Talk:P57 bumper loop

This seems not notable, even though it is the smallest P57 oscillator, because it doesn't follow the 3-step procedure:

 1. "Did I create this pattern or this name?"
 2. "Have several other people besides me used this pattern or this name in their own patterns or postings?"
 If the answer to #1 is Yes and the answer to #2 is No, the article is unlikely to be notable.

Do you want me to propose deletion?

updated SKOP records?

In this edit, Freywa said that the smallest p57, p69, p81 and p129 oscillators are no longer based on p3 bumper loops now. Can someone confirm this? The two relevant pages, oscillator#Important_oscillators_by_period and Table_of_oscillators_by_period, seem to bear some discrepancy (e.g. see the p156 case), which I am not familiar with the status enough to resolve.

If yes, that could mean this article is no longer notable, just like p49 bumper loop, and we may need to do some cleanup and deletion. GUYTU6J (talk) 05:42, 30 May 2022 (UTC)