo17bo7b2o3bo8b2o9b2o3b2obo
bo2b16obo2bo$31b2o4bob3o4b3obobo6bo9b2o8bo2bo4b2obo5b3o13b2ob7o10bo5bo
2bo4bob2o4b3o8bo2bobobobo17bobo4b2o$33b2ob3obo6bo2bob2o4b2o9b2o11bo4b
2o5b2o2bo5b2o4b2obo4b2ob2o8bo6bo9b2o4bo2b2o4b2obobobo2b17o2bo2bobo3b2o
b2o$7bo10b2o5b3o5bo5b2o7b2ob3o4b3o9bobo11bo2bobo5b2o8bo3bo6bo6b2o11bo
10bobo6b2o4bobobobobo19bobo4b4o3b2o$3b2obobo4bob2ob2o4bo12bo2bo2bo14bo
2bo10b2o10bo5b2o3bobo7bo17bo7b2o3bo8b2o9b2o3b2obobo2b22ob2o3b2o4bo2bo$
3b2o4bo2b2ob2o3bo2b2o4bob3o4b3obobo6bo9b2o8bo2bo4b2obo5b3o13b2ob7o10bo
5bo2bo4bob2o4b3o8bo2bobobobo21bobobobo3b2o$2bo2bo5bo3b2o8b2ob3obo6bo2b
ob2o4b2o9b2o11bo4b2o5b2o2bo5b2o4b2obo4b2ob2o8bo6bo9b2o4bo2b2o4b2obobob
o2b2ob21obo2bo$8b2obobo11bo5b2o7b2ob3o4b3o9bobo11bo2bobo5b2o8bo3bo6bo
6b2o11bo10bobo6b2o4bobobobobo25bobo4b2o$7bo3bobo15bo2bo2bo14bo2bo10b2o
10bo5b2o3bobo7bo17bo7b2o3bo8b2o9b2o3b2obobo2b25o2bo2bobo3b2ob2o$6b2o2b
o4bo5bob3o2b2ob2obobo6bo9b2o8bo2bo4b2obo5b3o13b2ob7o10bo5bo2bo4bob2o4b
3o8bo2bobobobo27bobo4b4o3b2o$4b2obob2o2bo6b3obo6bo2bob2o4b2o9b2o11bo4b
2o5b2o2bo5b2o4b2obo4b2ob2o8bo6bo9b2o4bo2b2o4b2obobobo2b30ob2o3b2o4bo2b
o$2b2obo3bobo4b2o5b2o5bob2ob3o4b3o9bobo11bo2bobo5b2o8bo3bo6bo6b2o11bo
10bobo6b2o4bobobobobo29bobobobo3b2o$bo3bo3bobo2b2obo3bo2bo2b2o13bo2bo
10b2o10bo5b2o3bobo7bo17bo7b2o3bo8b2o9b2o3b2obobo2b32obo2bo$2bobo3bo6bo
bo4b3obobo6bo9b2o8bo2bo4b2obo5b3o13b2ob7o10bo5bo2bo4bob2o4b3o8bo2bobob
obo33bobo4b2o$8bob2o6bo4bo2bob2o4b2o9b2o11bo4b2o5b2o2bo5b2o4b2obo4b2ob
2o8bo6bo9b2o4bo2b2o4b2obobobo2b33o2bo2bobo3b2ob2o$24b2ob3o4b3o9bobo11b
o2bobo5b2o8bo3bo6bo6b2o11bo10bobo6b2o4bobobobobo35bobo4b4o3b2o$34bo2bo
10b2o10bo5b2o3bobo7bo17bo7b2o3bo8b2o9b2o3b2obobo2b38ob2o3b2o4bo2bo$27b
o9b2o8bo2bo4b2obo5b3o13b2ob7o10bo5bo2bo4bob2o4b3o8bo2bobobobo37bobobob
o3b2o$26b2o9b2o11bo4b2o5b2o2bo5b2o4b2obo4b2ob2o8bo6bo9b2o4bo2b2o4b2obo
bobob41obo2bo$26b3o9bobo11bo2bobo5b2o8bo3bo6bo6b2o11bo10bobo6b2o4bobob
obobo41bobo4b2o$26bo2bo10b2o10bo5b2o3bobo7bo17bo7b2o3bo8b2o9b2o3b2obob
o2b41o2bo2bobo3b2ob2o$29b2o8bo2bo4b2obo5b3o13b2ob7o10bo5bo2bo4bob2o4b
3o8bo2bobobobo43bobo4b4o3b2o$29b2o11bo4b2o5b2o2bo5b2o4b2obo4b2ob2o8bo
6bo9b2o4bo2b2o4b2obobobo2b46ob2o3b2o4bo2bo$30bobo11bo2bobo5b2o8bo3bo6b
o6b2o11bo10bobo6b2o4bobobobobo45bobobobo3b2o$32b2o10bo5b2o3bobo7bo17bo
7b2o3bo8b2o9b2o3b2obobo2b48obo2bo$31bo2bo4b2obo5b3o13b2ob7o10bo5bo2bo
4bob2o4b3o8bo2bobobobo49bobo4b2o$34bo4b2o5b2o2bo5b2o4b2obo4b2ob2o8bo6b
o9b2o4bo2b2o4b2obobobo2b49o2bo2bobo3b2ob2o$36bo2bobo5b2o8bo3bo6bo6b2o
11bo10bobo6b2o4bobobobobo51bobo4b4o3b2o$36bo5b2o3bobo7bo17bo7b2o3bo8b
2o9b2o3b2obobo2b54ob2o3b2o4bo2bo$31b2obo5b3o13b2ob7o10bo5bo2bo4bob2o4b
3o8bo2bobobobo53bobobobo3b2o$31b2o5b2o2bo5b2o4b2obo4b2ob2o8bo6bo9b2o4b
o2b2o4b2obobobo2b56obo2bo$31bobo5b2o8bo3bo6bo6b2o11bo10bobo6b2o4bobobo
bobo57bobo4b2o$34b2o3bobo7bo17bo7b2o3bo8b2o9b2o3b2obobo2b57o2bo2bobo3b
2ob2o$32b3o13b2ob7o10bo5bo2bo4bob2o4b3o8bo2bobobobo59bobo4b4o3b2o$30b
2o2bo5b2o4b2obo4b2ob2o8bo6bo9b2o4bo2b2o4b2obobobo2b62ob2o3b2o4bo2bo$
31b2o8bo3bo6bo6b2o11bo10bobo6b2o4bobobobobo61bobobobo3b2o$31bobo7bo17b
o7b2o3bo8b2o9b2o3b2obobo2b64obo2bo$40b2ob7o10bo5bo2bo4bob2o4b3o8bo2bob
obobo65bobo4b2o$32b2o4b2obo4b2ob2o8bo6bo9b2o4bo2b2o4b2obobobo2b65o2bo
2bobo3b2ob2o$33bo3bo6bo6b2o11bo10bobo6b2o4bobobobobo67bobo4b4o3b2o$33b
o17bo7b2o3bo8b2o9b2o3b2obobo2b70ob2o3b2o4bo2bo$29b2ob2ob7o10bo5bo2bo4b
ob2o4b3o8bo2bobobobo69bobobobo3b2o$27bobobobo4b2ob2o8bo6bo9b2o4bo2b2o
4b2obobobo2b72obo2bo$21b3o2b2o8bo6b2o11bo10bobo6b2o4bobobobobo73bobo4b
2o$20bobob3ob2o13bo7b2o3bo8b2o9b2o3b2obobo2b73o2bo2bobo3b2ob2o$21bo4bo
b6o10bo5bo2bo4bob2o4b3o8bo2bobobobo75bobo4b4o3b2o$24b2o4b2ob2o8bo6bo9b
2o4bo2b2o4b2obobobo2b78ob2o3b2o4bo2bo$35b2o11bo10bobo6b2o4bobobobobo
77bobobobo3b2o$35bo7b2o3bo8b2o9b2o3b2obobo2b80obo2bo$36bo5bo2bo4bob2o
4b3o8bo2bobobobo81bobo4b2o$35bo6bo9b2o4bo2b2o4b2obobobo2b81o2bo2bobo3b
2ob2o$40bo10bobo6b2o4bobobobobo83bobo4b4o3b2o$35b2o3bo8b2o9b2o3b2obobo
2b86ob2o3b2o4bo2bo$34bo2bo4bob2o4b3o8bo2bobobobo85bobobobo3b2o$34bo9b
2o4bo2b2o4b2obobobo2b88obo2bo$32bo10bobo6b2o4bobobobobo89bobo4b2o$32bo
8b2o9b2o3b2obobo2b89o2bo2bobo3b2ob2o$34bob2o4b3o8bo2bobobobo91bobo4b4o
3b2o$36b2o4bo2b2o4b2obobobo2b94ob2o3b2o4bo2bo$35bobo6b2o4bobobobobo93b
obobobo3b2o$33b2o9b2o3b2obobo2b96obo2bo$34b3o8bo2bobobobo97bobo4b2o$
34bo2b2o4b2obobobo2b97o2bo2bobo3b2ob2o$36b2o4bobobobobo99bobo4b4o3b2o$
36b2o3b2obobo2b102ob2o3b2o4bo2bo$37bo2bobobobo101bobobobo3b2o$35b2obob
obo2b104obo2bo$34bobobobobo105bobo4b2o$33b2obobo2b105o2bo2bobo3b2ob2o$
32bobobobo107bobo4b4o3b2o$32bobo2b110ob2o3b2o4bo2bo$32bobo109bobobobo
3b2o$33b112obo2bo$144bobo4b2o$33b109o2bo2bobo3b2ob2o$32bo109bobo4b4o3b
2o$32b111ob2o3b2o4bo2bo$32bobo105bobobobo3b2o$29bo2bob107obo2bo$26b2o
4bobo105bobo4b2o$21b2ob2o3bobo2bo2b101o2bo2bobo3b2ob2o$21b2o3b4o4bobo
101bobo4b4o3b2o$20bo2bo4b2o3b2ob103ob2o3b2o4bo2bo$27b2o3bobobobo97bobo
bobo3b2o$33bo2bob99obo2bo$30b2o4bobo97bobo4b2o$25b2ob2o3bobo2bo2b93o2b
o2bobo3b2ob2o$25b2o3b4o4bobo93bobo4b4o3b2o$24bo2bo4b2o3b2ob95ob2o3b2o
4bo2bo$31b2o3bobobobo89bobobobo3b2o$37bo2bob91obo2bo$34b2o4bobo89bobo
4b2o$29b2ob2o3bobo2bo2b85o2bo2bobo3b2ob2o$29b2o3b4o4bobo85bobo4b4o3b2o
$28bo2bo4b2o3b2ob87ob2o3b2o4bo2bo$35b2o3bobobobo81bobobobo3b2o$41bo2bo
b83obo2bo$38b2o4bobo81bobo4b2o$33b2ob2o3bobo2bo2b77o2bo2bobo3b2ob2o$
33b2o3b4o4bobo77bobo4b4o3b2o$32bo2bo4b2o3b2ob79ob2o3b2o4bo2bo$39b2o3bo
bobobo73bobobobo3b2o$45bo2bob75obo2bo$42b2o4bobo73bobo4b2o$37b2ob2o3bo
bo2bo2b69o2bo2bobo3b2ob2o$37b2o3b4o4bobo69bobo4b4o3b2o$36bo2bo4b2o3b2o
b71ob2o3b2o4bo2bo$43b2o3bobobobo65bobobobo3b2o$49bo2bob67obo2bo$46b2o
4bobo65bobo4b2o$41b2ob2o3bobo2bo2b61o2bo2bobo3b2ob2o$41b2o3b4o4bobo61b
obo4b4o3b2o$40bo2bo4b2o3b2ob63ob2o3b2o4bo2bo$47b2o3bobobobo57bobobobo
3b2o$53bo2bob59obo2bo$50b2o4bobo57bobo4b2o$45b2ob2o3bobo2bo2b53o2bo2bo
bo3b2ob2o$45b2o3b4o4bobo53bobo4b4o3b2o$44bo2bo4b2o3b2ob55ob2o3b2o4bo2b
o$51b2o3bobobobo49bobobobo3b2o$57bo2bob51obo2bo$54b2o4bobo49bobo4b2o$
49b2ob2o3bobo2bo2b45o2bo2bobo3b2ob2o$49b2o3b4o4bobo45bobo4b4o3b2o$48bo
2bo4b2o3b2ob47ob2o3b2o4bo2bo$55b2o3bobobobo41bobobobo3b2o$61bo2bob43ob
o2bo$58b2o4bobo41bobo4b2o$53b2ob2o3bobo2bo2b37o2bo2bobo3b2ob2o$53b2o3b
4o4bobo37bobo4b4o3b2o$52bo2bo4b2o3b2ob39ob2o3b2o4bo2bo$59b2o3bobobobo
33bobobobo3b2o$65bo2bob35obo2bo$62b2o4bobo33bobo4b2o$57b2ob2o3bobo2bo
2b29o2bo2bobo3b2ob2o$57b2o3b4o4bobo29bobo4b4o3b2o$56bo2bo4b2o3b2ob31ob
2o3b2o4bo2bo$63b2o3bobobobo25bobobobo3b2o$69bo2bob27obo2bo$66b2o4bobo
25bobo4b2o$61b2ob2o3bobo2bo2b21o2bo2bobo3b2ob2o$61b2o3b4o4bobo21bobo4b
4o3b2o$60bo2bo4b2o3b2ob23ob2o3b2o4bo2bo$67b2o3bobobobo17bobobobo3b2o$
73bo2bob19obo2bo$70b2o4bobo17bobo4b2o$65b2ob2o3bobo2bo2b13o2bo2bobo3b
2ob2o$65b2o3b4o4bobo13bobo4b4o3b2o$64bo2bo4b2o3b2ob15ob2o3b2o4bo2bo$
71b2o3bobobobo9bobobobo3b2o$77bo2bob4o3b4obo2bo$74b2o4bobo9bobo4b2o$
69b2ob2o3bobo5bobobo5bobo3b2ob2o$69b2o3b4o5bo7bo5b4o3b2o$68bo2bo4b2o
19b2o4bo2bo$75b2o21b2o2$75b2o21b2o$67b2o7b2o19b2o7b2o$64b2obob2o5b2o
19b2o5b2obob2o$61b4o2bo4b2ob3o19b3ob2o4bo2b4o$60bo4bo6b2obo23bob2o6bo
4bo$61b2o7bo2bobo23bobo2bo7b2o!

[shuich01]

now report some results I've completed via qfind:

Which version of qfind are you using?

qfind 2.0.

[Sokwe]

now report some results I've completed via qfind:

Which version of qfind are you using?

qfind 2.0.

Ordinary qfind v2.0 cannot eliminate the possibility of a spaceship when gcd(period,translation) > 1. The version in this post can, but the searches generally take longer to complete and find a number of extraneous ships (typically, ships closely following each other).

[bibunsekibun]

c/7 Partial

Code: Select all

x = 14, y = 7, rule = B3/S23
6b2o$2o3bo2bo3b2o$o5b2o5bo$b2o8b2o$5b4o$3bo6bo$3bo6bo!

[wwei47]

Are you sure you want to use LSSS? I'm pretty sure it's still bugged.

It may be buggy, and it may miss things, but it can also finds things that nothing else can. From what I've seen, it's the fastest program for wide, high-speed ships.

If it returns negative, how would we check the result?

[Sokwe]

If it returns negative, how would we check the result?

If we wanted to prove that no such spaceships exist, we would need to use some other program. qfind needs (probably) over 200 GB of RAM to run a logical-width-12 search, so it effectively can't be used. I'm not sure, but I doubt that ikpx2 is fast enough to run a complete width-12 2c/7 search in a reasonable length of time. WLS is definitely too slow, and JLS is even slower.

Consider the symmetric width-23 (non-gutter) search. Even though LSSS sometimes misses things, it was still able to find the scholar, while I doubt that any other current search program could. Likewise, LSSS might be able to find a width-25 gutter ship where no other search program can.

[Sokwe]

I ran all of the 5c/11 logical-width-10 and 4c/11 logical-width-9 searches with qfind v2.1. No ships were found, and the longest partial results were similar to those posted by Andrew J. Wade here and here.

Code: Select all

x = 184, y = 31, rule = B3/S23
5b3o3b3o17b3o10b3o19bo5bo49bo20bo10bo15bo9bo$4bo3bobo3bo16bo2bo8bo2bo
18b3o3b3o47bobo18bobo8bobo12b2ob2o5b2ob2o$4b2o2bobo2b2o15bo2b2o8b2o2bo
16b2ob2ob2ob2o45b2ob2o16b2o2bo6bo2b2o11b2ob2o5b2ob2o$8bobo19b3o12b3o
15b2o9b2o65b2o2bo6bo2b2o$7bo3bo18b3o12b3o16bob3ob3obo45bo3bo44b2o9b2o$
32b3o8b3o18bo2b2ob2o2bo43b3o3b3o42b2o3bobo3b2o$5b2o5b2o22bo4bo22b2o7b
2o46bobo21b2o4b2o20b2ob2o$2b3obobobobob3o14bo4bo4bo4bo17b2o2bobo2b2o
43b2o5b2o14b2o2b3o2b3o2b2o15b2o3b2o$2bo13bo13bo16bo16b2o2bobo2b2o43b2o
5b2o14b2o2bobo2bobo2b2o11b3obo5bob3o$3b2obo5bob2o15bob3o6b3obo18b3o3b
3o45bo5bo16bo2b2o4b2o2bo12bobo9bobo$4bo3bobo3bo17bobo8bobo15b2o3bo5bo
3b2o38b2ob2o3b2ob2o14bob2ob2ob2obo12b4o9b4o$4bo9bo21b6o19b3o11b3o37bo
2b2o5b2o2bo13bo10bo12bobo11bobo$3bobob2ob2obobo16bobo2b4o2bobo19bobo3b
obo70b3o4b3o$2bobo9bobo14b3o3bo2bo3b3o14b3obo2bobo2bob3o38bo11bo15bo8b
o16b3o5b3o$o17bo12b2o4b4o4b2o15bo4bo3bo4bo39b2o2bo3bo2b2o15bo8bo19bo3b
o$o2bo11bo2bo11bo2bo2bob2obo2bo2bo15bo2bo5bo2bo40b2obobobobob2o16b8o
17b2obo3bob2o$3b2obo5bob2o14b3o3b2o2b2o3b3o15bo2bo5bo2bo41b2o7b2o16b3o
4b3o17bo2bobo2bo$2obo2bo5bo2bob2o14bo2b2o2b2o2bo17b3o9b3o40b5ob5o15b2o
3b2o3b2o13bo3b2o3b2o3bo$4bobo5bobo16b2o12b2o13b2o2bo9bo2b2o63b2o10b2o
11bobo11bobo$2obo11bob2o10bo18bo11bo4bo7bo4bo37b2o9b2o13bo3b6o3bo11bo
5bo3bo5bo$bob2o4bo4b2obo12b2ob2o8b2ob2o13b2o13b2o36b3obo7bob3o11bo2b2o
4b2o2bo16bobobobo$5bob2ob2obo19b2ob2o2b2ob2o17bo3b2o3b2o3bo40b3o5b3o
17b2o4b2o15bob2ob2ob2ob2obo$30bo3bo8bo3bo11b2o3bo9bo3b2o37bobo5bobo13b
o2bob2o2b2obo2bo10b2ob2ob2ob2ob2ob2o$29bo4b2obo2bob2o4bo10b2obobo3bobo
3bobob2o34b2o13b2o10bob3obo2bob3obo16b2ob2o$66b3ob3o69bo4bo2bo4bo13bob
o2bobo2bobo$116bo11bo18bo2bo18b2o2b2ob2o2b2o$115bobo9bobo13bobo2b2o2bo
bo13b2o3bo3bo3b2o$115bob2o7b2obo12bobo3b2o3bobo$114b2obob7obob2o10bo2b
obo4bobo2bo$116b2o2bobobo2b2o$120bobobo!

[MathAndCode]

I ran all of the 5c/11 logical-width-10 and 4c/11 logical-width-9 searches with qfind v2.1.

Are you planning to do a 3c/11 search next? I'd be interested to see how useful the 3c/11 forward movement mechanism that I mentioned a while back turns out to be.

[Sokwe]

I ran all of the 5c/11 logical-width-10 and 4c/11 logical-width-9 searches with qfind v2.1.

Are you planning to do a 3c/11 search next? I'd be interested to see how useful the 3c/11 forward movement mechanism that I mentioned a while back turns out to be.

No, I just started the c/8 width-21 gutter search, which will likely take months and may need to be split up like the width-19 odd search was.

[hotdogPi]

That's a really long time. I estimate that I've put in about 30 hours of running time into my program that found 6 full oscillators (31 R, 57 R, 70 century, 76 pi, 120 pi, 217 U-turner).

[wwei47]

There appear to be new minstrels in ikpx2_stdin. I did not find these.
https://catagolue.hatsya.com/object/xq6 ... d131/b3s23

Code: Select all

x = 62, y = 147, rule = B3/S23
5b2ob2o$10bo$3bo$2bo2b3o$3bob3obo$8b3o$4bobo$4b5o$4bo$5b3o$4b3o2$4b2o$5bo$5bo
2bo$5b2o2b2o$2bo6b2o$o5bo2bo$bo2b2ob2o$bo2b5o$4b6o2$7bo$7b3obo2$10bo3bo$14bo
3bo$11bobo3bo$13b3obo$14bob2o$13bo3bo$16b3o$13bo4bobo$16b2o2bo$14b4o2bo$15bo
3bo$15bo$15b2obo$17bo$11bobo3bo$12b3ob2o$18bo$15b3o$16bo2bo$16bobobo$17b2o3b
2o$24bo$21bo2bo$24bo$24bo$19b2o2bo$19b4o$20b2o$17b2o7b3o$17b5o4bo$26bobo$21b
7o$22bo4bo$22bo4bo$23b3obo$27bo$29bo$26bo2bo$26b2o2bo$29b2o$29b2obo$29bo3bo$
29bo3bo$29bo6bo$31b2o4bo$34b4o$33bo$32bo$33bo3bo$33bobo2bo$34b2o2bo$34bo2bo$
34b2obo$35bobo$32b2obobo$33bobo2bo$32b2ob2o3b2o$33bob4obo$33bo4b2o$32b3ob3o$
34b2obo$34bo3bob2o$34b2ob5o$35bo6b2o$36b3ob4o$36bo6bo$37b7o$38bo5bo$36bo5bobo
$36bo2b2ob2o$40bo$38bo3bo$39b3o$39bo2bo$40b2o$39bob2o$32bob2o3bo2bo$32bob2o3b
3ob2o$36bo6b2o$33bo3bobob3o2$33bo5b3o$34bobo5bo$35bo2bob2o$37b2o2bo2$40bo$39b
ob2o4bobo$37bobo7bobo$38b2o3bo3bobo$41bo2bo$42bo2b3o2bo$43bob2ob3o$45b2o3bo$
40bo3b2o$38b3o8bo$40b3o6bo$40b2obo5bo$40b2obo$43bob5o$43b6ob2o$42bo3bo3b2o$
44b2o2bobo$43b2obob2o$43bo2bo$44bo4bob2o$43b2o2bobobo$44bo4b2o$43bo2bob2o$44b
o9bo$48b2o2b2o$48b2obobobobobo$48bo2b2o3bo2b3o$51b2o2b2o3b2o$46b2o3bo2b3o3b2o
$51b5o4b2o$48b2obobo6bo$49b2o2b3ob3o$54b3obo$54b2o2b2o$56b3o$57bo!

https://catagolue.hatsya.com/object/xq6 ... 6443/b3s23

Code: Select all

x = 79, y = 203, rule = B3/S23
2b2o$2o$o3bo2$b3o2bo$2b2ob2o$3bo$2b3o$5bo$3b2o2$3bo2b2o$8bo$6bo2bo$8bo$3b4o$
4b2ob2obo$6b2ob2o$4b2o4bo$3bobo2b2o2$3b3o3b3o$9b2obo$8bo3bo$6b3o$6bo3b3o$13bo
$5bo4b3o$6b2o4bo$9bo$9bo4bo$6b3o5bo$10b2o$6b3ob2o3bo$11bo$13bobo$15b3o$16b2o
2$12bobo3bo$12bobo3b3o$13bobo4bo$18bo$15bo2bobo$14bob3o2bo$14bo6bo$14bo5bo$
20bo$17b3o2$19bo$17b2o$17b2o$17bo$16bo2bo$17bob2o$18bo6bo$25bo$22bo$18b2obob
2o$20b2o3b2o$20bo3b3o$20bobo$19b2ob2o$20bo3bo$23bo$20bo2bo$22bo$20b2o$21b2o$
20b2o3bo$21b2obobo$21b2obo$17bo3b3ob2o$16b2o2bo4bo$19bo$20bo4bo$21bo$23bo$23b
2o$24b3o2$29b2o$28b2ob4o$28b2obob2o$33b2o$31bo$32bob2o$34bo$30bo3bob2o$30bo2b
4o2$30b2o$31b3o$33b2o$29b2o2b2o$28b3ob3o$29b2o3bo$31b4o$34b2o$32bobo$33b3o3bo
$38bobo$39b3o$39b3o$39b2o$35bo2b2o$38bo$34bo3bo4bo$33bo8b2o$33bob2o4b2obo$34b
2o3b2o$37b5o2bo$40b2ob2o$38bobo2b2o$39b2o2b2o$40bobobo$44bo$42b5o$42b3obo$44b
o$44bo2bo$44b2o2b2o$44b3o$46bobo$53bo$48b6o$49b4o$48b2o$48b3o$49bob4o$49bob4o
$49bo3b2o$50b2ob2o$49bobob2o$48b2obob2o$51bobo$48b2o4bob2o$49bobo2bob2o2$48bo
3bo2bo$55bo$49bo7bo$50b5o$50b2o7bo$51b3o3bo2bo$52bo7bo$53b8o$54bobo3bo$53bobo
b2obo$55b2ob2o$56bob2o2$54b5o$55bo2bo$55bo$55bo2bo$50b2o2b2o$50bobo2b3o2bo$
49b4ob2o$58b3o$54b2o$56b2o$50b2o6bo$51b2ob5o$53b5o2$56b2o$54b2obo$55bo2bo3b2o
b2o$54b3o$58b4ob2o$58b2o3b2obo$64bob2o$63bo2bo$56bo3b3o2$58bo5b3o$55bo3bo$56b
2obo2b2obo$59bo5b2o$58b2o7bo$64bo$60bobobob2o$59bo2bob2o$59bo3b4o$60b2o2bo2b
2o$59b3o3bob2o$60b2obo$59b3o2b3o$63bo5bo$64b3ob2o$63bo3bob2obob2o$64b2o3b2o2b
3obo$63bo2bo2b2o2bo4bo$66bo8bo2bo$63b2o2bo4bo2bo$64b2obo4bobob2o$64b3ob2o3b3o
2$70bo4bo$71b2o2bo$72b3o!

https://catagolue.hatsya.com/object/xq6 ... y111/b3s23

Code: Select all

x = 71, y = 176, rule = B3/S23
65b3o$64bo2bo$61b2ob2obo$58b2o7b2o$58bo4bo5bo$56bo3b2obo5bo$56bobobo3bo5bo$
56bobobo3b2o4bo$61bo3bo3bo$58bobo2bobobobo$57b2obobo$53b2o2bo5b2o$53b5o$52bo
4bo2bo$55b2obobo$52b2o3b2ob2o$54b2o2bo$53bobob2o$51bob2o2bo$51bo5bob2o$52b3ob
4o$50bobo2bo$50bobo$50b2o$48bo2bo5b3o$48bo$48bo4b2o$50bo3bo4bo$52bobo2b3o$51b
3o2bo$50bo2bo2bo2bo$47bo2b2o$46bob3obo3b3o$46bobobo6b2o$53bo$49bo3bo$44b2obo$
47b4o$43bo3bo3bo$43b4ob3o$43b4obo$42b5ob5o$43bo5bo2bo$42b2o5b2obo$40b2obo4bo
3bo$44bo3bo$49b3o2$48b3o$47bo3bo$47b2obo$46b3o$45b2o4b3o$46b2obo2b2o$46bo3b2o
$49bo$45b8o$44bo2bo5bo$44bobo2bo$44b3o2b2obo$44b3o$41b2o$42bo4b2o$42bobo2bo$
41b2ob2o3b2o$42bobo3b2o$42bobo2b3o$42bo2b2obo$44bobobo$40bo3bo$42bo3b2o$44b4o
$42b3o$42b3o$42b2o$44b3o$40bo5bo$38b4o2b2o$38b3obo$41bo$39b3o$36bob2o2$34b2ob
2o$36b3o$36bo2$31b6o$31b5o2$29b2o5b2o$26b2o7b3o$26b2o2bo5bo2$29b2o$28b2ob2o$
31b2o$31b2o$30b3o$31b2o$30b3o$31b2o$26b3o2b2o$26b3o$25bobo$23bob3o$24bo$20bo
3bo$20b2obobo$20b5o4$19b2o$21bo$21b2o$21b3o$18b2o3bo$20b2o2bo$18b2obobo$18b2o
bo$19bob2o$16bo4bo$15bo2b3o$19bo$18bo$14b4o$14b3o3$11b3o$10bo3bo$15bo$14b2o$
12b2obo$9b3o3b2o$8bo6bo$11bo$11bo$8bo2bo$9bobo$10b2o2$9bo$7b2ob2o$7b2o$8bo3bo
$7b2o3bo$7b2o3bo$7b2ob3o$4bo$3bob5o$5bo2bobo$5bob4o$4b2ob2obo$7b2o$7b2o$6b2o$
4b2o$2bob2o$2bo2b3o$3bobobo$2b2o2bo$3bo$b4o$o4bo$o5bo$6bo$4b2o$4bo$2b2obo$3bo
bo$2bo3bo$5b3o$7bo$5b2o!